Replies that are obscure and incomprehensive, I do not accept.

I am sorry but you can't learn untill you accept you know nothing... reply is always comprehensive you just don't look deeply..
For you to be clear about my first reply about books i will give you an example. I don't know you who you are neither have much interaction on this forum still by just the reply i quoted let me tell you a bit about you..
You are kind but show you are not you think life went hard on you so you live in imaginations you have a created whole of your own for your own self to not look the realities that hurts..
Now that is what book can't teach thats why i asked you to read the book special for you. But you didnot ask what that book is even you donot know .. hope my replies make sense now.
Delete this reply after you read it cause that is not intended to discuss further will come to the topic tomorrow..
Regards

__________________
Its not you till you don't have your own philosophy.

Your last post doesn't make sense at all. Since you don't know me, avoid being judgmental.

__________________
The Me you have always known, the Me that's a stranger still.

well guy, i believe miss last island has rightly said,
nafs i ammara is discussed at the very beginning of 13th para,
nafs ul lwama at the very beginning of surah al imran and nafs i mutmainna in surah fajr and i would love to quote:
"YA AYYATO HAN NAFS UL MUTMAINNA, IRJI I RUBBIKI RADYA MARDYA, FAD KHUL LI FI IBBADI WAD KHULI JANNATI"
I wish, we have read the quran with such an optimism.please, respected members iss ka tarjuma zrror prhna.and do share on this forum about what you have understood from this ayat as well.Literally i believe its a golden asset for muslims.
What about luck and fate factor
Once i asked the question of luck factor from my islamic studies teacher and he responded that being as a muslim, we believe on luck and he demonstrated me with the quote of Sheikh Abdul Qadir jilani saying, when a person asked the same question from Radi allah tala anhu he replied:
Allah has blessed the man the two feet, so that if one leads to fate than the next step guide him to his effort as well.

Regarding nafs, i read the quote of Maz bin jabbal(RA),
who said that nafs is like mother breast feeding, which nourishes the child, but at the certain stage its compulsive for both to shun this activity,othewise it is harmful to the child as well as the mother.
same is the case with nafs.
P.S.Miss last island, i agree with you at all points, and mashallah you have very sound knowledge of islam.

i hope it work and if you have any confusion fee free to ask me annd if you find any incorrection, correct me as well.

Secondly, I would love to mention, surah yousaf, which quran says "ahsan ul kassas"that demonstrate you people, how, nafs I ammara was transformed into nafs I mutmainna.I.e. case of zulakha vs Joseph.
Inshallah, it will work.

Back to topic as said...

What is nafs ...? Leave the types define nufs..

__________________
Its not you till you don't have your own philosophy.

Mr. Taimur, you seem to put all debris on human's self (nafs), which implies that shaitaan is all innocent. If this is the case then what is the purpose of shaitan and please elaborate how come only nafs is responsible for all the sins humans commit?

My basic question is still unanswered on this platform but one video on youtube passed through my view which cleared my confusion. I'll search it again and will share the link

Yours sincerely

Well, watch this 22 mins video and your confusion will be hopefully cleared https://youtu.be/XEcocSZnk1g

Yours sincerely

Well watch this 4 mins video and hopefully it will beautifully clear the difference that whether its nafs or shaitan which is behind the committing of the sin.

https://youtu.be/VJ8_0fFt0JE

Yours sincerely

__________________
Try to be a rainbow in someone's cloud - Maya Angelou

well, what i gotta something out of the video now is that nafs i ammara and nafs i lawwama is a main culprit in doing bad deeds which is lodged by delvils and their nefarious attitude, right or otty to wrong side???
Now, my question to you, how you can define nafs i mutmainna keeping this thing in mind that devils and shatani waswah may be influencing the momin as well?
please, suggest me good book as well.

Ursala, can you please rephrase your question and more clearly? I had difficulty in understanding it.

Yours sincerely

__________________
Try to be a rainbow in someone's cloud - Maya Angelou

My question is agar ye sach k nafs our shatan mill kr hmain burrayy k taraf le jate Han to kya ye each nhy k ye momin ko bhy seedhe raste se deviate krte Han.To who kesse defend krtae Han?
Because, in surahfajr Allah says
Ya ayato Han nafs ul mutmainnah irjii rbiki radya mardya, fad khulyy fe ibadi .......
Now, how this nafs I mutmainna is achieved? I thought its a secret that makes distinction b/w a Muslim and a mom in.
And for ordinary person like me, how to overcome both the devils, because mjhe sab se zyada problem namaz main hoty he.For example, year I'm getting tired so I will delay that eventually lead to wastage of time.Bad me I repent on my own self.
Jab k momin is not of such kind, he/she is punctual and never compromise on his/her duty or obligation.
I hope you have now understood.

Your fate is written yes, does not mean that you will act according to what is written. There is a fine line between acting according to what is scripted and writing what will be acted.

Allah has given us free will, with guidance in the form of Prophets and Holy Books, to choose from the good and evil. It is now at the discretion of the human to do as he wills but even after granting the human freedom to choose Allah knows what the individual will do. This is the concept of Islam regarding Allah being all-knowledgeable as the Quran in Ayat-ul-Kursi says " Ya'lamo ma Baynaho Aideehim wa ma Khalfahum". Hence, given the freedom to choose, our creator knows what we are going to do.

Thereby, the fine line between acting according to the script and writing what will be acted. He knows what will be acted by virtue of his knowledge and the Loh-e-Mehfooz has it written.

It is just like a teacher, based on his limited knowledge, knows how the weak student is ought to perform in the test and a studious pupil's result, even before the test is taken. But the weak student still tries, in his own right to do whatever he can in the test(freewill), so does the studios one.

In a similar vein, we are the students, the world is a test and Allah is the teacher but One Who does not have limited knowledge neither limited means rather knowledge itself is His creation. Although the human teacher, due to his limited knowledge, cannot foresee a weak student overcoming his weakness and passing the test but Allah even knows the twists and turns that will accompany His student in the test He has given.

I hope I was successful in easing your troubled mind