It will be a sheer disappointment and intellectual failure of country's policy makers if this scheme would be implemented. First of All, the competition will be shifted from general to group by group. It'd cast a far reaching, long term effects. Presently, after 19th grade, officers may be given any service in any group, no matter what is his specialized group. But once, this scheme is implemented, there would be no reshuffling. Consequently, there will be mismanagement as a result of want of diversity. Secondly, less seats will be available for, the recruitment will be on group basis. It would not only shatter the confidence of the candidates but also result in failure of the most of the candidates.