View Single Post
  #7  
Old Friday, December 11, 2015
Eager's Avatar
Eager Eager is offline
40th CTP (PAAS)
CSP Medal: Awarded to those Members of the forum who are serving CSP Officers - Issue reason: CE 2011 - Merit 364
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 356
Thanks: 1,199
Thanked 379 Times in 155 Posts
Eager is a jewel in the roughEager is a jewel in the roughEager is a jewel in the roughEager is a jewel in the rough
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by wasxxm View Post
Aoa. I have tried to put up my first ever precis. The precis of CE-2015 paper. Seniors may kindly review. Thanks in anticipation.

In studding the breakdowns of civilizations, the writer has subscribed to the conclusion – no new discovery! – that war has proved to have been the proximate cause of the breakdown of every civilization which is known for certain to have broken down, in so far as it has been possible to analyze the nature of these breakdowns and to account for their occurrence. Like other evils war has no insidious way of appearing not intolerable until it has secured such a stranglehold upon the lives of its addicts that they no longer have the power to escape from its grip when its deadlines has become manifest. In the early stages of civilization’s growth, the cost of wars in suffering and destruction might seem to be exceeded by the benefits occurring from the wining of wealth and power and the cultivation of the “military virtues” ; and, in this phase of history, states have often found themselves able to indulge in war with one another with something like impunity even for the defeated party. War does not begin to reveal its malignity till the war making society has begun to increase its economic ability to exploit physical nature and its political ability to organize manpower; but, as soon as this happens, the god of war to which the growing society has long since been dedicated proves himself a Moloch by devouring an ever larger share of the increasing fruits of man’s industry and intelligence in the process of taking an ever larger toll of life and happiness; and, when the society’s growth in efficiency reaches a point at which it becomes capable of mobilizing a lethal quantum of its energies and resources for military use then war reveals itself as being a cancer which is bound to prove fatal to its victim unless he can cut it out and cast it from him, since its malignant tissues have now learnt to grow faster that the healthy tissues on which they feed.
In the past when this danger-point in the history of the relations between war and civilization has been reached and recognized, serious efforts have sometimes been made to get rid of war in time to save society, and these endeavors have been apt to take one or other of two alternative directions. Salvation cannot, of course, be sought anywhere except in the working of the consciences of individual human beings; but individuals have a choice between trying to achieve their aims through direct action as private citizens and trying to achieve then through indirect action as citizen of states. Personal refusal to lend himself in any way to any war waged by his state for any purpose and in any circumstances is a line of attack against the institution of war that is likely to appeal to an ardent and self-sacrificing nature; by comparison, the alternative peace strategy of seeking to persuade and accustom governments to combine in jointly resisting aggression when it comes and in trying to remove its stimuli beforehand may seem a circuitous and unheroic line of attack on the problem. Yet experience up to date indicates unmistakably, in the present writer’s opinion, that the second of these two hard roads is by far the more promising.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title: Breakdown of civilizations due to wars and its remedies
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Precis:
In writer’s opinion war has caused breakdown of many civilizations. In the early civilizations, wars have proved to be more of monetary and military value than the devastations occurred. The defeated were seldom crushed to extinction. It is when the aggressors advanced their military equipment and developed powerful disciplined armies, the full scale of destructions of wars became clear, capable of extinguishing entire civilizations.

In history, two approaches have been pursued by individuals to circumvent war and its menaces. Acting as a private citizen, one approach is to distance oneself from the war waging activities of the state. The other, rather peace making approach, is to strive to make the government join united front against aggression. According to the author, the second approach may seem lengthy and unappealing, yet the experience proves it more fruitful.
Not at all a good precis. You didn't seem to get the gist of the passage and have left many important points. I would advise you to write it again. Few observations:

1. Title is lengthy + inappropriate

2. Write your precis in third person. Everyone knows you're presenting writer's opinion. Hence, there is no need to start it with "In writer's opinion"

3. The precis had to be of 179 words. You can take the liberty of lengthening or shortening it up to 4-6 words, but not beyond that. Since you did not mention many important points present in original passage, you have difficulty reaching the required word limit.

4. Poor attempt. Try again.

P.S:
Do not get discouraged by the harsh comments. As you have mentioned it is your first precis, i would advise you to practice shorter, easier passages first by some precis book. Once you attempt 20-30 easier passages, then start solving past papers. It will be easier for you and help you more.

Keep practising. Best of luck!
__________________
Whatever is important will remain; whatever is useless will disappear.
Reply With Quote