what is actual history of Bagh-e-Fidak???????

salam,
bagh e fidak is one of the controversial topic in the history of Islam. this bagh was gifted to the prophet SAWW.as prophet saww was the owner of that bagh hazrat ALI(R.A) and HAZRAT FATIMA (R.A) claimed the ownership of the bagh after the death of the prophet SAWW because they were they real heirs of the prophet saww.
1) HAZRATABU BAKA (R.A) AND HAZRAT UMER (R.A) Refused to gave them.
(q k wo kehtay thay k, 1) nabi ka koi waris nahe hota 2) and rasool ullah ne waseat ki the k wisal k bad mera sub kuch baitul mal me jama kara daina)
controversy
1) sunny consider the pious caliph right according to shariah
2) shiit are saying the it was a discriminatory decision of the first 2 caliph.
(k jis ko ALLAH K RASOOL NE BABUL ILM KAHA, KYA UNKA DEMAND karna GHALAT THA??? )
BAGH E FIDAK K FAISALAY K BAD HAZRAT FATIMA RA NE DONO KHULAFA SE NARAZGI IKHTIYAR KI THE

WALLAHU AALAM
regard

__________________
Nurture your mind with great thoughts, for you will never go any higher than you think.

Hazrat Fatima ne narazgi ka izhar nahi kiya tha. Wo khamosh ho gai theen aur us khamoshi ka matlab razamandi tha jisay shites ne apnay andaz main interpret kiya aur us khamoshi to narazgi ka naam diya.

__________________
The Me you have always known, the Me that's a stranger still.

salaam
thanx members for ur reply but
hazrat Fatima(R.A) died after the six months of the death of Holy Prophet (peace be upon him).
Hazrat Umer(R.A) was no more capliph at that time.
so Hazrat Fatima's conversation would be with Hazrat Abu Bakar Siddiq(R.A) not with Hazrat Umar(R.A). IS It?

__________________
kainaat

Yes the conversation was with Hazrat Abu Bakar (R.A) only.

__________________
The Me you have always known, the Me that's a stranger still.

[QUOTE=Last Island;255730]Yes the conversation was with Hazrat Abu Bakar (R.A) only.[/QUO


Thanks 4 replying

__________________
kainaat

mujy harangi ati hay un logo pay jo ye kahty hain k hazrat Ali(r.a) aur hazrat fatima (r.a) bagh-e-fidak naa milny per naraz ho gae they

bahla app logoo ko wo waqya yad nahi jab ak gazway k baad kuch gulam bi muslimanoo k qabzy mai ae, tu hazart ali(r.a) nay hazrat fatima(r.a) ko behja
app (saw) k pass kio k hazrat fatima(r.a) ky hathoo mai chalay per gae thay
chaki pisty pisty, magar nabi akram(saw) nay khadam deny say inkar kar dia,
kia hazrat fatima(r.a) aur hazrat ali(r.a) nabi akram (saw) say naraz ho gae they? nahi bilkul nahi

app duno ki zindagi ka maqsad mallo dulat hassal karna tha he nahi

hazart ali (r.a) nay kabi apni darwazy say kisi mangny waly ko khali hath nahi lotaya, hazart fatima(r.a) ka taqwa apni masal app tha

bahla ye azeem loog(allah un say razi ho) itni si baat per naaraz ho sakty hai?
kabi nahi

khuda k liay iss bat per ummat k dermiyan ikhtilaf tu na daliay,

__________________
The world suffers a lot, not because of the violence of bad people, but because of the silence of good people.

In my very personal opinion, it should be pronounced as "Fadak" instead of "Fidak" (I have asked many scholars and Ulema for confirmation and they corrected me about the right word)

No offense to anyone and I am not here to participate in this debate. I just considered it my duty to pass on this information.

Jazak Allah

__________________
You cannot hate a person when you know him

since u know a lot,wud u plz tell us how did Hazrat Fatima (r.a) die n who attended her funeral ???

Please some one explain Waqia e Kirtas ( issue of pen and paper as narrated in Bukari)?

__________________
" None are more hopelessly enslaved, than those, who falsely believe that they are free"
Goethe