let us first revise and compare the rules for ce 2012 and ce 2013
CE-2012
ce-2013
now let us see what factors are involved to pass the whole exam.
there are four factors :
A . compulsory subject
B. optional subject
C. aggregate
D. viva voce
to pass the written and get interview call the conditions A,B,C are to be checked only. viva is a later process. so we ignore that on this stage .
let us make Truth Tables for the ce-2012 and ce-2013 and see what should be the criterion to pass as per stated rules .
for ce 2012 the condition is
"atleast 40% marks in any compulsory subject, 33% marks in any of
the optional subjects, or 50% marks in the Aggregate"
so the Boolean function should be " A and B or C"
for ce 2013 the condition is
"at least 40% marks in any compulsory subject, 33% marks in any of
the optional subjects, 50% marks in the Aggregate "
so the Boolean function should be " A and B and C"
you can see that fpsc violated its own rules in 2012 and in previous years ( according to what they said on their rules section.)
for example ,they were wrong at failing the candidates who passed 50% aggregate no matter what status they had in compulsory . Also they were wrong at failing those who passed
all compulsory and all optional but got less than 50 % aggregate . ( you may seek help on Boolean functions from a philosopher or mathematician , because if "words " make "rules " then this above mentioned hypothesis will help you a lot in case you file a lawsuit or have a personal hearing )
ce-2013 rule according to Boolean function is very simple
its states that to get pass all three conditions need to get satisfied ,otherwise you shall be declared fail ( this is what happened to you . that this time they strictly followed the rule and went against the traditional customary law)
the long and short of this story is that their rules prior to 2013 were ambiguous . so you and the candidates of ce-2013 must get the benefit of doubt .
PS. to learn about truth tables ( which actually are very easy) see wikipedia and
http://turner.faculty.swau.edu/mathe...library/truth/