CSS Forums - View Single Post

redmax · #40 Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hasan Raza Awan

[B]
janab ye log shamil hain kbhi inko khd se alag nai smjha cz ye hain to Pakistan hai but main sirf itna khta hon jo jiska roght hai wo do use n right chenne ki try mt kro.

I hope live up to your words - especially the highlighted ones.

Quote:

Originally Posted by zeeshan1001

In order to maintain the real meaning of the competitive examination it is necessary to implement its system in the real letter and spirit. All the allocations must be done on the basis of final merit. Quota system not only gives relaxation to candidates but also minimizes the quality of preparation. Those who compete in the cut throat competition on all Pakistan basis are the real talented people. Otherwise the name of the exam be changed from competitive examination to Quota based recruitment exam..

All the allocations are done on the basis of final merit list. The only difference is that FPSC does not take instructions from you or me, it prepared the final merit list as per its constitution.

Quote:

Originally Posted by shallowwater

No the quota system must go as it has hampered progress. It creates a sense of complacency in the people of other provinces that after qualifying the written they would be definitely allocated. And also the carried over seats must be distributed among the people of all provinces rather than keeping them for future.

So much for the individualism and optimistic approach. We are so frustratingly running after pulling the legs of candidates from other provinces that we almost tend to forget our own worth. Complacency is one's own issue and has nothing to do with the quota system and national interest at large. So much for the irrational arguments!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Muhammad T S Awan

Brother, our history had necessitated such a system, but our present does not necessarily need it and it is an agreed thing, that the government should do away with the military induction. The genesis of military induction in civilian bureaucracy can little be found from a recently published column,

Military in civil service By Aminullah Chaudry | Columnspk.com | English Newspaper Columns, News, Top Stories, World News, Politics, Middle East

Dear if one or two aggrieved people are from Punjab and they are having certain point of view, it does'nt mean that Punjab is bad or Punjab is trying to devour upon other provinces. Probably you have been having an idea that Punjab is getting a lion's share in everything and now trying to eat up the quota system, no this is not the actual thing, I have just tried to dispell this impression that Punjab is bad or Punjabi airs regionalism or racism. .. We should all think like being Pakistanis putting our castes/race aside for the greater national interest. We, being a part of our nation as well as part of civil beaurucracy, should not think that any race is trying to oppress the other race. Problems are everywhere, including in the Punjab. The people of Punjab are not living in heaven when people of other country are in trouble. .. We must shun the concept of regionalism at all cost when a number of enemies are at our doorstep to break us apart...

This is issue of serious concern that many individuals, even having lot of hardwork and passing all the rounds of css, dont get allocated. This creates a sense of alienation amongst them and the governmnet should do something for their prosperity.

The quota system, in current system, is not required to be disbanded, rather the actual people from backward areas should be given consideration instead of the people, who spent their lives in big cities studying in best educational institutions of big cities and get benefit of quota system to sit in the csp laders.

The actual notion of quota system is varied nature/disparity of educational systems in different parts of the country so that students for far flung areas are given due consideration. But in case eight persons, one each from Multan, Lahore, Sukkur, Quetta, Peshawar, Parachanar, Ghanche and Karachi remained class fellows throughout their educational career i.e. studying in same educational institutions from class first to graduation/post graduation at Quaid-e-Azam University having grooming/nurturing in same environment, thn apparently there needs not to be given consideration under quota system. In this way, the actual/needy individual, who studied in backward school of Mastung, Khairpur, D.I.Khan, Gopis/Yasir, Miranshah or even for matter that at D.G. Khan(Punjab) , will suffer and will not be able to get allocation even though having domicile from FATA, Balochistan or Sindh.

Reforms should be made so that level playing field be given to our brethren hailing from all areas of our beloved homeland Islamic Republic of Pakistan....

Allow me to conclude it, Mr. Mod.

1. We cannot do away with quota because it serves the national interest where secessionist movements are already on the rise with covert support. It is also necessitated by our own system of government to provide uniform and justified chances of opportunities to all its citizens.

2. Reforms that do not directly or indirectly affect the interests of other provinces should be introduced.

3. I personally believe those candidates who are left out after the final allocation should be interviewed by various ministries as per their qualifications and inducted as Assistant Directors (BS-17). This will also optimize the process of recruiting hundreds of ADs by various ministries each year. This may also help eradicating the malpractice of inducting sons and daughters of ministers, MNAs and Senators' as ADs in their respective departments/Ministries.

Regards,