CSS Forums

CSS Forums (http://www.cssforum.com.pk/)
-   Discussion (http://www.cssforum.com.pk/general/discussion/)
-   -   Myth of India as greate power (http://www.cssforum.com.pk/general/discussion/97948-myth-india-greate-power.html)

asma mehvish Wednesday, December 24, 2014 11:30 AM

Myth of India as greate power
 
[COLOR="Red"][SIZE="7"][/SIZE][/COLOR][COLOR="Black"][/COLOR] numerous analyst has hailed India as next power of the world . which is your idea about this:blink

Qurratulain Aslam Wednesday, December 24, 2014 11:55 AM

India needs to go a long way to become a power.
They have to first nip the crime against women and children, corruption and inequality in the distribution of resources from its bud. Then they have chances of getting into power.
World powers have first severely degraded the social evils, India must do that first.

RAO RAMEEZ Friday, December 26, 2014 09:39 AM

[QUOTE=asma mehvish;791927][COLOR="Red"][SIZE="7"][/SIZE][/COLOR][COLOR="Black"][/COLOR] numerous analyst has hailed India as next power of the world . which is your idea about this:blink[/QUOTE]

Yes, May be next to China.
Henry Kessinger had predicted it 20 years before.
We can't deny the facts. Nationalism in India will drive her to this point. Modi have also entered the game to boost the economy. US India relations are getting much strong and even China sees India as his next rival in economic game. Due to it's large population, India is bringing reforms which are based on long sighted benefits.

But the residuary powers, no doubt will reside in Muslim states. So, while establishing your world order, you will have to consider these people as well, until or unless you wage another war against Iran, Syria and Pakistan and deprive them from their sovereignty anew.

Wars on Religion and Nationalism are over in the Post-Modern world.

Next wars in "Post American World" will be on "Identities".

The states who kept them aloof from these wars, will remain stable.
It's the time for Muslim states to reckon the fact before hand and should put air, that our survival do not depend on the survival of identities, but on survival of Economy, boundaries and sovereignty.
All our religious factions, who are trying to impose their set of identities should be quietened by going to any means, via war or strategy to keep away this proxy war, coming to us.

Hassan02 Friday, December 26, 2014 08:29 PM

[QUOTE=asma mehvish;791927][COLOR="Red"][SIZE="7"][/SIZE][/COLOR][COLOR="Black"][/COLOR] numerous analyst has hailed India as next power of the world . which is your idea about this:blink[/QUOTE]

The very concept of "great powers" will disappear with time. First of all, the superpower era is at an end. America can no longer continue to yield the power it does now with the growth of China and the European Union. One reason for this is shifting of wealth and another is the inability of major powers to enforce their will by force. Books can be written about this, I'm just giving you a summary.

Second, as the world progresses and the lines between the developing and developed countries began to blur, the influence of powers such as China and America will decrease further.

So a hundred years later, India will just be another large country in the overall community of nations, not a "Power" in the present sense of the word.

sikander kalhoro Friday, December 26, 2014 10:44 PM

[QUOTE=Hassan02;792484]The very concept of "great powers" will disappear with time. First of all, the superpower era is at an end. America can no longer continue to yield the power it does now with the growth of China and the European Union. One reason for this is shifting of wealth and another is the inability of major powers to enforce their will by force. Books can be written about this, I'm just giving you a summary.

Second, as the world progresses and the lines between the developing and developed countries began to blur, the influence of powers such as China and America will decrease further.

So a hundred years later, India will just be another large country in the overall community of nations, not a "Power" in the present sense of the word.[/QUOTE]

Keeping in view your point of view, i would somehow disagree. The influence of China has just been augmented, it could not be decreased until some powerful economic country see eye to eye with her. US policies failed to render their shots of being a super power. India could never rise in the name of nationalism, Russia is already lingering behind sanctions, but her military power is intact. On the whole, China would triumph in 2015 as the sole super powers, not as capitalist, nor as rival, but a friendly super power country.

Hassan02 Friday, December 26, 2014 11:41 PM

[QUOTE=sikander kalhoro;792507]Keeping in view your point of view, i would somehow disagree. The influence of China has just been augmented, it could not be decreased until some powerful economic country see eye to eye with her. US policies failed to render their shots of being a super power. India could never rise in the name of nationalism, Russia is already lingering behind sanctions, but her military power is intact. On the whole, China would triumph in 2015 as the sole super powers, not as capitalist, nor as rival, but a friendly super power country.[/QUOTE]

I'm of the view that the entire concept of a super power is slowly fading away. I'm talking about the next 100 years, not the next 10 or 20. By its very definition, a superpower should be able to exert influence over other, do you agree? Superpowers such as China and America are slowly losing this ability to exert influence. It is already almost impossible to exert inflection through military strength and will become more difficult in the future. Economically too, the influence of individual countries will decrease as 1) the economy becomes more globalized and 2) poor countries move out of the cycle of poverty. Remember that by 2050, many currently underdeveloped countries will have joined the list of developed, prosperous countries. Therefore, the ability of any one country, including China and America to exert influence over the rest of the world will diminish.

On a side note, the dominant culture of the future will still be Western. People can come up with all kinds of weird reasons for that but the BASIC, CORE reason is that it promotes gender equality. Muslim culture by comparison is centered around segregation of the sexes, something that is not acceptable to a majority of the population.

If you take a look at China, you will see this in action. Already the Chinese are becoming increasingly Westernized.

Breaking Bad Saturday, December 27, 2014 09:35 PM

Indian democracy has lasted 60 years.its india's plus point.still it needs to address the rural poverty and corruption.india needs to increase its per capita income because still average Europeans and Americans are earning more than Indians.

sadafazam Wednesday, December 31, 2014 04:21 PM

[QUOTE=asma mehvish;791927][COLOR="Red"][SIZE="7"][/SIZE][/COLOR][COLOR="Black"][/COLOR] numerous analyst has hailed India as next power of the world . which is your idea about this:blink[/QUOTE]

power is moving back to the status of being multipolar. There would no longer be single super power as we see in unipolar order. Reason for this shift is increasing interdependency of numerous nations. In that scenario india would no doubt be a force to be reckoned with, owing to the large population contained in it. As for now, Modi is doing blunders in name of nationalism and india would have to suffer the consequences in coming future. As i always say, modi is proving to be india's ziaulhaq.

India can play a role in regional prosperity and thus become a strong influence only if it starts realizing its strengths and responsibilities in saarc. Poverty, corruption, women persecution, caste system(yes still its there), unemployment are some of the major problems of india which are still not done away with. Mending this all would take plenty of time, especially in the case when the will to do so is found wanting.

Luck Monday, January 26, 2015 02:30 PM

Obama Visit India not Pakistan Why.................?

sikander kalhoro Monday, January 26, 2015 11:42 PM

[QUOTE=Luck;799800]Obama Visit India not Pakistan Why.................?[/QUOTE]

Because we didn't invite him yet :dd

Introuvable fella Tuesday, January 27, 2015 12:22 PM

India as a great power
 
No one can deny the fact that India will rise up as a great power. In spite of that she has a many problems to solve but her way seems smooth. Second largest population, boosting economy, BRICs, SCO observer, and above all support in region and by world powers. It is pity on us that we are still denying the change in regional situation.

MIR A GHAFFAR Tuesday, January 27, 2015 11:32 PM

India can be included in emerging powers because of india market and economy,but being an asian country india has many similar issue as pakistan and other asian countries are going through. India has no different issues like corruption,illiteracy,poverty and over population,so we can say india is far from becoming super power in coming decade. An other plus point of india is that they,as a nation,have great vision and vigour to become a king of asia which we lack. They have got a direction but we are still at crossroads,are't we??

Ali Raza Abbass Wednesday, January 28, 2015 06:22 PM

Well one can not turn down the fact the India is progressing but labeling it a new super would be quite an immature and inflated idea. We should not forget that this region already has two regional powers (Russia and China) contesting for supremacy and hegemony. They are a lot more sophisticated in their global countenance than India. And in this situation of power play in the region, it is unlikely that these regional powers would concede any substantial breathing space to India to emerge as another powerful player in South Asia.

Arsalanthahim Thursday, February 05, 2015 05:51 PM

India cannot become great power but may stumble in the way of China through out the south Asian countries: where China is wanting Pearls Of Strings. No doubt India can surpass all its SAARC members countries and many others; one should not live in fool's paradise, primarily Pakistan to compete with the Indian economy in such circumstances. We cannot stand on the equal footing with India in terms of business and trade beside militarily, which is not the necessity of the time, unless we overcome the terrorism and energy crisis we scarcely make the parity situation in the Indo-Pak state.


01:50 AM (GMT +5)

vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.