CSS Forums - View Single Post - CSS quota system; a blow to the merit system

Engr.Aftab · #4 Sunday, May 17, 2009

Quote:

Originally Posted by snake

There should be no quota system in the examination of CSS for obvious reason that it belongs to the federal affairs and the eligibility must be determined on one’s ability .
The quota system can be tolerated at the university level. Abolition of quota system brings a positive competition among the students.
The matter of representation of the provinces in the federal affairs is solved by providing them appropriate representation in the upper and lower houses. A bureaucrat is a professional serving his nation in his/her best way irrespective of his domicile . The quota system also inflames the provincialism when the people are allocated on the provincial distribution of seats .
A lot of candidates are not going to be allocated yet inferior quality people as compared to them will get the seats in the prestigious institution just because of their domicile . Isn’t this against the Islamic values? The preference is given only on the basis of their birth place not on the intellectual capacity that is laid for the selection of the CSPs .

AOA
dear i appreciate your sensations, but dont you think that without getting 50% marks and without passing all subjects in css , one cant b a csp.
secondly if a person pass the exam than we can say that he has abilities and capabilities...there is quota system but after all that one has to pass through the selection criteria.... so dear if u think analytically there are many many things and on the basis of these things quota system was introduced. ..in quota the population is considered.. in our country the facilities are also not distributed uniformally. look at balochistan if one is seriously ill than he is brought towards karachi or some where else for treatment...likewise standard education facilties are also lacking there ,and that province has abt 6% quota...i am also not fevour in quota system in sindh as they have distributed that quota in sindh urban and sindh rural, and urban seats are not filled completly due lack of interest of sindh urban candidates so in sindh urban and rural system shoud b end. . . . in punjab competition is high and its increasing day by day so those cadidates do face prbl during their allocations..competition in nwfp is also increasing... . so quota is important in this way that all the provinces participate and their participation represent the issues and prblms of concerend province at high level....there are also many other things aswel because of them the quota system introduced...i am pakistani and i dont want the interprovincial problems in pakistan, as v are facing now days like on NFC award, water issues etc...so if quota system ends than this would b an other issue..........
regards