Well, there are people who fail in their first attempt and pass in the second one. or even their third attempt. When failing in the first attempt doesnt stop candidates from making it in their second or third, then how does this make it an obligation that if somebody has PAS or FSP in their first attempts cant fail their next one?

The only best attempt is the one which takes you to CSA. There is no different opinion about it. May be the candidates failed to give their best... Perhaps they didnt attempt their papers the way they did it in their first attempts...

Instead of making these assumptions, we should all focus on our aim. If you will keep thinking that there is a bad, rotten system out there, ready to grab you just like that, then you will never make it. You know the rules for attempting essay paper plus all others. You have enough material to learn from, either provided by the successful ones, or the ones who couldnt make it. Make use of it and stop thinking negative. Or it will bog you down!