I don't understand why would you discuss the appointment criterion? You appeared in the test, scored well. That's it.. Now, don't bother yourselves with the things that are not in your hands! Have some patience and trust in Allah! All these comments and time you are giving to the things that are not in your hands are going to upset you if you didn't get selected! Believe me.. There is much more to do in life! Go with the flow brothers. I am talking from experience. Hope you didn't mind me saying that!