ASP or AC more powerful??

[Razzi]

Salam to all dea senior members plz tell here and comparison to these 2 posts
that which has more power, authority.

i mean plz tell me advantages and disadvantages of these 2 posts.

after that finally which is better and why??? state some reasons. plz
Waiting for your precious reply.

Regards,

[Abdul Rahim Chaudhry]

Originally Posted by Razzi

Salam to all dea senior members plz tell here and comparison to these 2 posts
that which has more power, authority.

i mean plz tell me advantages and disadvantages of these 2 posts.

after that finally which is better and why??? state some reasons. plz
Waiting for your precious reply.

Regards,

ASP is more powerful than AC....!!

After devolution plan AC has lost its power n charm of the post...its duty is only to collect revenue from urban sector...Ac hs not power of settlement ...!!

ASP enjoys more power ..he has power to arrest, to release the personon personal bond, vital power during investigation, incharge of its sub-division, police station under his control etc...he is only liable to his superiors SSP, DIG , CCPO IG wtever is situation!!

on the other hand AC is under DC,DCO, Commissioner/member board of revence, Secretary stablishment, ACS , Cheif Secretary etc

[Hamza Salick]

Originally Posted by Abdul Rahim Chaudhry

ASP is more powerful than AC....!!

After devolution plan AC has lost its power n charm of the post...its duty is only to collect revenue from urban sector...Ac hs not power of settlement ...!!

ASP enjoys more power ..he has power to arrest, to release the personon personal bond, vital power during investigation, incharge of its sub-division, police station under his control etc...he is only liable to his superiors SSP, DIG , CCPO IG wtever is situation!!

on the other hand AC is under DC,DCO, Commissioner/member board of revence, Secretary stablishment, ACS , Cheif Secretary etc

Janab Punjab me tw atleast DMG ko wohi powers wapis mil gai hain..Devoultion is going to binned soon..

[SadafRani]

police department to phr b DMG k under nai aya na, bus nominclature hi change howa hy from DDOR to AC

[SDM]

ASP is more powerful but AC is not merely a revenue collector. He's a vast assemblage of administrative powers .only his/her interference in Police Deptt is limited but other provincial govt departments are not immune from his/her intervention and by taking an advantage of his coordinative functions and of his position being the representative of govt/DCO in his/her Sub-Division, he exercises a lot of supervisory control on provincial govt departments. therefore both the ASP and AC are equal and equivalent in district administration. thus it becomes a matter of personal choice for an aspirant which group he wants to opt.

[camran]

I think the whole debate of the powers of AC and ASP needs to be done again after the restoration of ACs in Punjab, Balochistan and KP. Balochistan has infact restored DCs as well but Punjab and KP hasnt. Most the debate done (even in the DMG sub-forum) in context of DCO vs ASP.

[Saqib Shah]

Here is my answer both have their own places with a trademark of CSP...both are selected from a neck to neck competitive Exam..so no difference...both officers work is to help the nation..why you asking again and again for powers....

[AC Mehar]

Assistant Commisioner excercises more powers than assistant suprindent of police, being an AC i can assure you that ASPs reports to me in many situations, it depends wether the district level situation is being monitored by me or not. I see many people here misunderstood the devolution plan, let me clarify, the devolution plan have actually distributed some powerfuls but certainly not taken them away. The department of police or ASP only in minor situation of small theft/robbery conditions can make arrest/investigate on their on, while mostly they act upon orders recieved from DMG. Let me take you on a long drive of power corridors:

1- Power Magnitude: power magnitude of ASP is small and concentrated to law & Order only and that too in condition of "coordination" with DMG or any other concerned authority.

While power magnitude of AC is huge and massive,

e.g i can inspect any institution/company/organization/office/building within my authority limit which includes my respective tehsil. I can also demand transfer of ASP from government upon complaint or unsatisfactory performance. I can also observe and interfere in trades and businesses within my border. I can direct police department to investigate certain matter, i can direct ASP to arrest certain people, i can direct ASP to ban any public gathering which includes jalsa, marriage, friends standing and chatting etc I can also deliver jail sentence of upto 6 months but only taking into confidence the DC.

Basically Comissionerate system was introduced to be an all-rounder service to directly address the problem of people and deal immediately with power.

[yasirisrar]

Originally Posted by AC Mehar

Assistant Commisioner excercises more powers than assistant suprindent of police, being an AC i can assure you that ASPs reports to me in many situations, it depends wether the district level situation is being monitored by me or not. I see many people here misunderstood the devolution plan, let me clarify, the devolution plan have actually distributed some powerfuls but certainly not taken them away. The department of police or ASP only in minor situation of small theft/robbery conditions can make arrest/investigate on their on, while mostly they act upon orders recieved from DMG. Let me take you on a long drive of power corridors:

1- Power Magnitude: power magnitude of ASP is small and concentrated to law & Order only and that too in condition of "coordination" with DMG or any other concerned authority.

While power magnitude of AC is huge and massive,

e.g i can inspect any institution/company/organization/office/building within my authority limit which includes my respective tehsil. I can also demand transfer of ASP from government upon complaint or unsatisfactory performance. I can also observe and interfere in trades and businesses within my border. I can direct police department to investigate certain matter, i can direct ASP to arrest certain people, i can direct ASP to ban any public gathering which includes jalsa, marriage, friends standing and chatting etc I can also deliver jail sentence of upto 6 months but only taking into confidence the DC.

Basically Comissionerate system was introduced to be an all-rounder service to directly address the problem of people and deal immediately with power.

Thank you for the detailed reply. Can you please answer the following (Please)

1) You are from which common? (43rd or 44th)
2) Secondly, what are the duties of AC/DC during muharram or security situations?
3) Is it true that PAS has lost all power of the magistracy? if not, what sort of powers can they exercise?

Regards

[Sidewinder]

Originally Posted by yasirisrar

Thank you for the detailed reply. Can you please answer the following (Please)

1) You are from which common? (43rd or 44th)
2) Secondly, what are the duties of AC/DC during muharram or security situations?
3) Is it true that PAS has lost all power of the magistracy? if not, what sort of powers can they exercise?

Regards

I would like to know the answers to the above questions too.