Did I make a blunder ??

[hamzaakbar]

I attempted the first question which goes like:

Critically evaluate the foundations of Allama Iqbal's concept of muslim separation in the context of Indo-Pak subcontinent.

Outline:

Introduction
Hindi urdu controversy sowing the seeds for separatism.
Bengal partition and hindus fierce reaction towards it.
Backing out from the Khilafat movement.
Nehru report and depriving the muslims of their right to separate electorates.
Congress government and atrocities inflicted on the muslims i.e. three colored flag, conspiracy towards muslim provinces etc.
Conclusion: All these factors provided a solid foundation to realize the concept of Iqbal's separatism.


Now can someone please guide me whether i answered the question correctly or made a blunder ?? Seniors please need your input .... Thank you

[aristotlekhan]

These are the arguments in favour of the rise of Muslim nationalism.

[hamzaakbar]

means ill lose 20 marks now ?/

[Mubashar Khattak]

You had to simple critically evaluate the Two nations theory aka Ideology of Pakistan in the context of Allama Iqbal's different quotations. Though remembering quotations exactly is a tough task.

[étoile brillante]

Originally Posted by hamzaakbar

I attempted the first question which goes like:

Critically evaluate the foundations of Allama Iqbal's concept of muslim separation in the context of Indo-Pak subcontinent.

Outline:

Introduction
Hindi urdu controversy sowing the seeds for separatism.
Bengal partition and hindus fierce reaction towards it.
Backing out from the Khilafat movement.
Nehru report and depriving the muslims of their right to separate electorates.
Congress government and atrocities inflicted on the muslims i.e. three colored flag, conspiracy towards muslim provinces etc.
Conclusion: All these factors provided a solid foundation to realize the concept of Iqbal's separatism.


Now can someone please guide me whether i answered the question correctly or made a blunder ?? Seniors please need your input .... Thank you

No actually u r close cuz these are the incidents behind the genesis of that separate or two nation theory but yes it was about ideology u had to give both his concepts plus these incidents plus what he did to preach his concept but ok u will not lose 20 marks altogether.....

Sent from my HTC 10 evo using Tapatalk

[Anum Zara]

Originally Posted by hamzaakbar

I attempted the first question which goes like:

Critically evaluate the foundations of Allama Iqbal's concept of muslim separation in the context of Indo-Pak subcontinent.

Outline:

Introduction
Hindi urdu controversy sowing the seeds for separatism.
Bengal partition and hindus fierce reaction towards it.
Backing out from the Khilafat movement.
Nehru report and depriving the muslims of their right to separate electorates.
Congress government and atrocities inflicted on the muslims i.e. three colored flag, conspiracy towards muslim provinces etc.
Conclusion: All these factors provided a solid foundation to realize the concept of Iqbal's separatism.


Now can someone please guide me whether i answered the question correctly or made a blunder ?? Seniors please need your input .... Thank you

This question was not straight forward. Sayings of Allama Iqbal which support two nation theory were required. After mentioning them their critical analysis was required. You have only mentioned some factors that led to this concept in general but they have no link with Iqbal. Iqbal's address of Allahabad was very important in this regard. One has to utilize different saying to give analysis in this question. I did not attempt this question due to this very reason. I was able to recall only 2 of his addresses. So, chose another question.

[Muhammad Waqas Rafique]

Foundational basis of Iqbal's Muslims separatism:

1. Tawheed as a unifying factor for Muslims
2. Muslims have Distinct Religious Identity
3. Islam is not only a Religion but a complete way of life
4. Therefore, Muslims should form separate states under British or Indian union
(These are the some core points of his ALLAH ABAD address)

Evaluation of these core Principles:
1. Despite living for 1,000 years, Muslims maintained their distinct cultural Identity.
2. Despite living for centuries, Muslims and Hindus could not assimilate into each other
3. Tehreek-e-Khilafat movement; Depicts Iqbal's notion of Muslim Ummah concept
4. Quaid-e-Azam's 1940 speech of demand for a separate Muslim state augments Iqbal's notion of Muslim separatism (quoted Quiad e Azam's speech of asserting Muslim's separate identity)
5. Current Muslim's dilapidated conditions in India (killings on beef issue) justifies Iqbal's notion of Muslim's separatism.

I attempted this way.

[Anum Zara]

Originally Posted by Muhammad Waqas Rafique

Foundational basis of Iqbal's Muslims separatism:

1. Tawheed as a unifying factor for Muslims
2. Muslims have Distinct Religious Identity
3. Islam is not only a Religion but a complete way of life
4. Therefore, Muslims should form separate states under British or Indian union
(These are the some core points of his ALLAH ABAD address)

Evaluation of these core Principles:
1. Despite living for 1,000 years, Muslims maintained their distinct cultural Identity.
2. Despite living for centuries, Muslims and Hindus could not assimilate into each other
3. Tehreek-e-Khilafat movement; Depicts Iqbal's notion of Muslim Ummah concept
4. Quaid-e-Azam's 1940 speech of demand for a separate Muslim state augments Iqbal's notion of Muslim separatism (quoted Quiad e Azam's speech of asserting Muslim's separate identity)
5. Current Muslim's dilapidated conditions in India (killings on beef issue) justifies Iqbal's notion of Muslim's separatism.

I attempted this way.

This was also another way of solution. Nice attempt. Totally justified and to the point. Goodluck for final result and allocation.

[Muhammad Waqas Rafique]

Thank you!!

[usman sunny]

Man how you manage time