View Single Post
  #9  
Old Monday, February 15, 2010
fidamah fidamah is offline
38th CTP (CTG)
CSP Medal: Awarded to those Members of the forum who are serving CSP Officers - Issue reason: CE 2009 - Merit  579
 
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 95
Thanks: 90
Thanked 84 Times in 42 Posts
fidamah will become famous soon enough
Default

Quote:
Standard and performance level of candidates was extremely weak. Out of 3482, 92 percent candidate failed. 7 percent secured 40-49 marks, while 1 percent obtained 50-59 marks and one candidate got 60-69 marks. Candidates did no know how to write précis and also lacked comprehension of subject.
Very harsh comment on our poor understanding of precise writting.


Quote:
Essay:Another factor contributing negatively was a grossly misplaced reliance on preparatory help books with meaningless stocks phrases and irrelevant references, taking away originality from candidates.
This is a clear warning to those who forsefully and mistakenly try to write maximum number of quotations without even judging the worth and relevance of these quotations.


Quote:
Islamiat: Majority of candidates did not give any quotation or references. Even their answers were not supported with verses of the Holy Quran, Hadiths, and saying of jurists and scholars. However, some candidates had good knowledge, appreciable expression and justified their answers with a lot of verses of the Holy Quran, Hadiths, quotations, TV programmes, Internet/other latest material and stable bibliography.
So it is better to include maximum relevant quotations in Islamiat.



Quote:
Candidates were poor in punctuation, spelling/tenses with illegible writing.
English is checked in each paper.



Quote:
Public Administration:[/B] Majority of candidates who had only general knowledge of subject could not secure good marks. However, performance of some candidates was no doubt exemplary. Non availability of proper books, material and ample guidance of the teacher hampers their performance. Candidates must have proficiency in oral and written English to express their ideas properly. Quality of education must be improved in educational institutions.
Very good pointation. We are lacking these things and majority of us attempt this paper on our general knowledge basis.



Quote:
Sociology: However, a few took exam as a joke and failed miserably.
Very bad. Such students should be carefull in attempting CSS Exam.


Quote:
Statistics:[/B] Result was quite encouraging as 80 percent candidates passed in subject. 10 percent obtained more than 80% marks, while 14 percent got 70-80 marks. This performance showed dedication of candidates and their right choice of subject.
This is not the right commentary on statistics, FPSC may have commented on any other paper and mistakenly included in the statistics paper analysis. We don't have such bright examples infront of us to quote in this paper.
Reply With Quote