Every person seems to marketing his/her own group rather than telling pro and contra of group. Moreover commissioner system has nt been restored in Punjab yet ,so how DMG has been reverted???
If you ask from PSP / FSP / Customs guys they also exaggerate things.
Which one is Top preferred group varies from person to person and keep changing from year to year. Even sometimes top position dont go for DMG/PSP rather they prefer FSP/Custom.

[QUOTE=asif_ijaz78;376671]Every person seems to marketing his/her own group rather than telling pro and contra of group. Moreover commissioner system has nt been restored in Punjab yet ,so how DMG has been reverted???
If you ask from PSP / FSP / Customs guys they also exaggerate things.
Which one is Top preferred group varies from person to person and keep changing from year to year. Even sometimes top position dont go for DMG/PSP rather they prefer FSP/Custom.[/QUOTE]

Fully agreed

Correction....
 

@ asif_ijaz78
@ Mr.Hashmi

As far as Punjab is concerned, DMG was the first preference of almost all the candidates. Go for the group of your choice, but don't make irresponsible and naive statements here.
As far as your query about the commissioner system is concerned, a half-backed commissioner system is in vogue in Punjab which is hardly different from the one in Sindh.

[QUOTE=DEVOLUTION GEEK;376822]@ asif_ijaz78
@ Mr.Hashmi

As far as Punjab is concerned, DMG was the first preference of almost all the candidates. Go for the group of your choice, but don't make irresponsible and naive statements here.
As far as your query about the commissioner system is concerned, a half-backed commissioner system is in vogue in Punjab which is hardly different from the one in Sindh.[/QUOTE]

U mean to say all the toppers had been allocated to Psp group against their first preference in previous years, which was DMG according to u. What a joke sir

[QUOTE=Mr hashmi;376945]U mean to say all the toppers had been allocated to Psp group against their first preference in previous years, which was DMG according to u. What a joke sir[/QUOTE]

Dear! You are misquoting me. I never wrote that all the candidates chose DMG as their first preference. I said that "almost all" not "all" candidates went for DMG. Read my post again. Yes, a few candidates opted for PSP or FSP as their first choice, but this doesn't change the overall preference criteria.

[QUOTE=DEVOLUTION GEEK;377127]Dear! You are misquoting me. I never wrote that all the candidates chose DMG as their first preference. I said that "almost all" not "all" candidates went for DMG. Read my post again. Yes, a few candidates opted for PSP or FSP as their first choice, but this doesn't change the overall preference criteria.[/QUOTE]

Dear have a look at allocations of 2009/08/07/ and so on , PSP was preferred over DMG.Its in 2010 trend went to DMG

[QUOTE=asif_ijaz78;377156]Dear have a look at allocations of 2009/08/07/ and so on , PSP was preferred over DMG.Its in 2010 trend went to DMG[/QUOTE]
I have been reading comments on this forum quietly for the last few months, finally today i have joined the forum because the confusions being promoted on this forum got too much as far as I think.

I am surprised to see you guys discussing on such small things, most of you have not even spent a single day in the field and making such big statements as if no one around knows better than you.

Being a senior by several years, let me make one thing very clear that things are not the way these appear on their face. Most of the members on this forum have been discussing and sometimes even making really rude statements. Dear all PSP and DMG both are really good groups, you cant compare these groups coz nature of job in both cases is totally different. It would be really unfair to compare these 2 groups, rather they cant be even compared. Remember one thing when groups are opted in CSS exam, ofcourse candidates do not know about the ground realities of PSP or DMG, for me the true decision can be made by discussing the matter with almost 10 officers (5 from DMG & 5 from PSP), these 10 officers must have a job experience of around 10 years. I think then you will be able to make a right choice according to your aptitude. I opted for PSP on its face value;, gun men, uniform,cars and salutes all that attracted me...but believe me "all that glitters is not gold" so please stop making irresponsible statements against any group, no doubt DMG/PSP are the top groups but which group ended where in which year doesnt let down or promotes the other group. I can write 100 pages on the pros n cons of both groups n hopefully from time to time i'll keep on writing something about these 2 groups, so that prospective CSS qualifiers can make a right choice.

Moreover I am really curious to know about the Occupational Group of our honorable member [B]"Mr Hashmi"[/B] e.g PSP,PCS,PMS or what? I have been reading his comments, would like to know the experience and knowledge of his

Sir Nadeem
You r really angel in Psp group, I would dare say, I have not seen good natured, humble n God fearing officer like you in whole of the police force.

Sir I have honour of being your subordinate.