Result of Candidates of Sindh
 

I'm find myself speechless and shocked to find out that only [B]"35" [/B]candidates have qualified out [B]"1904" [/B]students that applied from Sindh Province, that is just 1.83% of total candidature.......... And I fell that Something is seriously wrong wither with "The Candidates or The Great Great FPSC".

Who is to be blamed for this all???


[url]http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs157.snc4/37171_481950611809_693216809_6896843_216820_n.jpg[/url]


[ATTACH]3728[/ATTACH]

I ws disappointed to see that my roll number and name was not in de list of successful candidates but i am shocked to know that some of very hardworking friends of mine who were supposed to be most favorite and many of whom were giving their 3rd attempt also were retrogressed. who is to be blamed for this all?????????????

Sindh hv quota ov around 135 seats apart from those which are carried every year....... this time it is de most number ov candidates that hv applied to appear in CSS exam nd they r welcome in such a pathetic way so that no one shud dare nd think ov getting into this field. its a very pessimistic nd a dark result to discourage de youth, which vl take FPSC no where nd I find this system scattering all around. specially since Mr. Rana BhagwanDas has taken the charge over. Thank U Mr. Bhagwandas for proving yourself as a failed and ill administrator by ruining de precious year of nearly de entire Sindh candidature.

[QUOTE=Naveed_Bhuutto;226011]I ws disappointed to see that my roll number and name was not in de list of successful candidates but i am shocked to know that some of very hardworking friends of mine who were supposed to be most favorite and many of whom were giving their 3rd attempt also retrogressed.[/QUOTE]

Its really inexplicable that 1.8% candidates are declared successful from sindh.
Although,I am also one among the failures yet hopes are high for next attempt.

But the thing is making me upset is that one csp stated that it could be conspiracy theory for augmenting the failure ratio of sindh.

We can't fight with our fate brother
lets wait for our turn,Inshallah one day we will be successful.
Bus Allah ki raza pe khush hona chahiyeh.

Regards,

To Be Fair though Naveed Sindh usually has a poor result in CSS.I think Most talented chaps from Sindh don't like civil Service and go into other professions.Still my viewpoint and not backed up by any statistics.That's is a lovely chart by the way :thumbup:

[QUOTE=Mansoor 1983;226014]To Be Fair though Naveed Sindh usually has a poor result in CSS.I think Most talented chaps from Sindh don't like civil Service and go into other professions.Still my viewpoint and not backed up by any statistics.That's is a lovely chart by the way :thumbup:[/QUOTE]

yes brother agreed wd ur point that many peoples ov sindh get into other fields nd dnt like CSS vcuz de passing ratio always hurt them...... but it never had been de worst as it has been today.......

i gave up ma Job infact a very gud job, ma friends, ma family nd my hobbies nd prepared myself wd 100% dedication wd only one dream to see ma name in de list ov successful candiates ov CSS 2010 as i wud be de 1st person in ma family to do it in 1st attempt. lekin result anai k baad yaar meri tau shorain mujhai un doston ka bhi dukh ho raha hia jo becharai genius kehlatai thai.............. nd yet they were unable to make it..........:sad::sad::sad::sad::sad:... this is one ov de sadest day ov my life............

[QUOTE=Waqar Abro;226013]Its really inexplicable that 1.8% candidates are declared successful from sindh.
Although,I am also one among the failures yet hopes are high for next attempt.

But the thing is making me upset is that one csp stated that it could be conspiracy theory for augmenting the failure ratio of sindh.

We can't fight with our fate brother
lets wait for our turn,Inshallah one day we will be successful.
Bus Allah ki raza pe khush hona chahiyeh.

Regards,[/QUOTE]

I am Shocked
I am Shocked
nd I am Shocked

kisi kai marnai par bhi laug itni dil jawai nahi kartai hoongai jitni aaj mera result anai k baad logon nai mujhse ki hia............
its one ov de saddest nd toughest day ov ma life..........

[QUOTE=Naveed_Bhuutto;226017]yes brother agreed wd ur point that many peoples ov sindh get into other fields nd dnt like CSS vcuz de passing ratio always hurt them...... but it never had been de worst as it has been today.......

i gave up ma Job infact a very gud job, ma friends, ma family nd my hobbies nd prepared myself wd 100% dedication wd only one dream to see ma name in de list ov successful candiates ov CSS 2010 as i wud be de 1st person in ma family to do it in 1st attempt. lekin result anai k baad yaar meri tau shorain mujhai un doston ka bhi dukh ho raha hia jo becharai genius kehlatai thai.............. nd yet they were unable to make it..........:sad::sad::sad::sad::sad:... this is one ov de sadest day ov my life............[/QUOTE]

cheer up bro.If it's any consolation, i have passed and i was always regarded as the idiot amongst my friends:angry: and my friends aren't amongst the ten greatest minds in history to be honest.If you have youth on your side, you can do anything, as regards to the plight of your friends, the reality is in CSS you can have 11 top papers and one terrible one and you will be failed, so perhaps Islamiat or perhaps some other subject has drowned your friends.I would humbly suggest to take this as a yard stick, you have already made many sacrifices, only one more is to try for 2011 attempt and make sure the next topper is from Sindh, cheer up bro whatever happened yesterday has no bearing on what happens tomorrow if we don't let it.

Also have you made one of those nifty charts for KPK, i want to know how many of us took part and how many were passed.Thanks in advance

[QUOTE=Mansoor 1983;226019]I would humbly suggest to take this as a yard stick, you have already made many sacrifices, only one more is to try for 2011 attempt and make sure the next topper is from Sindh, cheer up bro whatever happened yesterday has no bearing on what happens tomorrow if we don't let it.
[/QUOTE]

thanx u for ur laudatory words for boosting ma spirits brother, and yes! fore sure i would never let it go so easily. I vl work even more harder infact I'm working even more harder this tym for 2011 attempt nd hopefully i vl see ma name atleast in de list ov successful aspirants if not de topper. Ceteris paribus if Rana Bhagwandas nd FPSC dnt find ma words too harsh for them. but I honestly feel something is going wrong somewhere. May Allah give us de courage to put up a winning fight after this losing show.

[QUOTE=Naveed_Bhuutto;226018]I am Shocked
I am Shocked
nd I am Shocked

kisi kai marnai par bhi laug itni dil jawai nahi kartai hoongai jitni aaj mera result anai k baad logon nai mujhse ki hia............
its one ov de saddest nd toughest day ov ma life..........[/QUOTE]

Agar humare Nabi,Buzrig,wali,aur Aalim es society ka shikaar ban sakty hain then we are nothing though.

Put dust over their statements and work hard for your next attempt.
Inshallah i will be with you in that boat:pipe

@ Naveed Bhutto

First of all, do not loose your hope and keep your commitment constant. We expect your victory in coming attempt.

See the history of Toppers from Sindh. You can learn a lesson of patience, consistency and commitment from them:

Fida Hussain Shah All Pakistan Top in his 3rd attempt and fail in 1st, 2nd.
Irfan Samo Sindh Top and 6th in open merit in his 3rd attempt. Fail in 1st and 2nd.



Your effort to compile the result of Sindh is a nice step. Number of successful candidates as per your calculation might vary with +/- 5 to 8 because you have not accounted for the candidates appearing from Punjab and other provinces on Sindh domicile, likewise, candidates appearing from Sindh on domicile of other provinces. In past ratio of Sindhi candidates for preparation in Lahore/Islamabad based CSS preparatory academies has been on increasing trend and due to their study sphere/group studies and availability of relevant material and guidance they opted for Lahore/Islamabad exam centers.
So there is a possibility of around 40 successful candidates on Sindh Domicile.


Regards

Wish you good luck.

@ waqar abro nd Razz
 

[QUOTE=Waqar Abro;226024]Agar humare Nabi,Buzrig,wali,aur Aalim es society ka shikaar ban sakty hain then we are nothing though.

Put dust over their statements and work hard for your next attempt.
Inshallah i will be with you in that boat:pipe[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=Raz;226034]@ Naveed Bhutto

First of all, do not loose your hope and keep your commitment constant. We expect your victory in coming attempt.

See the history of Toppers from Sindh. You can learn a lesson of patience, consistency and commitment from them:

Fida Hussain Shah All Pakistan Top in his 3rd attempt and fail in 1st, 2nd.
Irfan Samo Sindh Top and 6th in open merit in his 3rd attempt. Fail in 1st and 2nd.



Your effort to compile the result of Sindh is a nice step. Number of successful candidates as per your calculation might vary with +/- 5 to 8 because you have not accounted for the candidates appearing from Punjab and other provinces on Sindh domicile, likewise, candidates appearing from Sindh on domicile of other provinces. In past ratio of Sindhi candidates for preparation in Lahore/Islamabad based CSS preparatory academies has been on increasing trend and due to their study sphere/group studies and availability of relevant material and guidance they opted for Lahore/Islamabad exam centers.
So there is a possibility of around 40 successful candidates on Sindh Domicile.


Regards

Wish you good luck.[/QUOTE]



I really thanx both ov u from de bottom ov ma heart for ur corroboration. 1st ov all tau we all are onn for de 2011 attempt nd hope fuly it vl bring us some joy nd felicity next year. Yes i too hv de name ov these two pplz in ma mind. Irfan Samo de last year topper ws giving his heart out since so many years nd he appeared with his 1st attempt in 2007. finally topped sindh in his 3rd attempt in 2009.

regarding Fida Hussain Shah, brother i personally have met him and according to him it ws his 2nd attempt as he conked out to pass his 1st attempt due to lapse in geography.

are these figures under sindh domicile or is this the data of those who appeared from sindh??

@ Sidra
 

these r de candidates that applied from sindh..........

i applied from lahore but i have a sindh urban domicile, there would be many more cases like this also

yes for sure there wud be many cases lekin phir bhi kitnai hongai???
2,4,5 ya max 10...........

@ Naveed

First of all, don't lose hope. I failed my first attempt by scoring 5 less marks in English Essay. But tried again and cleared my written part this time.

Secondly, when you receive your DMC, you should then analyse your mistakes and weaknesses. Plan systematically to over come your weaknesses.

Thirdly, there is no exact pattern of CSS exam papers. You should be overall confident enough to answer the given questions and concentrate on what is actually asked and stick to it. For that, you do not have to rely only on prescribed books or notes. Read any type of material and books that would help you gain knowledge. REMEMBER, even if you fail CSS exam, you have gained more knowledge than any other person who did not appear in the exam.

Fourthly, plan systematically and accordingly. Go into past papers section in this forum and look into repeated questions threads for every module. Make a list of it and prepare small points to remember the answers.

Fifth, use youtube and other resources available to you, because this will help you not only to understand the concepts in a better way but, it will also stick to the back of your memory.

Remember, there is a difference between ordinary Hard Work and systematic Hard Work.

Good luck for your next try.

Assalam O Alaikum,

Hearty Congrats to the passers and wish others best of luck in their future attempts and endeavors. I failed two consecutive attempts of CSS back in 2003 & 2004 but never lost patience and tried my luck in almlost every exam that came in my way. A rigorous CSS study has helped me to get a decent job which I have been doing since last two years and recently passed Combined Competitive Examination. All of my friends who prepared for CSS with me have acquired good jobs either through FPSC or SPSC and others. The motive behind depicting this historiography of mine is to motivate those capable youngsters who could not get through due to the elements of luck and mistakes in CSS 2009. Be brave and don't lose heart because brave ultimately muddles through the difficult times. Allah Hafiz

Thank you for posting such an encouraging post : )

@candidates from sindh
 

Friends
This was also my last attempt and honestly speaking I was very sure I will make it this time but my no wasnt in the list.
Am waiting desperately 4 DMC
I would also request tht u folks dont lose hope as i think something can b done abt it.
Firstly, the failures in CSS 2008 due to aggregate r in court. Barrister zameer ghumro is pleading their case and the plea is tht practice of aggregate shud be relaxed 4 Sindh bcoz evry yr lot of vacancies go unfilled and the policy shud be brought at par with tht of 80 when simply passing was enough.
Secondly, many qualifiers also cleared CSS 2009 so expect lesser candidates to fill the 2010 slots than Mr Bhutto points out.
Thirdly, i feel the conspiracy theory for mark deduction should also be probed more.
I request again DONT LOSE HOPE

Stunned!
 

Nothing can console the courageous candidates from Indus Valley for their agony and crippled fate unless they themselves strive for overcoming it. I am an amateur in the CSS arena but I have witnessed the painstaking patience of those awaiting their results as well as their jubilant and flamboyant moods when they were proclaimed victorious. I am appalled as well. While it is true that all is well if end is well, i.e If result is positive, you forgive the pains suffered during preparation. However, I remember something my teacher once told me when I didn't fetch any distinction in college debate competition. He said,
"Honour lies in struggle, not in achievment."
I remind this to myself in every contest I participate. The purpose of stating it here is nothing but encouraging and rejuvenating my fellow patriots from southern region. Being an aspirant for the upcoming exam in feb;2010, I empathize with everyone out there who has been bestowed with a chance to take this exam.


Regards,

@ all
 

CSS quota system
Friday, 11 , 2009
THE CSS is the topmost examination in terms of competition in Pakistan. Recruitment is made on the basis of open merit and the provincial quota system. The latter is the exclusive proportion as well as the right of the provinces.

As a matter of fact, the quota in Sindh witnessed around 80 vacant seats till the allocation in 2008. These seats are placed in the provincial quota. Owing to the lack of qualified candidates in the province, the seats remain unoccupied.

History reveals that during the 1970s, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, the then prime minister, had ordered the allocation of aggregate failures against vacant seats because they are the exclusive right of candidates belonging to the same province. Similarly, the case is before the law.

In the CSS 2008 examinations, a multitude of candidates from Sindh failed in the aggregate.

Barrister Zamir Hussain Ghumro, after a thought-provoking analysis, has found the provision for the allocation of aggregate failures against vacant seats.

Senator Moula Bux has also taken the case to put it up in the Senate. In this connection, the Supreme Court is requested to take suo motu notice of the matter.

Moreover, President Asif Ali Zardari must look into the matter, keeping in view the legal provision and discretionary powers to allocate seats to aggregate failures.

@naveed.
Dont lose hope. Refine your skills. Put ur maximum effort in the next attempt.

regards

Dear Moderators and all those who use this website!

How many candidates have qualified css-2010 written part from Sindh Urban?

I am unable to download the list of successful candidates from the FPSC website.

[QUOTE=fahadfa;226423]Dear Moderators and all those who use this website!

How many candidates have qualified css-2010 written part from Sindh Urban?

I am unable to download the list of successful candidates from the FPSC website.[/QUOTE]

Here is the [URL="http://www.cssforum.com.pk/css-datesheets-results/css-result-datesheet/css-2010-exam/39750-ce-2010-result-announced.html"]list[/URL]

@Fahadfa

Only 32 candidates have cleared from Sindh Urban according to the list, the real number might be lower as quite a few candidates from Sindh Rural often opt Karachi as their examination center.

And No one from our academy has cleared according to my knowledge, quite shocking to know, even I failed, but I guess I wasn't meant to be a CSP.

Fahad have you passed?

Dear Silent Volcano! Your list does not show whether the candidates are from Sindh (rural) or Sindh Urban or from Punjab or...

@Mansoor: no

[QUOTE=vicky786;226534]

Only 32 candidates have cleared from Sindh Urban according to the list, the real number might be lower as quite a few candidates from Sindh Rural often opt Karachi as their examination center.

And No one from our academy has cleared according to my knowledge, quite shocking to know, even I failed, but I guess I wasn't meant to be a CSP.[/QUOTE]

Vicky! 32 passed candidates from Sindh [B][SIZE="4"]Urban alone[/SIZE][/B], is quite an acceptable figure, since about the same number passed from Sindh Urban last year.

But what I dont understand is that, if this trend continues, then I wonder who is going to fill in the vacant seats collecting year after year! Nobody is probably going to let , say, Punjab or Baluchistan, to fill in the Sindh seats (just a little food for thought)

and even if they let Sindh Rural fill in the Sindh Urban seats, then according to my information, there are vacant seats even in Sindh Rural (remaining after all the occupants have taken their places) : so who is going to fill that?

[QUOTE=fahadfa;226614]Vicky! 32 passed candidates from Sindh [B][SIZE=4]Urban alone[/SIZE][/B], is quite an acceptable figure, since about the same number passed from Sindh Urban last year.

But what I dont understand is that, if this trend continues, then I wonder who is going to fill in the vacant seats collecting year after year! Nobody is probably going to let , say, Punjab or Baluchistan, to fill in the Sindh seats (just a little food for thought)[/QUOTE]

32 for Sindh-U is not a correct figure. Actual number is much lower than 32 in Sindh Urban.

Dear Raz! Test centre does not matter! It is the domicile that matters. I think if a Punjabi living in sindh since ages has a Sindh Rural domicile, then he wil fill the Sindh Rural quota seat and not a Punjab quota seat.

Dear Everyone!

I am being unable to download the list of successful candidates of css-2010 from the FPSC website, can somebody email it to me at [email]fahad18g@yahoo.com[/email] ??

[QUOTE=fahadfa;226667]Dear Raz! Test centre does not matter! It is the domicile that matters. I think if a Punjabi living in sindh since ages has a Sindh Rural domicile, then he wil fill the Sindh Rural quota seat and not a Punjab quota seat.

Dear Everyone!

I am being unable to download the list of successful candidates of css-2010 from the FPSC website, can somebody email it to me at [EMAIL="fahad18g@yahoo.com"]fahad18g@yahoo.com[/EMAIL] ??[/QUOTE]

Brother: I know about domicile. See my post which is already available on the same issue: [URL]http://www.cssforum.com.pk/226034-post10.html[/URL]

Salam brothers,

Css results have always been unpredictable . Honestly, I have seen a lot of very competitive students failing from Punjab ( a lot of them had more than 700 marks in written ) .. Still they failed because of only one subjects .. Hamare sindh k bhai please dil chota mat kare .. Allah aap ki mehnat ko zaya nahi honay de ga .. bus dil laga kr 2011 ki attempt k lie tayari karain with special focus on english essay .. I had the opportunity to study with many sindhi friends (more than 10 ) and believe me sab ko english main buhat mehnat karna pari .. Bus english par focus kare , Allah next attempt main guaranteed allocation de ga.. You see a lot of students from Punjab are unable to get allocations despite passing the written .. so just dont get dicouraged .. Allah ne shayad isi main ap logo k lie behtari rkhi ho .. Finally , I would like to add that a huge number of students from Sindh study in Lahore , and so give there exams here .. so the number of candidates passing from Sindh ll be much higher than 35 Inshallah ..

One thing which I found very disturbing about css2010 was that the candidature of around 200 students was rejected !

[QUOTE=Bilal Salim;226702]Salam brothers,

Css results have always been unpredictable . Honestly, I have seen a lot of very competitive students failing from Punjab ( a lot of them had more than 700 marks in written ) .. Still they failed because of only one subjects .. Hamare sindh k bhai please dil chota mat kare .. Allah aap ki mehnat ko zaya nahi honay de ga .. bus dil laga kr 2011 ki attempt k lie tayari karain with special focus on english essay .. I had the opportunity to study with many sindhi friends (more than 10 ) and believe me sab ko english main buhat mehnat karna pari .. Bus english par focus kare , Allah next attempt main guaranteed allocation de ga.. You see a lot of students from Punjab are unable to get allocations despite passing the written .. so just dont get dicouraged .. Allah ne shayad isi main ap logo k lie behtari rkhi ho .. Finally , I would like to add that a huge number of students from Sindh study in Lahore , and so give there exams here .. so the number of candidates passing from Sindh ll be much higher than 35 Inshallah ..[/QUOTE]


I agree with Bilal, Although Sindhi (interior) guys are really very hard working yet they have weaker English due to deficiency in primary education. Situation is alarming when we have only 35 candidates from whole Sindh but picture is not clear, have patience.

Failure is first step toward success, always remember "[I]Hope for the best but plan for the worst.[/I]"

Regards,

17 from urban passed n 21 frm rural

poor sindhi candidates
 

well i am from pano akil sukkur sindh and only girl in my town who dared to give css. but bad luck i might be ray of hope.i think sindhi student are ignorable even no one from sukkur result is so much worse this time than ever before.i think we should change our domicile applied for punjab domicile it might help us but it is css so fair exam well better luck next time pray for me::blush:

is it confirmed, i mean + _ 5 to hosakta hai

do anyone knows, how many girls have qualified from sindh

[QUOTE=rizvan;226744]17 from urban passed n 21 frm rural[/QUOTE]

Can this be confirmed ????????

plz tell me that where my interveiw would be conducted if i have a sindh urban domicile but appeared from center lahore,

Isn't the passing ratio very low? And what is this? NO one from Sukkur?