View Single Post
  #6  
Old Thursday, December 26, 2013
Fassi's Avatar
Fassi Fassi is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Islamabad, Hafizabad
Posts: 469
Thanks: 13
Thanked 753 Times in 324 Posts
Fassi is a glorious beacon of lightFassi is a glorious beacon of lightFassi is a glorious beacon of lightFassi is a glorious beacon of lightFassi is a glorious beacon of lightFassi is a glorious beacon of light
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hamza Kahlon View Post
Hello guys
I need advice on which book from these two i.e Agarwal and Tandon, i should make my text book?

Facts:
2nd attempt (first in 2012)
Used Agarwal in the 1st attempt
Now, a teacher(done LLM) in NOA, suggested us to go for TANDON. His score was 73

My View:
Tandon: After going through a few chapters of Tandon, i felt, that there is much detail, and toooo many references, with minimal input from the author himself. Even in his conclusions, he is using more references and his own view is given in a sentence or two. (my opinion, could be faulty)
Tandon has a few extra chapters. Sometimes the details are..useless? as i found him repeating the same point over and over again

Agarwal:
To be honest, apart from a few Questions/Chapters/Dimensions....I found Agarwal more "friendly" or convenient than Tandon. He has not overburdened with innumerable references on every page, and feels a bit more "student oriented".

To conclude, I just want to ASK....Which book would be the best? and if my approach to the subject is faulty, please suggest remedial steps to be taken.
In 2013, I scored 74 in International Law and I'm a Law Graduate as well as a practicing lawyer. I'll suggest you to go for Agarwall's book only. Its handy and to the point. I consider it the best book to cope with CSS I.L paper. One thing more, don't be panic prepare the relevant topics only. For that very purpose download the study plan who's link is given below and do follow it for to the point study of this subject.

__________________
Apni Matti Pay Hi Chalnay Ka Saleeqa Seekho
Sang-e-Marmar Py Chalo Gy To Phisal Jao Gy
Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to Fassi For This Useful Post:
Hamza Kahlon (Thursday, December 26, 2013)