|
Share Thread: Facebook Twitter Google+ |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Short History of the Saracens for Umayyad's Notes
I am following History of the Saracens particularly to cover the topic on Umayyad. I am finding it that Syed Ali has used quite strong words to highlight the acts of most of the Caliphs of Umayyad.
For instance, he writes: Muawiyah's character and the circumstances which ensured his success are thus summed up by English writer Osborn, whose view, Syed Ameer Ali expresses, on this point at least are free from prejudice. "Astute, unscrupulous, and pitiless, the first Caliph of the Umayyads shrank from no crime necessary to secure his position. Murder was his accustomed mode of removing a formidable opponent ....." Keeping in view this you think it is alright to follow History of Saracens by Syed Ameer Ali to prepare the notes? Because the other books/authors haven't used strong words despite the obviousness of the events. Response from specially those who have secured good marks in the subject would be helpful |
#2
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
As for the particular extract, I think Syed Ameer Ali has just tried to agree with the statement of Osborn and it was not merely a statment made my Ameer Ali himself .. However, If you read different texts you'd find some writers in strong favour of Muawiya and others bashing him .. But at least one thing was commonly stated, that he was very clever and could do what he wanted to by any means .. Some writers took it as a very positive trait of his personality and the others ridiculed him for it .. My understanding, after having read some books on Islamic History is that at least Muawiya's part of History is uncertain .. So I decided not to attempt it in exams .. Ameer Ali's 'Spirit of Islam' and 'History of Saracens' are excellent books .. However, you need to follow another text too for better understanding .. Best of Luck .. Regards ..
__________________
You Have To Keep Breaking Your Heart Until It Opens .. !! Rumi .. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
If I am copying a whole para from a book, is it okay or the paraphrasing should be done?
Shiites don't regard Muawiyah. You think calling Muawiyah an apt/clever ruler is equal to avoiding the controversial subject? Even at one point Syed Ameer Ali writes: "On the whole Muawiyah's rule was prosperous and peaceful at home and successful abroad." What if the examiner is a Shiite? This thought just popped in my mind .. Last edited by Shooting Star; Monday, June 04, 2012 at 02:33 AM. Reason: merged |
#4
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
'Clever' in some parts of the world is seen as a positive trait and in others as a negative one .. It is best used in context and I think in Muawiya's context it amounts to a negative one, as a string of allegations is attached to it .. I do not personally think that a professional Shiite or Sunni examiner would do injustice on basis of bias reasoning, however, a bleak possibility remains .. And on the last part, as I wrote earlier .. To me Muawiya's part of history is uncertain and I thought that I could not do justice to the topic in exam and hence skipped it .. You can decide what's best in your interest .. If you have further queries feel free to ask .. Regards ..
__________________
You Have To Keep Breaking Your Heart Until It Opens .. !! Rumi .. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
How long should the answer be of a 20 marks question? Any estimate, like how many words? I understand that quality of the answer rather than quantity is of essence. But still ...
|
#6
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
Regards ..
__________________
You Have To Keep Breaking Your Heart Until It Opens .. !! Rumi .. |
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Stunner For This Useful Post: | ||
naveed khan (Monday, July 30, 2012), usman qureshi (Saturday, January 12, 2013) |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
How to make Good Notes? | rose_pak | Tips and Experience Sharing | 7 | Thursday, October 17, 2019 10:30 AM |
Repeated Questions of Forestry | Last Island | Forestry | 0 | Saturday, December 03, 2011 07:24 PM |
What is History, Lessons we learn from it, benefits of its study. | Xeric | History of Pakistan & India | 0 | Tuesday, May 19, 2009 08:23 PM |
The Philosophical Interpretation Of History | Emaan | Philosophy | 1 | Tuesday, July 26, 2005 03:50 AM |