Wednesday, October 19, 2016
|
 |
Senior Member
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 111
Thanks: 7
Thanked 27 Times in 17 Posts
|
|
Tenacious read it
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tenacious
The reason lies in why all four sons and 2 nephews of Dr. Liaqat Niazi are in PMS while none of them could ever qualify the written of CSS. The reason lies in topper of PMS 2011 Nazia Mohal failing all three attempts of CSS while topping in PMS, her sister Zeba Mohal also failing the CSS thrice while she is in service in Punjab, the reason lies in her brother becoming a provincial officer but never passed the CSS.
PMS has such lowest criteria that those who cannot do CSS can surely do PMS.
P.S: Btw if you passed PMS two times, you should be a PMS officer by now.
|
"Those who cannot do css can surely do PMS".
I did not read your posts neither do I have time to indulge myself in irrational discussion, but when I saw Farah`s post I read some of your posts and decided to respond. Partially because of absurdity of your logic and partially because I have been follower of Farah since 2012 and admire her a lot. So just read my post and at the end, for the love of God, respond rationally if that is something you could please do!
Though I still believe that one should have sportsmen like spirit and embrace defeat as one would celebrate a win. But at the same time I am strong believer of luck. My research suggest that FPSC changed its policy from 2012 and has targeted few subjects deliberately. You said that FPSC has not changed its criteria rather standard of Education has decreased. Would you with all your "civil servant" wisdom tell me how come 2014 topper failed in Essay in 2015 CSS? How come so many other allocated candidates failed essay exam in 2015 and 2013? How come only 3% of candidates could pass essay in 2013 and suddenly that ration rose to 47% in 2014 for essay paper?
( I am a lawyer so I would talk with evidence but consider this just a notice and I will give my evidence in next hearing :-) )
Now I will come to your absurd logic that PMS has such lowest criteria that those who cannot do CSS can surely do PMS..
I did not wanted to mention respected forum member but you compelled me to do so.
Following is the DMC of a PMS officer who got allocation in PMS and also passed 2016 css and just take a look at his essay marks.
Quote:
Originally Posted by neversaynever
1 ENGLISH ESSAY 100 33 PASS
2 ENGLISH (PRECIS & COMPOSITION) 100 42 PASS
3 URDU INCLUDING ESSAY 100 33 PASS
4 GENERAL KNOWLEDGE 100 56 PASS
5 PAKISTAN STUDIES 100 44 PASS
6 ISLAMIC STUDIES 100 61 PASS
7 GEOGRAPHY PAPER-I 100 71 PASS
8 GEOGRAPHY PAPER-II 100 74 PASS
9 POL. SCIENCE PAPER-I 100 52 PASS
10 POL. SCIENCE PAPER-II 100 72 PASS
11 PUNJABI PAPER-I 100 69 PASS
12 PUNJABI PAPER-II 100 76 PASS
**************************************
Written Marks Obtained: 683 / 1200 Merit No: 25
Interview Marks Obtained: 150 / 200
Overall Marks Obtained: 833 / 1400
Date: 28/04/2016
|
Now let me share with you another DMC of a potential candidate who also appeared in PMS and CSS in same year.
Quote:
Originally Posted by najambaloch
MARKS DETAIL
Sr. No. Paper Name Maximum Marks Marks Obtained Status
1 GEOGRAPHY PAPER-I 100 70 PASS
2 GEOGRAPHY PAPER-II 100 48 PASS
3 POL. SCIENCE PAPER-I 100 53 PASS
4 POL. SCIENCE PAPER-II 100 57 PASS
5 PUBLIC ADMN. PAPER-I 100 55 PASS
6 PUBLIC ADMN. PAPER-II 100 51 PASS
7 ENGLISH (PRECIS & COMPOSITION) 100 48 PASS
8 ENGLISH ESSAY 100 56 PASS
9 GENERAL KNOWLEDGE 100 36 PASS
10 ISLAMIC STUDIES 100 40 PASS
11 PAKISTAN STUDIES 100 36 PASS
12 URDU INCLUDING ESSAY 100 47 PASS
**************************************
Total Obtained Written Marks: 597 Total Written Marks: 1200 Over All Written Exam Status FA
|
And below is his CSS result
Quote:
Originally Posted by najambaloch
Going to focus on PMS for now. I won't appear in CSS exam until 2018.
Candidate Name : NAJAM UL HASSAN BALOUCH
Roll No: 19348
CNIC:
COMPULSORY SUBJECTS
Subject
Total Marks
Passing Marks
Marks Obtained
Total Marks
Accepted
English Essay 100 40 27 27 00
English (Precis and Composition) 100 40 44 44 44
General Knowledge 300 120
GK1 (General Science & Ability) 100 50
GK2 (Current Affairs) 100 49
GK3 (Pakistan Affairs) 100 57 156 156
Islamic Studies/ Comparative Study of Major Religions 100 40 65 65 65
OPTIONAL SUBJECTS
Subject
Total Marks
Passing Marks
Marks Obtained
Total Marks
Accepted
Political Science 200 66
Paper A 46
Paper B 45 91 91
Town Planning & Urban Management 100 33 33 33 33
History of Pakistan & India 100 33 49 49 49
Gender Studies 100 33 57 57 57
Geography 100 33 40 40 40
Total Marks
535
|
PMS essay exam was held on 27Dec 2015 and CSS in Feb 2016. If your logic is correct then former must have scored below 10? Because PMS is too insignificant for you. I can give you thousands example of candidates scoring less in PMS and more in CSS. Should I quote them?? But only if you promise to share your name with us.
The only point I wanted to make was that CSS has become so unpredictable that one cannot be sure what would happen. Believe me those who qualified this time ask them if they were sure? These people just wanted to make FPSC realize that it is not they who are flawed but it is their system which is flawed.
|