I myself have witnessed the sifarish culture in the most acclaimed sifarish proof fpsc :p it was very disappointing for me as i thought it was the only institution above sifarish.and those people have secured prominent merit numbers :p after all ITS PAKISTAN . No offence to anyone!

Merit No. 16
Written 741, Inerview 188
Essay 40 That was close :p
Precis 46 Could be 50+
PA 64
CA 66
EDS 61 I thought EDS was my strength
Islamiat 56

Optionals
Forestry 81 (Msc and Bsc)
IHC 78 & 69
Socio 63
I. Law 58
Pashto 59 Pushto should have been at par with punjabi in terms of marks.

Yet, I am extremely grateful to Almighty Allah for bestowing this success upon me in my first attempt with a short preparation period. Shukar Alhamdolillah

__________________
"I strictly disagree with what you say, but I will defend your right to say it untill my death"

Sad Story:
Roll Number 49:
Merit:445

Essay: 50
English: 73
GK: 153
EDS: 63
PA:47
CA:43
Islamiat:63

Optional:

Business Ad: 53(18 MCQs were correct)
Indo Pak1:42
Indo Pak2:46
IR: 41
Philosophy 1: 71
Philosophy2: 63



Total in written: 655
Interview:142(I simply can not believe it... My interview was fantastic..I have been teaching tricks of giving professional,appealing and impressive interviews to my students for last three years... Essay and English marks suggest i am good in communication skills..... Anyways what else can i do except sharing it with dear forum members)
[/SIZE]

Plz read it too
I second you. I was born in Lyari area of karachi and i was brought up there. My education is from the same area from govt school. RBD asked me about it and i confidently replied and satisfied him. Lyari is known for crimes and drugs as its the most backward area of the country. My written score was 698 but still I was given 192, which is not that bad. so i dont agree in any claim of biasness or Sifarish or perchi system in these interviews. Everyone knows what and where did.he go wrong? So I request not to defame the prestigious panel please.
One more thing here, on my interview day there was a guy whose father was a retired secretary from DMG and serving advisor to chief minister, another was son of serving IG Police, another was son of a custom officer, then one from very high class feudal family full of csps. But Usman khalid was the top scorer of interview on that day and i stand second in interview marks on the same day. My father was a fire driver in fire brigade and he is not alive same is the case with Usman his father also not alive and he is also feom middle class. He stood 22nd in Pakistan and im 70. If you ask me about my perchi and Sifarish, it was ALLAH yes it was ALLAH Not any IG DIG OR DCO. Be positive and have trust in Allah.
Better luck next time

__________________
Wa tu izzo mann tasha'o wa tu zillo mann tasha'o

Nasrullah Yousafzai

Mr.Abbassi was with us in psychological.He is a blind fellow but he is so impressive in every form.He has only one preference i.e FSP and he got one.

Congratulation to all Qualifiers
Especially to Nasrullah
please tell about IR preparation and books.

please tell about IR preparation and books.

__________________
"Dreams" are not those which are seen during sleep.
Dreams are those which 'll never let you sleep.

The humble above mentioned candidates had surely got good marks in interview. Where they didnt score were written marks.You can proudly claim that you have got good marks but you cannot euphemistically deny that there is no sifarish culture, it is there which is very strong indeed. We cannot imagine how in such cut throat competition even one mark matters. My friend who qualified in 2009 told me that she did not have any wrong answer in interview and even then she was given low marks in interview and a son of IG or DIG was given highest marks in interview though he has low marks in written portion. We have witnessed the same trend in 2010 and 2011 and dont know for how many more years to come.

Very good if you are from lyari lets see what will you do for lyari after becoming chief secretary of Sindh. good luck.

Well first of all I must clarify that interview marks are not awarded only for correct answers of question. they want to check your confidence, ability for a specific group, personality and most of all your analytical skills. If at this level an aspirants speaks about the number of rite and wrong answers it for sure shows lack of maturity. and the panel.is very rite to send him back to the process for further maturity.

__________________
Wa tu izzo mann tasha'o wa tu zillo mann tasha'o

Nasrullah Yousafzai

Yes it was her maturity level that now she is assistant commissioner karachi. she was the top student of her class. and every where she scored top marks.

Well the credit goes to the panel which pushed her to refine her capabilities and see now she is AC. Thats what i explained that the panel analyse you and sometime resend you to the process. now if we follow your theory then Isn't it contradiction? She failed because she did not have perchi or sifarish but now she is AC, must have found some perchi this time around, rite????
Brother i believe that talent makes its own way and nobody can stop it by any means. best of luck to you and to her too. JazakAllah

__________________
Wa tu izzo mann tasha'o wa tu zillo mann tasha'o

Nasrullah Yousafzai