Disaster in 2011 Result
 

Dear Aspirants,

According to the constitution side, every one has got right of speaking and can condemn the decisions by any commission conducting the competitive examinations.
To broach the past results and the mid night oil burnt by the aspirants, it is quite hurting that 2011 result is unacceptable and discouraging, what policy has been adopted by the FPSC is out of the approach of students.
those who were intended to fall into the list of the top ten, failed thrice and students having no such a back ground of the study passed.
From Larkana specially cases under consideration are of the below given students like Saleem Mugheri, Afzal Shaikh, Murtaza Jukhar, Imtiaz Bhutto and others who would be valued, opening their sore of first and second attempts.
Saleem Mugheri was considered amongst those who would secure the position on the federal level but this person is quite dejected now, entitled into the list of abortive students of 2011.
Please all the aspirants are advised to put their posts against the policy of the commission so as the next appearing students couldn't be part of such a result like 2011.

Thanks,

Zakir Hussain Samo
Larkana

[B][U]@ Zakir[/U][/B]

there are many examples which prove CSS is a game of chance or luck. like person is spend his years of hardwork from 9:am to 9:pm daily sitting in libraries never intended to do anything else and just prepare for CSS is amongst in failures and on the other hand a person prepare just three months with a 8 hours daily is succeded. this is not a story of 2011, but almost every year this happens to someone. The thing is that i dont disagree that person you mentioned is well versed. but this exam needs both
hardwork/luck

best of luck to everyone who failed. better luck next time. inculding [B]ME...[/B]

my commiserations to all who didnt make it this time,i agree that luck matters,or rather the intention of Allah for us,as we cant claim to be "intended" for anything as long as we believe that its He who controls our fate! but making the time period a person spends on studying criteria for passing is also wrong,everyone has different capability gifted by God! believe in hard work,if it didn't pay off this time it will come in handy for something else Allah intends for you

[QUOTE=zakirsamo;381755]Dear Aspirants,

According to the constitution side, every one has got right of speaking and can condemn the decisions by any commission conducting the competitive examinations.
To broach the past results and the mid night oil burnt by the aspirants, it is quite hurting that 2011 result is unacceptable and discouraging, what policy has been adopted by the FPSC is out of the approach of students.
those who were intended to fall into the list of the top ten, failed thrice and students having no such a back ground of the study passed.
From Larkana specially cases under consideration are of the below given students like Saleem Mugheri, Afzal Shaikh, Murtaza Jukhar, Imtiaz Bhutto and others who would be valued, opening their sore of first and second attempts.
Saleem Mugheri was considered amongst those who would secure the position on the federal level but this person is quite dejected now, entitled into the list of abortive students of 2011.
Please all the aspirants are advised to put their posts against the policy of the commission so as the next appearing students couldn't be part of such a result like 2011.

Thanks,

Zakir Hussain Samo
Larkana[/QUOTE]












I was not intending to give any befitting response to above notion.However looking at level of frustration encompassed in members frame of mind,Ithought to give a concise response.
Well Css examanition is after all a competitive exam,designed to provide pathway to suitable entrants to civil services of Pakistan.It is test of your analytical reasoning,English expression,general awareness,knowledge,nerves,confidence,dedication.If you lack in any of them you will be out of competition.Its not about three months or three years preparation,rather it depends on your suitability to be part of superior services of Pakistan.You may be very bright candidate but if you lack any of the required skils,you will face the failure.You should avoid sweeping statements about working of any institution untill you get to very bottom of anything,as Fpsc criteria has worked very well in producing competent civil servants in past and will also do so in future.
I have all sympathies for those who could not live upto their dreams.Please donot be offended with what I said as it was not intended to hurt anyone.Regards

i being qualifier of CSS 2011 believe that it is more of LUCK than Hard Work..... Off course majority who appear in CSS are well versed but what separates them at the end of the day is LUCK factor..

I dont believe in luck and I certainly don't believe that if someone was a topper he is bound to succeed in any examination or life. Forget Matric/FSc which is based on rote learning; Even those who top O Levels/A Levels end up in mediocre positions. My own cousin who was a topper in Matric and FSc failed CSS twice. My class mates who secured 3.8 CGPA+/4.00 in BBA and MBA ended up with much worse jobs relative to others. One guy still has no job even after 3 years.

In short, if you are street smart you will succeed in life but if you are book smart, all you can be proud of is that trophy in your cabinet which you earned in High school and nothing more

There is no fault of FPSC! Don't waste your time in useless discussions. please go and work hard and leave everything else to Allah Almighty including the Luck factor.

You should blame yourself for failure rather than FPSC. Work hard and goodluck.

[QUOTE=greenhorn;381781]You should blame yourself for failure rather than FPSC. Work hard and goodluck.[/QUOTE]

Dear, i knew many persons some of them are from forum they are having allocation in their prviously attempts but now they were declared failed in written portion.

This thing raises many quesitions on the credibilty of fpsc checking policy .

I personaly condemn the checking pattern of fpsc and i render my phyiscal and spirtual efforts in this regard so that some concrete steps must be initiated for the better of aspirants :cry:cry:cry:cry:cry.. even i am not of them who failed in written portion in ce2011


regards

[QUOTE=mani1;381778]I dont believe in luck and I certainly don't believe that if someone was a topper he is bound to succeed in any examination or life.
Forget Matric/FSc which is based on rote learning; Even those who top O Levels/A Levels end up in mediocre positions. My own cousin who was a topper in Matric and FSc failed CSS twice. My class mates who secured 3.8 CGPA+/4.00 in BBA and MBA ended up with much worse jobs relative to others. One guy still has no job even after 3 years.

In short, if you are street smart you will succeed in life but if you are book smart, all you can be proud of is that trophy in your cabinet which you earned in High school and nothing more[/QUOTE]
A person who qualifies such exam has right to eulogize fpsc n its policies but i can qoute many examples of the candidates who got good positions in past bt could nt qualify this yr.

Agree with Zakirsamo.First of all the members who are opposing the statement of the said guy tell the candidates, what about the link of fpsc which was about the DMCs, posted soon after the announcement of result on css forum and removed after the comments f some deserving aspirants????????
Was that a valid link r nt???
If that was the link then why was removed?????
Secondly the candidates have confirmed their scores via phone to fpsc office, all of them were failed in essay instead of this, they have scored more then 730.
I have met with an officer f fpsc before the results and asked him about the delay in announcement, he just blamed that checker of the english papers has denied to check the answer sheets.

[SIZE="3"]Hum Pakistanis ko kisi ne LUCK ka bata dia hai. There is no existence of luck at all. Ye sab baatain, Dil ko jhooti tassalli denay kay liay banai gaey hain. One who works hard surely succeeds. So you people Don't waste time on this useless discussion.[/SIZE]

[QUOTE=zt4096;433354][SIZE="3"]Hum Pakistanis ko kisi ne LUCK ka bata dia hai. There is no existence of luck at all. Ye sab baatain, Dil ko jhooti tassalli denay kay liay banai gaey hain. One who works hard surely succeeds. So you people Don't waste time on this useless discussion.[/SIZE][/QUOTE]
Luck Matters.

A person scoring 770 failed in essay is a prey of bad luck. Also strictness or leniency of examiner matters

Luck in another words is ''fate'' and we have faith on fate and destiny, how can we say that luck has no importance and hard work is surety of success? We have many examples around us, where competent people don't get what they deserve and on the other hand, some people excel everywhere with a little effort. No qualifier can claim, at least i can't that those who couldn't qualify written part were less competent than those who qualified. No doubt hard work gets its reward and we should rely on hard work instead of luck, but ignoring the factor of luck, particularly for css would be wrong.

Hard work is a pre-condition, then the luck factor really counts; not only in this exam but in all the endeavors of life! This is also a part of our belief being Muslims. No idea about other religions, but guess there would be same teachings too in this respect...

So, is wished 'best of luck' in everyday jobs..! If one secures 730+ marks in written but could not qualify essay or Islamiat for want of 2 or 5 marks; what it is?? Could not he secure more marks in the very same subjects by the same checker, or by another one?? And the same way, those who are qualified these crucial subjects with 40 marks, could not be allotted 38, 35 or less marks?? One can term it 'luck' or 'human error' what one feels appropriate (or believes!)..

Best of luck friends!

I believe in one thing !!

[B]"Jo Karta Hai, ALLAH (SWT) Karta Hai
Aur
Allah (SWT) Jo Karta Hai, SAHEE Karta Hai."[/B]


Please reflect on these lines and you'll understand the relationship of hard work, luck and success.

Regards

there is no real existence of LUCK in this world. C'mon guys. try to face the realities. ye Luck waghera kuch nhi hota. Everything has a reason. Every cause has an effect. Kisi examiner ki kisi kay saath koi zaati dushmani nhi hoti. Agar itni baat kaafi nhi ha to jo log Top positions laytay hain , kabhi un ka aur apna paper compare karain, phir pata chalay aap ko.

If someone studies smartly, i mean choosing subjects that give him more marks, keeping trends of questions in past papers and marks he will surely in the category of toppers. Smart Work with some hard work will change the luck

Only good luck exists if we work smart and hard, Faliure/bad luck is the result of dodgy way of studies

[QUOTE=ali36;381775]I was not intending to give any befitting response to above notion.However looking at level of frustration encompassed in members frame of mind,Ithought to give a concise response.
Well Css examanition is after all a competitive exam,designed to provide pathway to suitable entrants to civil services of Pakistan.It is test of your analytical reasoning,English expression,general awareness,knowledge,nerves,confidence,dedication.If you lack in any of them you will be out of competition.Its not about three months or three years preparation,rather it depends on your suitability to be part of superior services of Pakistan.You may be very bright candidate but if you lack any of the required skils,you will face the failure.You should avoid sweeping statements about working of any institution untill you get to very bottom of anything,as Fpsc criteria has worked very well in producing competent civil servants in past and will also do so in future.
I have all sympathies for those who could not live upto their dreams.Please donot be offended with what I said as it was not intended to hurt anyone.Regards[/QUOTE]

Dear alfaaz ka chunao to bara achha hai, would you please explain that a person who qualifies in a subject with 55% marks, next time fails in that specific subject by 3 to 4 marks. I am quite sure that you have a concept of reliability. Are you sure about the reliability of this exam??