Q&A: Guantánamo Bay

16/07/2008



The US prison for alleged terrorists has detained suspects from all over the world for five years but how exactly does it work?


Peter Walker and James Sturcke



What is Guantánamo Bay?
It is a US naval base on the eastern tip of Cuba which, for the past five years, has been used as a detention centre for suspected terrorists, mainly captured in Afghanistan during the US assault following the September 11 attacks.

Those held are suspected of fighting for the Taliban or being operatives for al-Qaida, and are considered "enemy combatants" rather than prisoners of war, meaning the US does not consider them subject to the Geneva convention.

This means prisoners can be detained indefinitely without trial, something critics condemn as a legal black hole.


Who is currently detained at Guantánamo Bay?
At its peak, around 750 prisoners were held at the camp but hundreds have been released over the years.

According to a Human Rights Watch report released last month, there are currently around 270 detainees. The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), the only organisation allowed to visit prisoners, says they come from about 40 countries in total, but most inmates are from Afghanistan or Pakistan.


Are there any Britons being held there?
No. Nine UK nationals were being detained. Five were released in March 2004, and the final four - Moazzam Begg, Feroz Abbasi, Martin Mubanga and Richard Belmar - were flown to London in January 2005.

Last year, the UK government requested the release five of the nine British residents held there. Four were released in December. Last month, the Pentagon said one of the remaining UK residents at the camp - Binyam Ahmed Mohamed, an Ethiopian educated in Britain - would be charged over an alleged al-Qaida dirty bomb plot.


What is the legal status of the prisoners?
Detainees have been denied their rights under the Geneva convention, although the US insists they are being treated humanely, in line with the protocols set out in the agreement.

As long as the prisoners never touch US soil - and American courts do not consider the Cuban base to be part of the US - they are also denied the rights guaranteed to criminals under the constitution, such as a presumption of innocence and a trial by jury.

The plan is to try prisoners by military tribunal, something that has been challenged by lawyers acting for some detainees.

In June last year, the US supreme court ruled that the military violated US and international law. The government responded by passing the Military Commissions Act 2006, which legislates for tribunals where evidence can be brought and permits indefinite detention without trial where it cannot.

Last month, the supreme court ruled that detainees have a constitutional right to take their cases to civilian courts on the US mainland.


What is the international attitude to Guantánamo?
Many governments, as well as human rights groups, have demanded it be closed and the detainees charged or released immediately. Amnesty International has labelled the camp a "symbol for injustice and abuse".

The British government's stance has hardened. In October 2006, the then foreign secretary, Margaret Beckett, used a speech on human rights to label the centre "unacceptable in terms of human rights", calling for it to be closed. Before leaving office, Tony Blair said Guantánamo Bay was an "anomaly" that would have to be "dealt with".


What will happen to the current detainees?
Around 75 of them are believed to have been selected to go before the military tribunals, which could begin hearings in the next few months. The fate of others is less certain.

Amnesty International has highlighted the plight of detainees such as Mohammed al-Amin, a Mauritanian national held in Pakistan as a teenager before being sent to Guantánamo.

"His interrogations have stopped; he simply languishes in the US detention facility with no ability to challenge his incarceration," the group said.


What is Camp Delta like for the prisoners?
Prisoners are held in four camps, in small, mesh-sided cells, for up to 24 hours a day. Cellblocks are made up of 48 cells. There is little privacy, and lights are kept on day and night.

Inmates are allowed half an hour of exercise between three and seven days each week in a caged recreation yard measuring 7.6 metres by 9.1 metres.

The ICRC visits prisoners, and arranges the exchange of letters between inmates and their families. US officials look over the contents of all correspondence with families, who are not allowed to visit.

Many released prisoners have alleged they were beaten or mistreated in other ways, something US officials vehemently denied.

In 2006, dozens of inmates staged hunger strikes in protest at their detention. In June 2006, three prisoners committed suicide by hanging themselves with bed sheets.


Why does the US have a naval base on Cuba?
The base dates back to a treaty, signed in 1903 and renewed in 1934, which leases the Guantánamo Bay site to the US for $4,085 (£2,113) per year.

The treaty requires the consent of both governments to revoke or change it and, unsurprisingly, the US will not agree to that. In protest, Cuba has refused to accept the rent payments.

SOURCE: The Guardian

http://www.cageprisoners.com/print.php?id=25442