CSS Forums

CSS Forums (http://www.cssforum.com.pk/)
-   International Law (http://www.cssforum.com.pk/css-optional-subjects/group-vi/international-law/)
-   -   Libyan Rebels were recognized as De facto or De jure ?? (http://www.cssforum.com.pk/css-optional-subjects/group-vi/international-law/51746-libyan-rebels-were-recognized-de-facto-de-jure.html)

khanbaba512 Sunday, July 17, 2011 01:59 AM

Libyan Rebels were recognized as De facto or De jure ??
 
Can anyone tell me when some countries recognized libyan rebels as the legitimate representator of libya then this recognition is considered as de facto or de jure recognition??

aariz Sunday, July 17, 2011 03:13 AM

Its de facto not de jure. coz the rebels still need legislation even though recognized by some Western states.

khanbaba512 Monday, July 18, 2011 01:20 AM

umm..Then it is recognition of belligerency or insurgency ..Right?? :thinking

aariz Monday, July 18, 2011 04:02 PM

[QUOTE=khanbaba512;331177]umm..Then it is recognition of belligerency or insurgency ..Right?? :thinking[/QUOTE]

Recognition of the both.

furqan87 Saturday, September 10, 2011 03:15 AM

3. Recognition as a rebel.This recognition is given to a group of rebels who were conducting a rebellion against his own government in a country. By providing this recognition, it does not mean the country which recognizes that siding with the rebels. The rationale of this recognition is purely humanitarian considerations. As is known, the insurgents typically make a revolt because the fight for political beliefs that differ from the government’s political beliefs that were in power. Therefore, they actually are not ordinary criminals. And that was the intent of this recognition, that is for the rebels are not treated the same as ordinary criminals. However, this recognition did not prevent authorities (government) is legitimate to quell the rebellion.
4. Recognition beligerensi. This recognition is similar to recognition as a rebel. However, the nature of this recognition is more powerful than recognition as a rebel. This recognition is given when the rebels had been so strong that as if there are two governments that are fighting. The consequence of granting this recognition, among others, beligeren can enter the port state that recognizes, can float a loan, etc..

furqan87 Saturday, September 10, 2011 03:19 AM

Recognition of rebels in Libya......
 
[QUOTE=furqan87;350553]3. Recognition as a rebel.This recognition is given to a group of rebels who were conducting a rebellion against his own government in a country. By providing this recognition, it does not mean the country which recognizes that siding with the rebels. The rationale of this recognition is purely humanitarian considerations. As is known, the insurgents typically make a revolt because the fight for political beliefs that differ from the government’s political beliefs that were in power. Therefore, they actually are not ordinary criminals. And that was the intent of this recognition, that is for the rebels are not treated the same as ordinary criminals. However, this recognition did not prevent authorities (government) is legitimate to quell the rebellion.
4. Recognition beligerensi. This recognition is similar to recognition as a rebel. However, the nature of this recognition is more powerful than recognition as a rebel. This recognition is given when the rebels had been so strong that as if there are two governments that are fighting. The consequence of granting this recognition, among others, beligeren can enter the port state that recognizes, can float a loan, etc..[/Enthusiasm is the genius of sincerity and truth accomplishes no victories without it. ]

khanbaba512 Saturday, September 10, 2011 10:44 AM

[QUOTE=furqan87;350553]3. Recognition as a rebel.This recognition is given to a group of rebels who were conducting a rebellion against his own government in a country. By providing this recognition, it does not mean the country which recognizes that siding with the rebels. The rationale of this recognition is purely humanitarian considerations. As is known, the insurgents typically make a revolt because the fight for political beliefs that differ from the government’s political beliefs that were in power. Therefore, they actually are not ordinary criminals. And that was the intent of this recognition, that is for the rebels are not treated the same as ordinary criminals. However, this recognition did not prevent authorities (government) is legitimate to quell the rebellion.
4. Recognition beligerensi. This recognition is similar to recognition as a rebel. However, the nature of this recognition is more powerful than recognition as a rebel. This recognition is given when the rebels had been so strong that as if there are two governments that are fighting. The consequence of granting this recognition, among others, beligeren can enter the port state that recognizes, can float a loan, etc..[/QUOTE]

Now that Qadhafi is gone..What will be the status of the recognition??

kamran_shaikh Thursday, October 13, 2011 06:22 PM

For a span of time the new government will be rocgnized as a de facto.if the government of libya under new administration fulfills the duties pertaining to law and order situation along with normal relationships with the citizens and stabilize itself, it will soon be rocognized as de jure. It depends upon the capability of the new administration as to whether it will promt the international community to regard it de jure or not.


05:42 AM (GMT +5)

vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.