Quote:
Originally Posted by umair jarwar
I strongly oppose this petition.
The reason are only understood by those aspirants who aspire by living far away from cities like lahore, karachi etc because they have to share some responsibilities with their family along with some other domestic problems along with poor educational system of rural areas as well cities in which they dwell. All of us are familiar with that harsh reality.
The development of intellect needs a base, a good base in order to qualify exams like CSS while exceptional cases of extraordinary minds are rare. You have to think for those unprivileged aspirants before doing any such thing.
They have the right to get equal amount after a painful job by which they manage to get success in this exam.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by ABDUL JABBAR KATIAR
bhai, punjab ko 50% quota mil rahi ha. ab kya doosre province ki quota bhi punjab ko de den. ye to sarasar nainsafi ha doosre provinces k sath. 50% quota k bawajood punjab men seats kum parjati hain aur css pass karne wale zyada hote hain. is men doosre province ka kya qasoor ha. punjabis ko chahye k woh next attempt k lye tayari karen. punjab her cheez men 50% se bhi zyada le jata ha muger css men to kuch raham karen doosre provinces pe. un ka bhi kuch haq ha pakistan men. unhoon ne bhi pakistan ki azaadi k lye koshish ki thi ya sirf punjab ne ki thi. iam disagree with u. quota system is right because every province should be given its share in every job.70% revenue pakistan ka sindh se aata ha baqi ye kahan ka insaaf ha k punjab population basis pe 50% job seats le jae. quota system is best.
|
Quota is not the issue. Distribution of quota is issue. Punjab’s quota is 50%. But this quota is in addition to its participation in open merit. Remember there are 17 all Pakistan open merit seats. I try to explain this with the help of an example:
Suppose there are 5 open merit seats and one seat is reserved for women. And suppose that final merit list is:
1- A (male)
2- B (female)
3- C (male)
4- D (male)
5- E (male)
6- F (male)
7- G (female)
Now how will you distribute seats among candidates:
This way?
1- A (male)(open merit 1)
2- B (woman) (open merit 2)
3- C (male)(open merit 3)
4- D (male)(open merit 4)
5- E (male)(open merit 5)
6- F (male)(not allocated)
7- G (women) (women quota 1)
Or this way?
1- A (male)(open merit 1)
2- B (woman) (women quota 1)
3- C (male)(open merit 2)
4- D (male)(open merit 3)
5- E (male)(open merit 4)
6- F(male)(open merit 5)
7- G (women) (not allocated)
If you believe that quota is a mean to ensure proper representation then you shall agree that the right distribution of seats is the first one and not the second one. The principle is “quota seats can not be filled before open merit seats.” This principle had been endorsed by Supreme court of Pakistan ( Civil Petition No. 941 of 2010).
Check the final result of CSS 2010. From among the first 17 candidates, there are 13 Punjabi. So Punjab should get 13 open merit seats. But Punjab is only given 7 seats. This is against the established principle of law.
App jis bhi province say ho, app ki reserved seats app ko Mubarak hoon. But you know open merit seats should be contested on open merit. Hope you agree now.