Hi.i am shabbir sethar(Roll no.1808). I have secured

Essay 40,
Comprehension 34,
EDS 74,
PA 45,
CA 53,
Islamiat 47,
political science 133,
Const. Law 55,
Islamic history 127,
Sindhi 80
Total 678 marks including marks in failed subject

salam

dear all i really appreciate those who failed in thier composition bcz no body knows where the justice is but i wanna to share one of the failed candidate DMC i dont know what i say abt it its needs u people comments ...

FEDERAL PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
COMPETITIVE EXAMINATION 2007
MARKS SHEET
:: Roll Number : 4251
:: Candidate Name : MUHAMMAD IMRAN KHAN
COMPULSORY SUBJECTS
Subject Total Marks
Essay 40
English 37
General Knowledge 189
General Knowledge (Everyday Science) 66
General Knowledge (Current Affairs) 63
General Knowledge (Pakistan Affairs) 60
Islamiat 64

OPTIONAL SUBJECTS
Subject Total Marks
Public Administration 62
Political Science 137
Paper A 77
Paper B 60
History of USA 75
Constitutional LAW 39
Pushto 85

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Total Marks FAILED IN COMPULSORY (691)

just three marks left him from being a CSP what will his feelings no body knows but GOD knos bettter

is this justice or ..................

regards

shahid khan mohmand

__________________
Mother – that was the bank where we deposited all our hurts and worries.

It is really sad 2 see DMCs of intelligent people who failed in only one subject.
in my psychological test, i was asked about the reforms in css. in my reply, i gave many proposals and one of them was that
candidates getting more than 55% in written( present criteria is 50% with all subjects pass) should b allowed 2 proceed further no matter in any subject they fail.
on MADAM's ( chief psychologist) querry, i justified my point by saying that we lose many good administrators every year simply coz they could not write one good essay on one day. if a candidate acquires more than 55% in written, we can safely assume that he/ she has enough potential 2 b a civil servant.
the whole panel seemed impressed. madam appreciated me on my proposal and said that i ll send it to the concerned deptt.
Anyhow, goood luck 2 all of u

__________________
Pray as everything depends on God, work as everything depends on you

Itz really heart-rendering to c the DMCs of such brilliant candidats.They deservd 2 be CSPz....I agree with ihs that the current Result is a big drain on the talentd manpower of the soil which, otherwise, was well-earned for bureaucratic slots.
There is an urgent need to overhaul the FPSC's system of appointments through CSS.All those candidats who cross 600 marks should be considered fit for administrativ dispositions in various capacities.If they fail in just one paper (SAY for example Composition paper), owing to whatevr reason,this does never mean tht they are lacking in required abilities.NO WAY.

__________________
Irfan Ali Samo
Police Service of Pakistan

I may disagree Irfi.........if relaxation is given in one paper.then the others may also asl for the relaxation in the papers in which they failed........u will find the fellows who passed the composition paper .but failed in the essay.........

So in this way ,if every one is given relaxation .this will not remain exam......u have to search another name for it .........

With regards .TAHIR

@marshal......

thank u very much for sharing ur mark sheet with us..........

I was worrying that just in shrt span of 4 months .will it be possible for me to do well in css............
But ur score of 450 in five months give me a new courage...........

I am appearing first time in CSS 2008......

thanks

If you are updated with world affairs,know inside out of current situation and if you think you have a great knowledge to put in the papers , then you should go for it.But if you just started reading material and you were not aware of it then i would recommend you to chill and relax.Prepare for 2009 and sure shot it rather than wasting your 1 pivotal attempt.

Regards.

WHJ

__________________
The only thing we have to fear is fear Itself !! :O

I agree with Irfi. I would suggest that the assessment criteria should be made less rigid in order to allow those candidates who secure more than 650 marks to appear in interview. This way some justice could be done to those deserving candidates, esp. those who are appearing in their last attempt.

__________________
Waheed Anwar Abro
Customs & Excise
37th CTP

In my view, precis, comprehension and expansion of ideas are considered important for the success of a candidate. The precis has an important place in the paper as it gives an idea abt a candidate's level of writing skills in English.

__________________
Waheed Anwar Abro
Customs & Excise
37th CTP

Here goes my marks sheet

Essay 55
English 40
General Knowledge 141
GK1 (Everyday Science) 65
GK2 (Current Affairs) 40
GK3 (Pakistan Affairs) 36
Islamiat 52

OPTIONAL SUBJECTS

Business Administration 55
Sociology 45
History of Pak and India 104
Paper A 55
Paper B 49
Musilm LAW and Juris 49
International Relations 42
Total Marks

FAILED IN AGGREGATE 583

dats pretty cool isn't it ...
u don't think so?? well let me clarify ..
i mean when i saw my result...i laughed like anything...i mean u people might think i m crazy or something..but no i m not..u wont believe da time i spent on preparing for da exam...brace urself....:P

it was 4 days...dat is 96 hrs...5760 minutes...345600 seconds...
i didn't even have a single book before dat...people think its unbelievable or i might b lying abt my prep time..but nope i ain't a liar...i dont know how i did it but i did...i didnt even chose my optionals myself n i had no intention of taking da exam but i took it just to c wat all da hoohaa was abt...plus...i had recently quit my job n had nothing better to do...so i know i didn't clear da exam..rite..but i didn't flunk in anything either...n its no mean feat i think ...
so all those who think CSS needs months of prep...well i dont really understand da logic behind it...anyways da papers weren't gravy i have to admit...n maybe i did well in 'em coz of my habit of reading newspapers n political journal quite regularly plus gr8 schooling throughout my life n regular discussions over hot issues with my father...i dont know really...but something did work for me...but not quite enuf apparently ...so all u guys..if i can (almost) do it without decent prep...all u guys with months of prep surely can...
give FPSC hell in 2008

hi.dr.m.saad here.my marks sheet reveels, assay 55,COMPOSITION 34,EDS 79,PAK AFFAIRS 46,CURRENT AFFAIRS 50,ISLAMIAT 79,ZOOLOGY 123,SOCIOLOGY 76,AMERICAN HISTORY 72,I.R.56,CONSTITUTIONAL LAW 56,TOTAL 726 INCLUDING failed subject.

hi.dr,m.saad here.my roll no.is 3101 as inquired by a coronor

is anybody going for litigation against marking of composition paper?it seems preposterous to have secured 726 marks,yet failing in one subject.such a stolidity on the part of FPSC is repremendable.