Wednesday, May 23, 2018
04:03 AM (GMT +5)

Go Back   CSS Forums > CSS Compulsory Subjects > Pakistan Affairs

Reply Share Thread: Submit Thread to Facebook Facebook     Submit Thread to Twitter Twitter     Submit Thread to Google+ Google+    
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old Friday, November 05, 2010
Muhammad Arif Shah's Avatar
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Peshawar
Posts: 120
Thanks: 72
Thanked 102 Times in 74 Posts
Muhammad Arif Shah will become famous soon enough
Question How to do a critical comparison in this case?

Make a critical comparison of the Nehru Report and the Quaid-e-Azam's Fourteen Points

should we write down both the nehru and Quaid's points?? its not making a sense then how to deal with this kind of questionz??
Reply With Quote
Old Friday, November 05, 2010
Senior Member
CSP Medal: Awarded to those Members of the forum who are serving CSP Officers - Issue reason: CE 2011 Merit 36
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 130
Thanks: 26
Thanked 37 Times in 29 Posts
muhammad imran sethi is on a distinguished road
Default comparision nehru report 14points

Simiilarities Political constitution in nature,Reforms in n.w.f.p,extension of democratic principles,Reforms in balochistan DISIMILARITIES,Nehru report,fed form of gov but not uniform degree of autonomy to fed units,14 points equal degree of autonomy,1/4muslim reprsentation in nehru vs1/3 in 14points,nehru ignored the issue of protection of minorities while jinnah placed much emphasis,Nehru discarded separate electrorate contrary to 14 points,nehru report Full constitution while 14points Minimum charter of muslim demands,Nehru limited acceptance of separation of sind from bombay jinnah clear cut demand,Nehru representating hindu point of view while jinnah championing minority rights,Nehru rejected nivel idea that Muslims should dominate at least in some parts of india while 14 oints contained this idea
Reply With Quote
Old Saturday, November 06, 2010
muhammad_essa's Avatar
Junior Member
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Mardan
Posts: 22
Thanks: 42
Thanked 6 Times in 4 Posts
muhammad_essa is on a distinguished road
Default comparision of nehru report jinnah 14 points

i want to add some insight into this Q..

a critical analysis demands not just the comparison with the nehru report but look into the background of the long standing demands of the muslim community.. as critics pointout that 14 points are just the brain-child of jinnah..

jinnah was also bluntly reminded at the all party muslim conference at delhi on jan, 1929. that he merely represented a small fraction of a community...
and congress is the only one representing all the communities..
nehro report came in this background...
congress had encroached over the rights of the muslims and denied all the previous commitments made in lucknow pact..
nehro report also came at a time when congress was dominated by extremist hindu mind-set..

in the light of such political situation, a critical analysis is:

14 points

1.the future constitution shall be federal...(delhi proposal jan 1929) legislatures and local bodies...effective representation of minorities... (congress accepted in Lcknow pact 1916... jinnah was refferring to bengal and punjab)

3. muslims shall be granted 1/3rd representation.. ( lucknow pact , act of 1919 and delhi proposal)

5. representation of communal groups.. by means of separate electorates... ( propounded by sir syed ahmad khan followed by ML leaders)

there is nothing new in 14 points with the exception of two or three twists in the points..
this was an elaboration of long standing demands of muslim community
it was also systematic draft of delhi muslim proposals
jinnah has given a it concrete shape.

Reply With Quote
Old Saturday, November 06, 2010
39th CTP (PSP)
CSP Medal: Awarded to those Members of the forum who are serving CSP Officers - Issue reason: CE 2010 - Merit 222
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 404
Thanks: 441
Thanked 489 Times in 237 Posts
floydian is a name known to allfloydian is a name known to allfloydian is a name known to allfloydian is a name known to allfloydian is a name known to allfloydian is a name known to all

Comparison of Jinnah's Fourteen Points & Nehru Report

1. Minority Question
The reccomendations in the Nehru Report were in the benefit og the Hindu majority. It rejected weightage for minorities because it thought that minority question is a British creation and would disappear as India attains the dominion status. While Jinnah viewed that minority question is real and based upon fundamental historical and political differences.

2. Separate Electorates
Nehru Report rejected the Muslim demand for separate electorates on the ground that all Indians belog to one nation. Whereas, Jinnah favored Muslim separate electorate because Muslims regarded themselves a separate nation.

3. Representation in the Central Legislature
Nehru Report reserved 1/4th seats for Muslims at the center and in provinces in which they are in minority so that minority must remain minority. Mr. Jinnah, on the other hand, favored that in the Central legislature Muslim representation shall not be less than 1/3rd.

4. Autonomy
Nehru favored that autonomy should remain at the center unlike Mr. Jinnah who proposed that uniform measure of autonomy shall be granted to all provinces.

5. Majority Government
Nehru demanded full independence and majority rule and refused to discuss the communal issue. While Mr. Jinnah refused to accept the majority government at the center.

These differences were really very wide and unbridgeable. The Nehru report and Quaid-e-Azam's Fourteen Points were just like a chasm political field which could not be filled. The reasonable and moderate demands contained in the Fourteen Points were rejected by the leaders of Congress. This further widened the gulf between the two communities. The political attitude of Muslims of India was shaped on the basis of Fourteen Points after 1930. As these points also contained the germs of the idea of Pakistan, they postulated the Muslims as a separate identity.

Police Service of Pakistan (PSP)
39th Common Training Program
Reply With Quote

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
All about Pakistan Muhammad Adnan General Knowledge, Quizzes, IQ Tests 80 Friday, April 28, 2017 07:06 PM
development of pakistan press since 1947 Janeeta Journalism & Mass Communication 14 Wednesday, November 11, 2015 11:03 AM
The Judicial System in Islam Daredevil39 Islamiat Notes 0 Friday, September 10, 2010 10:55 PM
The Reality of ‘Women Protection Bill’ chaleswanchor News & Articles 0 Thursday, February 01, 2007 04:11 AM

CSS Forum on Facebook Follow CSS Forum on Twitter

Disclaimer: All messages made available as part of this discussion group (including any bulletin boards and chat rooms) and any opinions, advice, statements or other information contained in any messages posted or transmitted by any third party are the responsibility of the author of that message and not of (unless is specifically identified as the author of the message). The fact that a particular message is posted on or transmitted using this web site does not mean that CSSForum has endorsed that message in any way or verified the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message. We encourage visitors to the forum to report any objectionable message in site feedback. This forum is not monitored 24/7.

Sponsors: ArgusVision   vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.