The two latest toppers.
2009 Topper --- a repeater.
2011 Topper --- a repeater
A matter of.......??????
It is up to you guys to decide and comment.
I am talking in General. So, plz no harsh comments.

The way I think the objection can be properly handled is as follows:
Certain %age of the total marks should be deducted from the candidates who appear for the second time. Higher %age of marks should be deducted if he is taking the exam for the 3rd time.
It is also a rule for the students aspiring to take admission in any medical college.
The older you get, the higher %age of marks are deducted from your marks obtained.
Similarly, a CSP who is to aspire for a better group should be deducted certain %age of marks from.
This is how I think the FPSC can make amend.
It will give some heart to the novice aspirants.
Regards,
Ainuddin Kibzai.

Sad to see that more and more incompetent competitors are getting into CSS.

__________________
The Me you have always known, the Me that's a stranger still.

Brother.
With all due veneration you purely deserve on the basis of seniority and your contribution, I just want to quote that I have only voiced the concern of numerous CSS aspirants in the form of this thread of mine.
Aap baray hai, senior hain, qabil-e-izzat hain.
I would really expect a more soothing and calm reply from a senior instead of the words such as " ncompetent competitors ".
Seniors like you have a very crucial role to play for the tyro aspirants.
Strongly expect a benign and soft reply with finesse.
regards.
A non-Commoner.

__________________
Form is temporary, but class is permanent.

well they scarified much more than a new comer.
the thing is when you fail for the first time you need a lot of courage to appear again. Will you if u can kindly share there subjects because may be they learned from there mistakes , opt better subjects , they learned the tricks of the trade .
We shouldn't label them incompetent. incompetent is one who fail and not try again.
and the term novice aspirants is an answer in its self. we fail we learn and we try again that's how it is. and how it should be.

well i think it is not wrong to appear twice or even thrice if you are unable to do it first time or failed to get allocation in your aspired group, the CSP officers are like normal aspirants who have qualified the exam but didn't get their dream shot, so big deal???

You have got me wrong. I havent labelled them (the toppers and repeaters) incompetent. Incompetent are those who want to succeed in the absence of competitors. Its a competitive examination and every eligible candidate has the right to compete.

__________________
The Me you have always known, the Me that's a stranger still.

Thomas Edison had invented Light Bulb after hundreds (don't remember the exact figure) of failed attempts. When he was asked, he said;

"I have not failed 100 (for instance) times, but I have discovered 100 ways which do not work."

I think the repeaters gain more experience and like Edison they discover different ways which do not work hence they avoid those ways in their successive attempts and register a remarkable success.


Regards,

__________________
Verily, His command, when He intends a thing, is only that He says "Be!" - and it is! (Al-Quran)

There is nothing wrong in being a repeater. After all, to repeat is not as easy a task as considered by some of my friends in above posts. Believe me it is as difficult as starting from scratch. The older you get, the more stamina you loose. It's a competition folks, which means we have to compete within the lines drawn by FPSC.

I would congratulate the topper, less for being a topper and more for being committed and dedicated to improve his group.

__________________
Ahmad Shakeel Babar
.
"If you really want to achieve something the whole universe conspires for you to get your dream realized."

i strongly disagree with the point that the marks of repeater should be deducted....it is a competitive exam and the one who gets the highest score should be on the top,the person who repeats have better preparation so they should be given what they deserve.The best man should be on the top

sometimes failure leads you to the success...so i think there would be no more concerns about repeaters...nakami kamiyabi ke zamanat hai as already said by redmax

__________________
"When God Want to Humiliate A Person then He Almighty Deprive him of Knowledge" Hazrat Ali A.S