CSS officers' arrogance’?

[Marjah]

CANDIDATES who appear and pass the Central Superior Services examinations are considered the most talented and intelligent lot of the country.

However, I would like to draw the attention of the authorities concerned towards the arrogant and humiliating behaviour of CSS officers towards their subordinates. It is beyond comprehension why these civil servants treat their own staff like personal, domestic servants. For example, a CSS officer can call his subordinate anywhere, anytime without any specific reason.

Can anyone concerned with this issue shed some light why these CSS officers are trained in the academy to behave in such a harsh manner?

A.J. BALOCH
Nawabshah

Ill-treatment I WOULD like to highlight rude behaviour and arrogance of civil servants towards the common man. The ill-treatment of people by these civil servants has become a daily routine.

To give an example, I recently went to the office of district accounts officer but returned after being treated rudely.

Civil servants should always keep in their minds that they have been given the position to serve the common man rather than act like masters.

GHULAM HUSSAIN SHAH
Shikarpur

CSS officers

I AGREE with the letters ‘CSS officers’ arrogance’ (Feb 22) written by A.J. Baloch and Ghulam Hussain Shah.

Such CSS officers serve the public as if they are the masters of the public. We have forgotten that our great Quaid advised the civil establishment to be honest and serve the nation.

The bureaucracy stems from the elite class of our society. Our CSP officers treat the public as their subordinate staff without realising that they are just there to serve the nation.

NASEER AHMAD ABBASI
Bahawalpur

CSS officers

[Ahmed_2007_Cool]

When you're one person and a hundred different people want something from you, it'd be very difficult for you to please everyone. Someone or the other would eventually feel as though you're arrogant or there's something else wrong with you.

[mukt]

It is common knowledge and an open secret why 95% of people go for CSS Examination. The main reasons are power & money. The remaining 4% which are not corrupt are killed or resigns within first few years of honest service and only 1% is left behind in service who are not only honest but also living and in service.

This is a bitter truth, accept it or not ..

[striver]

Hazrat Ali (as) said:
Power and money donot change a person, but only brings his inside to the surface

CSPs are no angels. They are the people from our society and just like our society they too are corrupt and power hungry. Ofcourse, to change them, we have to change the society first.

[aristocrat of heart]

The most factual thing is that, we insist them to adopt such exercise/behavior by performing unintellectual, selfish attitude and also by praising their xtraordinary glories in order to ascertain our specific goals.
Another aspect is to please the people by catering their fake demands is cock and bull story for an officer as people doesn't ever
acquiesce with Allah.

[sajidnuml]

Originally Posted by Marjah

CANDIDATES who appear and pass the Central Superior Services examinations are considered the most talented and intelligent lot of the country.

However, I would like to draw the attention of the authorities concerned towards the arrogant and humiliating behaviour of CSS officers towards their subordinates. It is beyond comprehension why these civil servants treat their own staff like personal, domestic servants. For example, a CSS officer can call his subordinate anywhere, anytime without any specific reason.

Can anyone concerned with this issue shed some light why these CSS officers are trained in the academy to behave in such a harsh manner?

A.J. BALOCH
Nawabshah

Ill-treatment I WOULD like to highlight rude behaviour and arrogance of civil servants towards the common man. The ill-treatment of people by these civil servants has become a daily routine.

To give an example, I recently went to the office of district accounts officer but returned after being treated rudely.

Civil servants should always keep in their minds that they have been given the position to serve the common man rather than act like masters.

GHULAM HUSSAIN SHAH
Shikarpur

CSS officers

I AGREE with the letters ‘CSS officers’ arrogance’ (Feb 22) written by A.J. Baloch and Ghulam Hussain Shah.

Such CSS officers serve the public as if they are the masters of the public. We have forgotten that our great Quaid advised the civil establishment to be honest and serve the nation.

The bureaucracy stems from the elite class of our society. Our CSP officers treat the public as their subordinate staff without realising that they are just there to serve the nation.

NASEER AHMAD ABBASI
Bahawalpur

CSS officers

I want to share with you people a personal experience that I had today when i was studying in the Defence Library Karachi. There are cabins in the library, they are very comfortable, one can get one by making entry at the reception however late comers do not get it. with this view I go to library early.

After making entry for the cabin and leaving my white pages at the cabin i went to newspaper section. After two hours when i returned I found some books lying there. I went to the receptionists and told her that i booked the cabin early but now it is occupied by an other student whose books are lying there however he is not there. after confirming it from the entry book that the cabin was booked by me she told me to sit there and if somebody comes he should be refered to the reception.

I went there and resumed my studies. after two hours somebody moved my shoulder rudely when i looked back I found a very angry man asking me: who permitted you to sit here. I humbly replied that sir I booked it in the morning. i told him to contact the receptionist.

However he was bent on picking a quarel he said since I was absent for 2 hours his is exclusive right to occupy it, I told him that by the same rule I had the exclusive right since he was also absent from there for two hours. He said he was out for nimaz and lunch, I said i was there in the newspaper section when he occupied my cabin.

To tell you the truth I knew the person he was 2010 written quailifier. I was introduced to him by an other friend however he was looking at me as if he never knew me.

Anyway at first I thought of leaving the cabin out of courtesy since After half an hour I was to move back to home but when I found him behaving rudely ignoring the fact that I was known to him, likewise he was not honouring the principle he himself mentioned: that absence for two hours render a person without a cabin. seeing his double standard statements I told him to accompany me to the receptionist. The receptionist told him that the cabin belongs to me and he should sit somewhere else.

he returned to the cabin alongwith me to collect his books however I told him to sit there since i was leaving in half an hour. I went to an other chair.

Anyway He thanked me for that.

Now you can assume that if he qualifies interview; I pray for him, How wil he behave with the common citizens.

Do you expect that he is gonna serve you, the poor, nasty citizens after all he is A CSP?

[Pakistaniguy]

I would also like to share my experience. I was studying in an academy for the preparation of CSS here at karachi. I will not mention the name of academy becuase the academy was good however, one of the teacher of this academy was so rude and arrogant. He was Sir Rehan (AC Custom). He was called to take our class on that day by administartion of academy. The administrator of academy was Sir Falak Shair (AC Custom) , very nice person and down to earth.

So Sir Rehan reached in the class late and just after few minutes of his lecture Moizin started Azaan in nearby mosque. He threw the mic on side and said "Kia museebat hay in ko bhi abhi azaan dena yaad aati hay". I and few other freinds were very angry on this statement and we decided to leave the class. When we were leaving he asked us are you fundamentalist ? We did not say anything to him and we just left the class.

Meraa eeman hay kay yeh teacher jisay haram ki dolat nay andha kar dia hay jis ko Azaan ki awaz achi nahi lagti aor us ko khamoshi say sunnany k bajaye us ko museebat kehta hay zillat ki moat karay ga.

After our complain to Sir Falak Shiar regarding this incident, he (Rehan) was not called again by Sir Falak sher to teach us and another teacher was arranged by him. May Allah guide all of us.

[pureapak]

Yes there comes a major shift in the behaviour when one reaches a destination, long cherished. specially in those who hav never seen such status before.
They start vaining off their office misconceiving that they 've got a huge portion of official power. Thus begin displaying a new attitude of arrogance born of this feeling.
but to tell you honestly, after they reach a mature age in their career they are alone to atone for such a rude behaviour.
let the ametuare enjoy the long cherished authority and let them vain it off arrogantly.
if you are ill treateed at their hand you mush show traits of mature response.
you have your own civil rights you may file a complaint against them any way.
and let them realize of the wrong turn in their behaviour.

regards

[Pakistaniguy]

Though I have written my bad experience here regarding the arrogance of CSP Sir Rehan (AC Custom). However, let me also share that still 10% good bureacuates are also serving and one of them is Qamar Cheema. Please find below his few threads o this forum and check the wordings in each thread. You will notice humbleness and down to earth behaviour in these threads and his threads are also highly useful for every css aspirants:

http://www.cssforum.com.pk/beginners...az-cheema.html

I am highly impressed from him when he writes "A success may seem to be a very stirring and moving and one may attribute it to hard working. No, my dear friends, any success comes only by blessing of Allah, and we should not try to divide it between My hardworking and Allah’s blessing. It is only Allah’s blessing that you worked hard otherwise you can not."

May Allah confer him longevity.