[QUOTE=anwaartheravian;641112]I'm also one of the victims of this hard luck. I'm on merit number 154. I committed all twelve groups in preference form. But i remained unallocated, while women of lower merit number were allocated on general seats.[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=silverfox;641152]Sir i am not confusing OMG with DMG.
I am try to explain how qouta system works.. ED first allocate punjab 86 seats male or female any which ends at no 147. After that 12 women allocated.
Now sutiablity clause means they cannot allocate the women below 150 to DMG they have to adjust them in lower groups like in OMG, railway..

For example
Merit 36 & 46 got DMG from women qouta
Because they are higher in merit
& merit 151 & 155 got OMG from general merit
(In actual 151 & 155 are women qouta and 36 & 46 are general merit they swap the groups due to sutiablity)
If you calculate you will find it
Up till 147(incl women qouta) 86 seats are given to male/female
After that 12 seats given to women

Brother hope i clear the point[/QUOTE]


Dear Silverfox, What you are trying to explain is something else and the problem here is something else even if the seats were swapped, this guy was at 154 and literally speaking he should have been allocated but merit nos.155,157,159 are allocated and its on punjab merit so if we are talking about merit seat his merit is higher than those after merit no.154....

Regards
Stay Blessed

Sir I'm 150th . This is not allocation but accomodation

Still no letters? Anyone received? Any update regarding CSA session?

[QUOTE=incounternable;641169]Dear Silverfox, What you are trying to explain is something else and the problem here is something else even if the seats were swapped, this guy was at 154 and literally speaking he should have been allocated but merit nos.155,157,159 are allocated and its on punjab merit so if we are talking about merit seat his merit is higher than those after merit no.154....

Regards
Stay Blessed[/QUOTE]
Hope seniors from last year can expain this thing better than me
also try to check this thread

[url]http://www.cssforum.com.pk/css-datesheets-results/css-result-datesheet/css-2011-exam/65540-unjust-allocations.html[/url]

many many congratulation to all those allocated in css 2012.

in KP's allocation i observed a girl at merit no 532 alloctaed to PAAS, how come she get allocated with this merit no on open merit seat leaving many in between?

[QUOTE=Islaw Khan;641292]many many congratulation to all those allocated in css 2012.

in KP's allocation i observed a girl at merit no 532 alloctaed to PAAS, how come she get allocated with this merit no on open merit seat leaving many in between?[/QUOTE]
Kindly Moderators, please answer this query. I have the same question and it is very confusing.
I request you to share any information if you have or can find any.

[QUOTE=Islaw Khan;641292]many many congratulation to all those allocated in css 2012.

in KP's allocation i observed a girl at merit no 532 alloctaed to PAAS, how come she get allocated with this merit no on open merit seat leaving many in between?[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=ShirazaH86;641342]Kindly Moderators, please answer this query. I have the same question and it is very confusing.
I request you to share any information if you have or can find any.[/QUOTE]

Dear members,please observe the merit list of KPK

14 3301 MUHAMMAD OMER KHAN-PSP
27 296 WASEEM AHMAD-DMG
30 3039 MANSOOR ARSHAD-DMG
77 11715 NEELUM SULTANA KHATTAK -DMG
83 10936 GULLANAY OMAMA-FSP
104 3648 SADIA USMAN-Customs
106 11464 MUHAMMAD IMRAN SETHI-FSP
156 3115 MUAHMMAD HUSSAIN SHAH-IRS
[B]167[/B] 12197 SYEDA WARDA BIBI-FSP [B](Women Quota)[/B]
199 10655 AMJAD HUSSAIN ZADA-IRS
194 10781 AZRA BAKHT -MLCG
213 2573 ASMA HUMAYUN -IRS
227 11004 HUDA SHAH -OMG
230 2942 JUNAID MANZOOR -IRS
272 11398 MUHAMMAD AWAIS JAVED-OMG
275 11466 MUHAMMAD IRFAN KHAN –PAAS
316 13231 MIAN USMAN ALI SHAH -OMG
326 11273 MARYAM KHALID -OMG
337 2596 ATIF RASHID KHATTAK -OMG
341 290 WAJEEHA BASHIR –OMG (Women Quota)
532 3443 NADIA USMAN -PAAS

i don't see that any unjust allocation here.... now the question is how did merit no.532 got PAAS, the thing is their preference.... after 316, I think no one had PAAS in their preference before OMG, so they were allocated OMG and remaining PAAS went to the last in merit.... Simple :))... If anyone in between 316 and 341 of KPK had PAAS in their preference before OMG, then my observation is wrong..... Otherwise I'm right...So if any of 316,326,337 and 341 is reading this post please respond...

Regards
Stay Blessed

Islaw:
I have posted this query in KP thread, but KPians didn't seem to be interested.
Did you mention all the 12 groups in preference form. And do you know other guys from KP who are above merit no. 532 and not allocated?

Incounterable:
Wardha stands at merit no 22 in KP and Nadia at merit no 40 in KP.
Here we are talking about those 16 candidates who fall in between and didn't get allocated. Islaw, I believe, is one of them. The only thing that can get Nadia (pakistan merit 532; kp merit 40) allocated is a case scenario in which all the 16 guys who are before her in merit have not given PAAS as a preference, ie , they were so confident about themselves that they didn't even care to consider PAAS as an option. And this case scenrio is beyond my comprehension.
So, Islaw, you can help solve this mystery: had u given PAAS as an option?

I'm sorry, it was not WARDHA I was talking about, it was Wajiha at merit no 341, she is 22nd and KP. There are only two women seats in KP; one FSp + one OMG. So merit no 532 has been allocated to PAAS on KP general seats.