Criticism on Agarwal book
1. It is old book even in chapter of State responsibility he mentioned that draft of State responsibility is not approved yet. While, draft of state responsibility is adopted by United Nations.
2. It is written according to Indian perspective. In this book, he has incarcerated Pakistan as an evil state. For example in chapter of War, he mentioned that Pak. Army is responsible for molestation of Bangali Woman while we denied these allegations.
3. Reference cases are not given in ample amount in this book. You have to read another for cases.

Positive Points of Agarwal

1. It is simple book even lay man can understand this book with basics of international system.
2. Headings are proper and material is organised in proper way so that reader can grasp the crux of it.



Shaw Book Criticism
1. It is lengthy book.
2. Wording are difficult for first time reader.
3. Reader cannot grasp the crux in first reading.

Shaw Book benefits

1. It is recommended book by Fpsc
2. It is depleted with hundreds of cases in each chapter.
3. Unlike Agarwal, it is written according international perspective. So you can understand International law without any bias.
4. It is complete conceptual book.


Now, It is your turn to critically analyse the criticism and favourism in my post and reach at conclusion.

Sent from my Nokia 3.1 Plus using Tapatalk

__________________
“Never leave that till tomorrow which you can do today.”
Benjamin Franklin