Here are My notes for Essays...I hope you find it helping..sources are mostly articles,Current affairs by Imtiaz Shahid,News paper.
CORRUPTION
Introduction
Economic rent:” arises when a person as something unique in possession which can be luxury in a posh neighborhood
A person who owns such a special asset can charge more then normal for its use
U-Miynt and Law Commission of Government of India drawing upon the concepts quoted a CORRUPTION equation
Corruption =(Monopoly) + (Discretion)- Accountability or in abbreviated form as
C= R + D – A
About Pakistan, no structure, no tier and no office of public sector is immune from It
Beyond executive, claws over judiciary and legislature
Incidence is so frequent that Pakistan is ranked 139 in the ranks of corruption free countries
HISTORY OF CORRUPTION
South Asian countries have pulurist society with colonial legacy of bribery and nepotism
Nepotism in colonial era included awarding of lands,titles and jobs
Post partition, Nationalization, drug money,foreign aid made corruption more systematic
Informal structure of economy
Grew with relations between legislators and businesses
Culture of corruption was promoted in colonial system of government
Part of political bribery
White collar crimes like refugee claims, industrial sanctions. Allotment of agriculture lands
Till the second WW-II corruption was among revenue, police, excise and Public works
REASONS OF CORRUPTION
Reasons are country-specific
Key drivers are visible by in-depth country studies
Public servants lacking a service mentality
Corruption flourishes where government is weak
Reasons are rooted in a country’s political development, legal development, bureaucratic traditions, economic conditions and policies
Interference of government in economy
In-appropriate administrative strict
Governmental monopolies
Expansion of rent
Unequal distribution of incomes
Falling of many democratic governments were done on the basis of allegation of corruption 90,96,99
Reasons
Land awards
Bloated Public sector
Private sector cooperatives
Drug money
Foreign aid and investment
Informal structure of National economy
Institutional erosion
RELATIONS WITH SOCITY
Relations with free press
Relation with democracy
Relation with Materialism
Relation with Low salaries
Impact on social thinking
FORMS OF CORRUPTION
Transparency international states various forms ranging from nepotism to bribery
Increase in acceptability of this bitter fact
People feel less guilty
Highest in development and procurement
Bank loans write offs
Rs. 200 billion loss per annum
Most prominent sectors
1. Power sector
2. Tax and Customs
3. Police
4.Judiciary
5. Health
6. Land admin
Public utilities WAPDA,SUI GAS and other public works department
Tax regime lack of documentation… untaxed sectors… weak administrative capcity… 50% urban income unaccounted. Tax evasion going to 218 billion
Public sector Banking
public sector expenditure
underground economy
health Hospital MS.. financial mis management… hiring people without merit… corrupt practices of official staff… medico-legal certificates… favors from pharma companies…ignoring emergency call
dire need to fight materialism through installation of high moral values
ISSUES OF CORRUPTION
Post independence settlement of refugees
Interventionist economic policies
Discretionary powers for Gas and textile quotas
Inadequate compensation to civil servants
Excessive aid flow without tackling corruption
Economic projects like “Green tractor scheme” “yellow cab scheme”, Ghazi barotha, Motorway, Karachi Mass transit system, IPPs huge source of corruption
Financial scams have severely damaged public trust
Weak regulatory system… State Bank Unable to prevent disasters
Politicization of civil servants
Complete Breakdown of Structures, Government departments and Anti-corruption organization
Delivery failure of Civil institutions
Sociological factors… Favors on the base of ethnic, familial, religious and other social considerations are responsible
CONSEQUENCES OF CORRUPTION
Cost of corruption are high
Distorts local resource allocation and government performance
Countries having lesser portion of GDP to spend at social development like Education
IN Pakistan Destroyed fabric of society
Role of money inn politics brought money rich businessmen into politics to safeguard their economic interests
Adil gillani from TI Pakistan said that Corruption is the reason of Pverty, illetracy , un employment, shortage of food and energy
Credibility at lowest level as no funding from FRIENDS OF PAKISTAN trust fund being managed by World Bank
CORRUPTION ACQUITTED of BIG WIGGS
In corruption references, some of the witnesses backtracked in their statements, recorded against the accused. The influential accused persons in the high profile cases are still being exonerated, even in those cases in which the Supreme Court had taken suo motu notice and had remanded the cases to the trial courts.In the Haj corruption case, the then federal minister Hamid Saeed Kazmi was considered to be the main accused.The final challan submitted to the court by the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA), however, exonerated Mr Kazmi from other sections of 409,420,467,468,471and109 (related to fraud and abetment) of Pakistan Penal Code in which the convict may get life imprisonment and only charged him with section 5(2)47 of Prevention of Corruption Act (PCA) in which the maximum punishment is not more than 7 year.
acquittal of a member National Assembly from Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) Anjum Ageel Khan is another example of bigwigs getting off the hook. MNA Mr Khan was arrested in July last year in connection with his alleged involvement in Rs6 billion National Police Foundation land scam.fled Shalimar station but later released because he voluntarily surrendered next day. The 12 police officials from the ranks of sub-inspectors to constables, who were the witnesses of the prosecution and had earlier recorded their statements against the accused became `hostile witnesses`, and also backtracked from the allegation becoming the sole reason for acquaintance of MNA.
October 2011, a session court of Lahore acquitted a member Punjab Assembly of PML-Q, and son of former chief minister Pervez Elahi, Moonis Elahi in the National Insurance Company Limited (NICL) scam in which he allegedly forced NICL to buy land at a highly inflated price.In the Moonis case, bank officials had turned `hostile witnesses` and did not utter a single word against Moonis in their statements.
the primitive prosecution methodology, in which the eye-witness is the key, is the main reason of acquittals.
our law of evidence is based on the Police Act of 1861, which is in fact a pro-accused law, adding that the law is a reason in the rapid increase in organised crimes.
He suggested that the law of evidence should be proprosecution in which forensic evidence photographs, video/CCTV footage or mobile phone record-would be treated at par with the evidence of eye witnesses.
FORIEGN INVESTMENT had declined from $5.1 billion of 2007-2008 to $813biilions of 2011-2012
PIA-PRIME EXAMPLE OF MIS-MANAGEMENT AND CORRUPTION
the culture of nepotism had become so endemic in the airline that even duty rosters and lucrative routes were given to the crew on the basis of favouritism and contracts for repairs and spare parts were also awarded on the same consideration. `This becomes the basis of vices like smuggling and also reasons for frequent delays at the international airports.PIA had suffered a whopping loss of Rs119 billion last year alone.With only 26 aircraft in the PIA fleet operational and approximately 20,000 employees, the ratio of employees per aircraft was 570.the PIA representatives startled the court when they said that only three per cent of the employees were appointed on merit while the rest came through quota system as per government rules.PIA faced a financial loan of $565 million, adding that the airline straight away suffered a loss of Rs40 billion last year because of exchange rate difference after depreciation of the rupee which was beyond the control of PIA.
This is an airline which helped set up other carriers and trained their staff, yet now it is gasping for air, dependent on government bailouts for survival. Mismanagement is the single biggest factor behind the decline.
If the airline can be restructured and run by a professional, honest set of managers who give priority to aircraft safety and customer service, perhaps PIA can cruise to a more comfortable altitude.
FACTS AND AMOUNT OF CORRUPTION
Wealthy businessmen strive for saving personal benefit over national advantage
Rs. 200 billion per annum
70% Pakistani believe that current government is more corrupt then previous except people in Punjab
Police and Power maintined their ranking as top two
“Tendering” eats away 40% development budget
Transportation of Suger by Trading Cooperation of Pakistan according to Public Procurement Rules 2004 saved Rs. 49.3 Mill 40% less then originaly paid
Violaters of above Rules include WPADA,CDA, NHA, SBP, CUSTOMS, FIA, PCB, NLC, PID and Utility stores Cooperation
In monetary most corrupt is Revenue collection staff giving a loss of USD 19 Billion accounting to 24% of GDP and 20% of which is received as kick backs
PERVENTION
For successful anti-corruption drive, anti corruption strategy to govern it, structure it ,drive it and above all right direction
Prevention of Corruption Act at independence , Public representative (Disqual) Act1949 and Elected Bodies (Disqu) Ordinance 1959 were mere tools of political victimization
FIA 1975… Ehtsaab Bureau 97 with Ehtsaab commission of 96 with Bureau to investigate and commission to prosecute
No meaningful improvement
Far lost credibility and Public trust so imperative for an anti corruption drive to succeed
Many Governments failed in past to curb this Menace because of
Misuse of Agencies by Governments
Poor investigations and lack of professional expertise
Misuse of mandate by agencies
Weakness in the accountability system
Incomplete judicial system
Appointment of head of agencies
In-adequencies and institutional weakness of Anti corruption agencies
Fighting Corruption requires both leadership and partnership
Leadership from local and national governments, tax collection agencies, judiciary, army, corporations, citizen in the community
They all aim up to break Monopolies
Private sector and civil society are the real players in this game
Korean example: to obtain a corruption free society various anti- corruption program in 1999.
Emphasis on prevention then punishment
Comprehensive and systematic approach
Feasibility must be given importance
Following three stratagies to maximize effectiveness
Infrastructure to fight corruption
Administrative reforms in tax prone areas
Building local and international partnerships
CONCLUSION
Universal phenomenon
Difference is only level and degree
Politicians in UK,Spain,Belgium and even whole European commission resigned due to it
Corruption provides WINGS in Pakistan to capital to fly rather then wheels to move into the country
Weak legal processes to fight it
Widespread form within the society
The state need to establish credibility by punishing highly visible corrupt
Intention should be to eradicate it rather than gaining public support