Discuss : urdu paper-I & II 2010

[soomro04]

Dear Aspirants lets discuss the questions that appeared in the papers of Urdu in C.S.S 2010, as it would be helpful to those who will be appearing in next attempt.


Regards,
Soomro

[Shah Sheh]

In Urdu paper II , i was suprised to see questions on MEERA G, MANTO and NAZIR AKBAR, i mean why he added these question in this paper , it simply means there is no outline of syllabus. even i did it very well but its unfair.There are hundrads of prominant urdu poets and writers, is he thinking we are student of Abdul haq or Sir syed

One mcq......Who was was first novalist of urdu?? how could you give right answer of this as according to some Nazir is first novalist, while for some its Sharar

[osman86.ali]

1st novel was KHATT e TAQDIR by molvi karimuddin in 1862.....!
nazir's mirat ul aroos was published in 1869....!it is now established fact....u cn consult dr. jamil jalbi....bhai i 200% agree wd u that paper2 was nt a standard paper......

[Maha Khan]

i find urdu pap 1 a bit difficult...there was a question to write about "Muzhamti Adab",,this question was very lengthy,but it was just for 5 marks..what one should do??im not satisfied with my urdu pap 1...urdu pap 2 was differnt than urdu pap 2009,however i attempted it well cz i had full commamd over Ghalib&Faiz'poetry...i didnot know from where they had given us the Paragraphif anybody knows about it,then plz tell me..
Remember me in ur Prayers

[javed_iqbal7863]

Paragraph was, from Sirat ul Nabi by Shibli Numani

[Maha Khan]

Originally Posted by javed_iqbal7863

Paragraph was, from Sirat ul Nabi by Shibli Numani

thnx...i attempted the 1st one...was it 4rm SIRAt-ul-Nabi by Shibli??i dnt think so it would be 4rm tht book..cz it was about some historical books??what do u say?

[Shah Sheh]

Yes 1st paragraph was from Sirat ul Nabi by Shibli Numani.

[javed_iqbal7863]

Definitely Paragraph was from sirat ul nabi by shibly naumani. Actually in the paragraph shibly was telling that he had collected the informations from qu'ran majeed and hadith sharif and most of the historians had collected inflammations about Haztrat Muhammad(PBUH)from unauthorized sources among those historians most were from Europe.

[osman86.ali]

2nd paragraph was from UDAAS NASLAIN

[waseem ahmad awan]

DEAR ASPIRANTS i appeared in css 2010 and took the paper of urdu,so i m interested in sharing my experience with all those who r willing to opt urdu as optional subject......it is often narrated to the students tht urdu is high scoring subject,the claim is appropriate nd true bt only till 2008...the situation had a dramatic twist in 2009,coz the paper setter had changed the mcqs trend....the candidates who secured towering marks in urdu in the past before 2009 heavily relied on mcqs,and its true tht mcqs were too simple in 05,06,07,08..bt the mcqs of 09,10 were not more than a night mare.....so i advise u all not to opt urdu rather go fr ny other subject....u may contradict my argument bt do read the past papers before final verdict....