Well, there are people who fail in their first attempt and pass in the second one. or even their third attempt. When failing in the first attempt doesnt stop candidates from making it in their second or third, then how does this make it an obligation that if somebody has PAS or FSP in their first attempts cant fail their next one?

The only best attempt is the one which takes you to CSA. There is no different opinion about it. May be the candidates failed to give their best... Perhaps they didnt attempt their papers the way they did it in their first attempts...

Instead of making these assumptions, we should all focus on our aim. If you will keep thinking that there is a bad, rotten system out there, ready to grab you just like that, then you will never make it. You know the rules for attempting essay paper plus all others. You have enough material to learn from, either provided by the successful ones, or the ones who couldnt make it. Make use of it and stop thinking negative. Or it will bog you down!

This is absolutely shocking... CSS is an excellent opportunity for the many... And such vivid issues of concern should be exterminated quickly ... There should be no factor of luck and the process should be highly competitive for the chosen few... We should all get together and press hard for some changes to occur in the process.... This issue should not be taken lightly

In my view, FPSC should take measures to prevent inadequate and unprofessional checking like the one seen in 2015 Essay exam.

You are all lost and hence shocked even after passing.until you won't give up living in fool paradise by favouring or believing word like luck.which is no where.in world you are not going no where.I heard chokers do choke but chokers becomes joke when choke.I would give fpsc a credit.to entertain me they done right the way you are complaining lol...

I don't comprehend: how a person who himself exists due to luck can deny luck?
It was a mere luck that of his father's X and Y Chromosomes, only one, X combined with his mother's X chromosome to bring him in existence; hence a male XX; and, similar explanation can be cited for a girl in which, merely by luck, and among thousands, only her father's Y joined with her mother's X.
If a river is flowing, it is flowing despite the denial of every single species in this world. So, if someone does not believe in Luck, don't believe! but, don't deny also! and if you he is a Muslim, his Imaan is incomplete without believing in good and bad Luck! (AAMANTU BILLAHE wa MALLAIKATE................)

Once you starting to understand ALLAH is bigger than luck and everything happens when ALLAH orders. KUN FAYAKUN.....you will forget the otherwise
....the reverse comment would be a product of a fool mind...

Aren't we doing something wrong? keeping secrets are demanded from us by ALLAH SWT but what are we doing? we are human beings and its in our nature that sometime we are prepared for a thing and sometimes not and bcoz of this weakness of ours ridiculing some one publicly like this is beyond my comprehension... if at all we were interested in giving example then we were supposed to hide the name of our sister... I know ALLAH SWT izat dete aur lete hn magar unke oper baht bura asar hoga if she came to know that she is being ridiculed on a public platform...kisis ka raaz hum rakhenge to qayamat me hamare raaz rakhe janege nahi to hum kahan jaenge aur kahan k rahenge agar hamare sare raaz zahir ho gae... i hope mene kisi ko hurt nahi kiya and if i did so then i apologize in advance

__________________
It is better to live in adversity than to serve in prosperity

Your comments are second of my thoughts and a cure of a mediocre minds around

Surely, Allah is above luck because Luck is what Allah desires!

Different strokes for different folks is justified but there is no accounting for taste that is unjustifiable.no more discussion from my side on it