View Single Post
  #25  
Old Sunday, September 23, 2007
Mazher's Avatar
Mazher Mazher is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Karachi
Posts: 390
Thanks: 2
Thanked 98 Times in 82 Posts
Mazher is on a distinguished road
Default

@ Asma Choudhary

Quote:
Assalamualikum!
Wa-alai-ku-m-u-salam

Quote:
I think discussion with any authentic scholar is also a type of research
Totally agreed .......


Quote:
i said k discuss it with someone who is sahib-e-raai
Here My confusion arises that: "Who is The Sahib-e-Raey?"

Quote:
As there is only 1 Allah, 1Prophet(S.A.W), 1 Ummah, 1 Quran

U r absolutely right


Quote:
then why so many differences...????

in my opinion ........ Dependency on other people like "Mulla-s" about Religion instead of searching Quran & Hadith myself

This is my fault sister....... that Mulla has created so confusions in same matters by also following the same parameteres (Same Quran, Hadith, Fiqa and Shariyah etc.)

BOlay to......... "Qasai (Butcher) b bakray par chhuri tab chalata hay jab log usay khatay hein"

If I would b supposed 2 hav knowledge bout Religion as it is my duty, no one can misguide me.

Coz Rasool-ullah (SAW) said:

"Talab-ul-ilm-i-fareeza-tu-n-ala-kull-i-muslim"

and:

"Khairu-kum-man-ta-alla-mal-Quran-a-wa-allama-hu"

Quote:
I didn’t impose my point of view on anyone
very right

Quote:
I feel fear while discussing such debatable issues
When u hav Quran then why do u so shy?

Quote:
this would be definitely revealed at any particular instance..
Absolutely right..... (Revealed in Makka)

Quote:
what is the context behind this?
Allah Pak discussed about His Prophethood in last Sura and about Himself (Tauheed) in these verses.

He said:

"Tabarak-alla-zi bi-yadi-hil mulk"

(Pak hay wo zaat jis k hathh Badshahat hay)

He arrogantly counts His Powers in this Surah that:

1) He is absolute Commander (Qadir-e-Mutlaq)
2) The best Creator

He emphasises on His creative ability by admiring the formation of Skies and invites criticism on his creation from His creation (Insaan).

Message is for research.... just invitation to criticize the Best One..... U will go with ur full mental and critic approach....... but result will b Nil.....

Muslims hav problem to enterprete Quran like this case...... They used to say that ..... Allah Almighty created the Best ...... and there is no need to find out the defficiencies as we know the result announced by Quran.... No defficiency.....

Dear,

The basic objective of these Quranic verses is to prepare man for Research & Development. His invitation "to find out His Defficiencies" is actually guidance of the path " to excel our efficiencies"

If we couldn't pick the real message, it will be harmful for us.

May Allah Almighty give us power to understand His Sayings truly

(Wallah-u-a-a-la-mu-bissa-wab)

Regards

Mazhar
Reply With Quote