Final merit list of CE-2009 removed from FPSC website
 

[FONT=Calibri][SIZE=3]Why has FPSC removed our merit list from its website? Any idea?[/SIZE][/FONT]

yes it has been removed . Its really very strange , perhaps they are going to upload detail mark certificates . But even though they should not have done so .

It is learnt tht some changes are being made in to the final merit list.???? isn't it strange???

It is being heard that the result is being revised due to some error. One thing that i noted in the list was that it was not in the order of merit number, rather it was in the order of roll numbers. The final merit list of css exams is always in the order of merit number starting from 1,2,3,...

listen guys,there would be corrigendum comprising annulment of this result due to human error.some ppl in FPSC are suspended.new result order will come.

yet another speculation!
 

CSS'09 has been marred by a series of controversial news but speculative ones regarding different matters ranging from delay of exams, announcement of written result to the alteration in the final merit list. But these were mere speculations and were proved wrong consequently.

After the interviews there were two holidays. Then within two days they completed the whole process and displayed the result on the second day. How is it possible to add the marks of 900 people and then re.check the list, get it signed from the authorities
( chairman, etc). Then the list never looked like final merit list which is always in merit order; seniors will confirm this thing that final merit list is never in order of roll numbers. It was done in undue haste and then it has been removed from the website without assigning any reason.

@ shallowwater: Yes you are right brother...
@ Versatile Bhutto: Sir in my opinion the software error which you are mentioning is highly unlikely because its not an ordinary upload rather final announcement of css'09 result by FPSC. Or atleast one should not expect such a grave error from competent office of fpsc.
What I believe is that the result has been removed from the website for updating it with detailed marks breakup for the candidates.

@ Maha and above

Can u please tell us your source.what exactly have been told to u.Will there be a major change in the merit list n what about current merit order.


@serena

can u please elaborte ur point.

However if this be done this will give give a bad impression about the most fair institution of pakistan.


regards

My sources have confirmed that there was a blunder in ranking, ranking is going to be revised and almost three meetings were called today in FPSC on the same issue.

@ raz


Dear brother r u confident about it, n what else have u heard like will there will a change in the merit order of one province or all n whether it will be a major change of few merit orders or a major change.

Dear raz what about the suspension of the FPSC officials as said by an other member of the forum , have u also heard the same?


regards

final result has been prepared and its gona be announced tomorrow...... only a few minor changes have been done in the previous result with reshuffling of a few candidates from punjab.

merit order above 100 is same as before .....

[QUOTE=sphinx;193707]@ raz


Dear brother r u confident about it, n what else have u heard like will there will a change in the merit order of one province or all n whether it will be a major change of few merit orders or a major change.

regards[/QUOTE]



Blunder was not intentional and was not targeted. There are chances that a systemic impact may come i.e. due to general issue with the system there might be change in almost all the positions. It was an inefficiency but not a deliberate step.

with due respect,it was delibrate attempt to temper with the result.certain influential ppl are still trying.be get together.my brother is 19 grade officer in secrecy branch in FPSC.am allocated but selflessly i am trying to make u ppl understand the conspiracy.i'll be allocated again watsoever the result is.so make ur conscious clear.its not a blunder rather scandel.

@ serena


[QUOTE]am allocated but selflessly i am trying to make u ppl understand the conspiracy.i'll be allocated again watsoever the result is.so make ur conscious clear[/QUOTE]

what was ur position in the declared result n what will be ur position in the new result.


regards

I have been informed that the result has been withdrawn as gross anomalies have been observed e.g. persons who had failed in the written exam had been shown in the merit list. :excl:

@ MohsinMumtaz

Dear brother can u give any example of this fact


regards

Well I've shared what was told. But one thing is for sure that there is no smoke without fire. A meticulous comparison of old and new merit list would unveil what has happened. And also I wonder what official note would accompany the new merit list. It has created dents in the credibility of the most transparent institution opertaing in public recruiting sector!

@ serene Beauty
 

than you so very much for your information.. Can you please keep on updating us about the upcoming events. Please also tell me that how far are the chances that this result would be on merit.

@ Raz and All


There is a big dicotomy between the result declared on 26-oct 2009 and the statistics of the result is given below


The salient features of the Competitive Examination 2009 are as under:-

CANDIDATES APPLIED : 9057
CANDIDATES APPEARED : 5707
CANDIDATES PASSED :900
PASS PERCENTAGE :15.77
MALE CANDIDATES PASSED : 684
FEMALE CANDIDATES PASSED : 216

and the link to this information is this


[url]http://www.cssforum.com.pk/css-datesheets-results/css-result-datesheet/css-2009-exam/28185-css-2009-result.html[/url]


The result declared on 15-june 2010 has the following statistics .


Candidates Applied: 9056
Candidates Appeared: 5707 (63 %)
Candidates Passed (Written Part): 0905 (15.85 %)
Finally Qualified: 0895 (15.68 %)
Male Candidates: 0683 (76.31 %)
Female Candidates: 0212 (23.69 %)
Disabled Candidate: 0001

and the link is

[url]http://www.cssforum.com.pk/css-datesheets-results/css-result-datesheet/css-2009-exam/35105-ce-2009-final-result.html[/url]


Now the question is how can the written passed candidated increased from 900 to 905.


your views are invited.


regards

If we compare the results of these two links provided it is easily infered that one male candidate has failed and 4 female candidates have failed who had earlier qualified the written but failed in the final interview.If we add these candidates in 895 who have qualifeid it becomes 900 candidates as shown by the post of last island .However the post of 15 june says that 905 candidates have qualified where r the other 5 candidates who have qualified the written .

The other question is about the disable candidate .There was no mention of such candidate in the result declared on oct 26.

regards

@TO ALL,
use media gun.media is still under influence.ask ur friends in media to raise the issue.its not a minor thing but question of all's career.(i am facing problem with my internet therefore cud nt reply) .i'll update when i hear some concrete news.

@ raz

Dear brother to me it its a near bit impossible the reason being that it is the result of the CSS examination n not an ordinary document .I havent heard about this thing happening in any examintion .How can the FPSC be so careless .

regards

[QUOTE]Point to be noted. Recounting is possible. After recounting there might be addition of few candidates. [/QUOTE]@RAZ

I am already of the opinion that there is some gross stoch of fishy ambitions in this latest move of FPSC.
Please not that FPSC has come to rectify the error of adding 5 more candidates to the written qualifier list of 900 candidates making total 905 after a lapse of more than a year????
I construe this to be sheer and wilful neglect on part of FPSC.

Recounting after more than a year??? bla bla

This is the first precedent of its sort.This is CSS result.CSS-2008 was merit wise no contradictions at all.

Regards,

Sikander

Moreover, the start of the list declared my FPSC declares that the listing is in the form of Merit order.Whereas the list is not in merit order.

Please ponder.

sikander

[QUOTE=SikanderHayat007;193754]@RAZ

I am already of the opinion that there is some gross stoch of fishy ambitions in this latest move of FPSC.
Please not that FPSC has come to rectify the error of adding 5 more candidates to the written qualifier list of 900 candidates making total 905 after a lapse of more than a year????
I construe this to be sheer and wilful neglect on part of FPSC.

Recounting after more than a year??? bla bla

This is the first precedent of its sort.This is CSS result.CSS-2008 was merit wise no contradictions at all.

Regards,

Sikander[/QUOTE]

[COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana]Recounting is not done after a period of one year, rather there is possibility that recounting might have been done in its proper time but as there was no written result available at FPSC website in consolidated form so it remained un-noticed.[/FONT][/COLOR]

[QUOTE]Recounting is not done after a period of one year, rather there is possibility that recounting might have been done in its proper time but as there was no written result available at FPSC website in consolidated form so it remained un-noticed[/QUOTE]

What written result?What form of result?

The list came into notice just after sphinx raised the matter.Before it,there was no contradiction of what FPSC published on 26 oct 2009 and on 15 june 2010.

In plain words the two previous records of FPSC are clashing with each other.

Regards,

Sikander

Though it is confirmed now that the merit list is going to be revised. I dont think it will change the merit orders of all candidates. Few will be affected. I also heard from a friend(whose brother's close frnd is Assisstant Director in FPSc) that FPSC is also preparing how will it defend itself in courts as new merit order will take many students to courts.
If there really is a big tremor in the new result, it may cost Rana Bhagwan Das his job.

Dear fellow qualifiers'

1-As far as the inclusion of 5 more candidates in the wriiten result is concerned, applications of a few candidates were rejected before the announcement of the written result.So they appealed and 5 were declared successful after detailed scrutiny.(underage,overage issues etc)

2.There wont be major changes in the result.

News just-in
 

Guys i have talked to 4 different officials of FPSC and they have confirmed that there was a problem with computer. After talking to these folks i was refered to Director CSS office where PA to director(CSS) confirmed that there were some irregularities in the result and that the result is being scrutinized again.
Mere bar bar israr per unhon ne btaya k computer mein koi masla tha, main ne pocha k kaun sa masla and he just skipped that question and said, you will know the result at 4,5 pm in the evening.
Main ne pocha k sir merit order mein kitna farq paray ga, he said "Insha ALLAh koi khas nahi"

But...But....

FPSC has removed the list after two days of its announcement.They have not cancelled the merit list as there is no notification to such effect..If there was any mishap in the result, the first step on part of FPSC would have been cancellation of the result notification..

slaam to all,

i have been iformed that this issue will effect only merit order number 130 to 133. a deputy director fpsc told me just before. now ALLAH knows better the reality

regards

guys the result has been finalised
there is no change whatsoever in the result .... it will be made official shortly


source:FPSC

every1 is referring to fpsc as a source.but all of their talks contradict.
i dun know what joke is this.

At least this piece of information has not remained a rumor by now. It has been confirmed from FPSC secrecy that there was a problem in ranking. Result will be modified accordingly.

[QUOTE]It has been confirmed from FPSC secrecy [/QUOTE]

hahahaha.
is this fpsc secrecy?
how cud u access to the secrecy raz?

yes the result is under scrutiny.
but whatever is going on,
i think that we shud wait and see.
and then comment upon this mishap.

[B][COLOR="Blue"]ye b to ho sakta he k kuch logo k sath zyadati hoyi ho result men.usko theek karne k liye fpsc ne ye step uthaya he.
[/COLOR][/B]
[COLOR="Blue"][SIZE="3"]u all rest assured.fpsc entertains merit.whatever is done, it wl be in accordance with the rules and regulations and in a transparent manner.
[B]fpsc can't sacrifice its credibility so cheaply[/B].[/SIZE][/COLOR]

FPSC does not want to wash its dirty linen in the public.assistant director is saying there is not a major change whereas deputy secretary is saying there is a major change and all the employee of FPSC haven't gone to their house and they have spent the whole day of yesterday and night in order to correct the result.if there were minor change it wud not have taken more than 5 or 6 hours.problem is big therefore time consumption is more than 36 hours.lets see what happens...

[QUOTE=fromQAU;193832]hahahaha.
is this fpsc secrecy?
how cud u access to the secrecy raz?

yes the result is under scrutiny.
but whatever is going on,
i think that we shud wait and see.
and then comment upon this mishap.

ye b to ho sakta he k kuch logo k sath zyadati hoyi ho result men.usko theek karne k liye fpsc ne ye step uthaya he.

[COLOR=blue][SIZE=3]u all rest assured.fpsc entertains merit.whatever is done, it wl be in accordance with the rules and regulations and in a transparent manner.[/SIZE][/COLOR]
[SIZE=3][COLOR=blue][B]fpsc can't sacrifice its credibility so cheaply[/B].[/COLOR][/SIZE][/QUOTE]

Yes, you can imagine the level of secrecy, and level of secrecy breaker.:wait

there are so many things, as been happening for the first time for past some yrs in CSS' history.
in 2007, there were many candidates put to suitability , and a couple of english dailies gave it space for many days, "that such a controversial thing happened for the first time , so many candidates ready to go to courts, and the stuff" at the end its just as normal, nothing happened to that mass suitability decision by the fpsc.

actually our coutry has been on the edge of precipice and sensitive circumstances for past 6 decades, yet all seems normal.

media channels need something to feed on, . they have mistaken tyre bursts and Jet rumbles as bomb blasts . all their news are not serious.

though this is a serious matter to an extent definitely, and m also waiting for update, as one of my frends s been in state of constant tension. so dudes do let us know about the latest situation.
thankx

Whatever the case; one thing is for sure that there are going to be major changes in the result. I mean if there was only an issue about one or two merit numbers then FPSC would have corrected the mistake yesterday and notified it in the previous list. Now it has taken more than 30 hours and still nothing is clear. The news has become public and everybody has come to know about it; so this must be a major issue. Lets hope and pray for the best.

Thats really a strange situation... but everyone should hope for the best... No one efforts eill be useless... everything will be clear soon... I'll disclose the real news with an authentic source soon... Best of Luck to all...