View Single Post
  #24  
Old Thursday, June 06, 2013
imbindas's Avatar
imbindas imbindas is offline
Senior Member
Medal of Appreciation: Awarded to appreciate member's contribution on forum. (Academic and professional achievements do not make you eligible for this medal) - Issue reason:
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Islamabad
Posts: 1,276
Thanks: 448
Thanked 851 Times in 551 Posts
imbindas is a glorious beacon of lightimbindas is a glorious beacon of lightimbindas is a glorious beacon of lightimbindas is a glorious beacon of lightimbindas is a glorious beacon of lightimbindas is a glorious beacon of light
Default

first of all we desperately need to get rid of CII (council of islamic ideology) and federal shriat court (FSC) . CII want to protect rapists and FSC had resisted every move to implement land reforms according to their so called shariah laws.

now what is shariat ? shariat mean a clear path, a path of truth, a path which is pure from ambiguity. who invented that word shariat ? Holy prophet, khulafa-e-rashdeen and all four great imams even respected shia imams like hazrat Imam jaffar sadiq never used used word as "shariat".

Islam is the most liberal religion of the world which is continuously in the state of transition since its inception. Holy prophet and all his great companions were most liberal in their interpretation. islamic law is not rigit, it is ever changing according to the needs of society.

Now lets talk about the Zina and its four eye witnesses. in Arab Jahiliya period before the inception of Islam the society of pagans were at the lowest ebb in morality. there were free mixing of opposite sex and sexual relations are rampant. it should be pointed out that there were no concept of rape, zina in islam means sex among the opposite sexes by their volition. and in that time frequently women were accused by their male partners of having sexual relations with other males or zina , for example if man wanted to get rid of his wife, he would accuse her of zina and then punish her in one way or another. this was really bad for the women of that time. we must bear in mind that Islamic zina laws were to protect women of arab society of being persecution in false cases, it was to protect her dignity from being baseless charges. thats why Allah in Quran ordered the condition of four witnesses. at that time there were no concept of RAPE, men and women were involved freely in sex. so this law was to protect the women from being persecution without a proof.

this was the whole concept of zina laws. now in present society, do these laws protect women ? the answer is absolutely NO. these laws protect the rapers and criminals who went unpunished in almost 99% cases. If Prophet were alive now, He would have get rid of these law asap. this is not a rocket science, its a matter of common sense if we have left with any.

Now many so called scholars, even on this form, will argue that how can we change the laws of Quran. let me elaborate please !

1- Punishment for stealing in Quran is to cut hands, why Prophet left one person unpunished when it was proved that he was involved in stealing ? did Prophet went against the law of Quran ?

2- Why Hazrat Umer disallowed the new muslims to have share in zakat ? Why He refuse to give share of bounty to new converts? Why Umer started Tarawh nimaz as it was never ordered by Prophet? why umer accepted women witness even two men were present as witness in one case? did hazrat Umer went against the law of Quran ?

3- why Prophet allowed women to retaliate against her husband who had slap her, later hazrat jibrael came and ordered Prophet to forbade women to do so, Prophet did so. why was that ? because at that time islam was in its early stages, it was a patriarchal society and such action could have provoked the men, it could had been a disaster for islam. it shows that even Prophet could not have challenged all jahiliyas customs for the reasons i explained.

4- Islam was not able to curb most of the Jahiliyas customs and traditions , the reason is simple , the non-materialistic culture takes time to change, it is impossible to change ideas and beliefs in a matter of few year or so. what Prophet did that he laid a general framework by exemplifying himself and left many matters for the believers to decide according to their own needs and time of their society. do remember that society is important. wearing shettle cock burqa is fine in fata but same burqa in lahore and islamabad would make no sense. well i don't want to divert my discussion towards "Purdah" in islam, will discuss it latter some other time. so the crux of the matter is that Prophet was aware of changing needs of society. that why he never imposed his understandings and interpretation of Holy text on believers.

5-let me ask CII mullahs, there are thousands of offenses and problems where the solution has not been provided in Quran , sunnah and even Ijma. how are they going to deal with it ? did they know any thing like "Ijtehad" which was himself initiated by the Holy Prophet approving the reply of Mouz bin jabal while appointing him the Governer.

6- these are the same Mullahs who declared TV, loudspeakers as Haram. now they are the one who are using these facilities more that anyone n this universe. now the Haram is Halal, but How?

the truth is that our Mullahs are cripple minded, they are still living in 3rd Hijri, they are dead intellectually. all they care about is Jannat, they sexual pleasures in Jannat with hoors, the wine, the milk, the beef, they Dont love Allah they fear Allah. those who don not love the creature of Allah can never love Allah. they are pleasure seekers, their lusty minds have little to ponder about.

When Hazrat Bayazid bustami was ascribe by Local mullah as heretic, the great sufi replied "O kitabi kerhay, tujhay kya pata ISHQ kya hota ha, tu sari umer jisko kitabon may dhondta rhta ha, wo meray Dil may rehta ha"
Regards.
__________________
Forget safety.Live where you fear to live.Destroy your reputation.Be notorious
Reply With Quote
The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to imbindas For This Useful Post:
Ayesha Chemist (Friday, June 07, 2013), Gypsified (Thursday, June 06, 2013), KHALID RAJPAR (Tuesday, June 11, 2013), Muhammad Usman Ghani (Tuesday, June 11, 2013), Sasha Fierce (Monday, June 10, 2013)