Should I challenge FPSC for marks?

[tadap]

Dear All,


Iam qualifier of css-2009 & stand at merit no:797. My marks in Muslim Law are 28 and in final DMC accepted marks are zero.As per my knowledge last year in 2008 amburak scored 25 in mercantile law and the marks were accepted & in 2009 roll No 1152: Scored 27 in IR and same was accepted.Now i need your valuable legal guidance whether it can be challgend or not.What are the policy parameters of FPSC. If I get these 28 marks than my final merit will be improved by atleast 200 position.


prompt response will be appreciated.

[versatile_bhutto]

Originally Posted by tadap

Dear All,


Iam qualifier of css-2009 & stand at merit no:797. My marks in Muslim Law are 28 and in final DMC accepted marks are zero.As per my knowledge last year in 2008 amburak scored 25 in mercantile law and the marks were accepted & in 2009 roll No 1152: Scored 27 in IR and same was accepted.Now i need your valuable legal guidance whether it can be challgend or not.What are the policy parameters of FPSC. If I get these 28 marks than my final merit will be improved by atleast 200 position.


prompt response will be appreciated.

in optional subjects having less than 33 r not accepted,clearly written in the FPSC rules

[tadap]

@ Bhutto

On what ground the marks of amburak in 2008 & roll no:1152 in 2009 were accepted.

[Nazik]

Check their DMCs again...they were passed but alloted zero marks in subjects with marks below 33.

plz do share ur DMC.

[Last Island]

If one fails in one optional subject and is pass in aggregate, one is declared pass.

Share your DMC.

[tadap]

Essay 40
Composition 54
EDs 58
CA 40
PA 42
Islamiat 63
Business add 58
IR 57
Journalism 52
M.Law 28 accepted 0
Sindhi 72
Sociology 64


Interview 186



@ Nazik Kindly Go through the DMCs of 2008 which was collected by one of the member of css forum.Name amburaksubject Mercantile law, marks 25 and all accepted. In css-2009 roll no 1152 who failed in written scored 27 in IR which was also accepted.I just want know, is there any rule to accept such type of marks.

[Raz]

Originally Posted by tadap

Dear All,


Iam qualifier of css-2009 & stand at merit no:797. My marks in Muslim Law are 28 and in final DMC accepted marks are zero.As per my knowledge last year in 2008 amburak scored 25 in mercantile law and the marks were accepted & in 2009 roll No 1152: Scored 27 in IR and same was accepted.Now i need your valuable legal guidance whether it can be challgend or not.What are the policy parameters of FPSC. If I get these 28 marks than my final merit will be improved by atleast 200 position.


prompt response will be appreciated.

Amubarak's marks in M Law were not counted in aggregate marks. Her total marks and merit position were calculated by excluding her M Law marks.

Click following link to see her individual paper-wise marks and aggregate marks.

http://www.cssforum.com.pk/111667-post13.html

[Farish]

@tadap

As per rules of FPSC, if you have scored below 33 marks in an optional sub then these marks are not accepted and further if your aggregate without that subject is above 600 then you are declared to be successful in the written part. But, if you have proof to prove your claim regarding the previously accepted marks, then definitely you should challenge this.

[tadap]

@ Raz

Please Go through the DMC of roll no 1152 in css 2009 who failed in written.

can I go for recounting of marks in one optional subjects? please guide.

[Raz]

Originally Posted by tadap

@ Raz

Please Go through the DMC of roll no 1152 in css 2009 who failed in written.

can I go for recounting of marks in one optional subjects? please guide.

He is fail in compulsor as well as in optional that is why he was not declared pass.

Rule: You have to pass compulsoy papers and your total in written should not be less than 600 if you wish to see yourself in pass candidates even with any failed paper in optionals.

Originally Posted by tadap

@ Raz

Please Go through the DMC of roll no 1152 in css 2009 who failed in written.

can I go for recounting of marks in one optional subjects? please guide.

FPSC has made a mistake by accepting his 27 marks in IR paper.