A very shocking news! So disappointing... Just because of few culprits all the other hard working student's career is on the brink of being ruined. How pathetic!

Well I think the rules for deducting marks on overwriting and untidiness in paper would apply and culprits would get the iron hand they deserve, unless they had blank FPSC answer-sheets as well on which they re-wrote answers . No retaking of examination seems possible and as some members pointed out, this maybe a breaking news for media (which is why they use lingo like commission ko hila ke rakha dia ) and many people, but this must have been happening in the past (which is why overwriting rules are placed)

__________________
The precondition for existence of a higher humanity is not the state, but the nation possessing the necessary ability.

I do not now what rules FPSC or FIA have to follow here or what are the possible punishments associated to this crime..

But i have to say that integrity of FPSC and CSS is at stake.SO,culprits should be made an example and possibly be banned from holding any public office throughout their life....There should be no room for in any kind of public office for these fraudsters and cheaters....!!

I hope these are exacly the words of law for this matter...

I guess there is also need to check paper handling and transferring mechanism...FPSC must have their own transportation system for this purpose..The sanctity of this examination should be preserved because fortunes of individuals and our country as well depend on it..There is no need to outsource this job to Post Office at this point of time when corruption is rapid in every department and in our society as a whole

__________________
"If we don't stand for something, we may fall for anything."

Bad idea, it would require lots of resources (which our country lakes at moment) and then FPSC's own organization will become oversized, overstretched and unmanageable. At present atleast they can blame someone (post office) and save their own tails .

__________________
The precondition for existence of a higher humanity is not the state, but the nation possessing the necessary ability.

CSS-13 ka scandal democracy k paida kerda us corrupt system ka tohfa hai jo aaj BPSC or SPSC kay scandals kay baad jis ne is most competent and superior exams ko bhi na bakhsha. Aaj is ne meritocratic system pe yaqeen rakhne wali youth ki aakhri umeed ko bhi maddham ker dala. CSS hi wo wahid exam bacha tha jis kay zariye really educated (not fake degree walay) bina rishwat or merit pe Pakistan ko serve kerne kay liae agay atay thay or shayad inhi mein se kuch honest officers kay honay ki waja se ab tak is corrupt Pakistani political, patronage system kay bawajod merit ko kahien na kahien bachai huway hain magar afsos is scandal ne Pakistani youth ki is aakhri umeed pe bhi sawaliya nishan laga diya hai.........

do you agree ?

__________________
SUCCESS is going process from failure to failure without losing your enthusiasm (Winston Churchill)

100% Agreed. Saaron ko kya saza hai bhei? Yani jis ke papers achay nahi huay, unhay muft main ek aur chance mill jaye aur jinho ne behtar perform kiya hai, they again are exposed to test their luck!! Ballay vai ballay.... Kya insaaf hai

Instead, wo parcel jo late milla hai, simply uss main tampered papers identify kar ke un ka candidature hamesha ke liye khatam kar diya jaye. And of course, all staff of that particular post office must be terminated.

__________________
In order to succeed, your desire for success should be greater than your fear of failure....

again hongay papers I think......

__________________
SUCCESS is going process from failure to failure without losing your enthusiasm (Winston Churchill)

And why a re-take should happen all over country? Ek centre ke ek parcel ke chand papers ki wajha se pooray Pakistan ki shaamat kyun aaye? Yani jin ke papers achay nahi huay, unhay ek aur chance mill jaye. Salaam hai iss soch pe.

Give me one valid reason why a re-take should be taken all over? Why not the culprits should be disqualified? Baaqion ka kya kasoor hai?

Agreed.

Bad idea. Interview is totally subjective thing. Sifarishi culture chall jaye ga. Waise bhi, interview main it is personal evaluation. Why should re-take be done at first place? Seedha seedha culprits identify kar ke farigh karo unhay hamesha hamesha ke liye.

Agar all over karain ge to jinho ne tayaari nahi ki thi, wo bhi better tayaari ke sath baith jayen ge. Tab farak nahi parray ga kya? What about those who took more than 6 months unpaid leaves from their jobs to take this exam and did well? Can they avail such chances again and again? If the exam is re-taken again all over, there would be no more a foolish move than this.

Sorry to say and not being personal with you, aisi baat wohi banda kar sakta hai jis ne pehlay tayaari na ki ho aur uss ke exams sahi na huay hon. Ab iss case ko cash-in kar ke such people are raising voice to give themselves another chance...

Re-take is no option my dear. Its only a voice of those could no do well and are looking for an opportunity in the light of this scandal.

Agar aisa hua to ye intahaati fazool faisla ho ga and I will be amongst the ones who will strongly and openly oppose it... Bilkull nahi hona chahiye re-take. Only the culprits out of those parcels should be permanently disqualified.

__________________
In order to succeed, your desire for success should be greater than your fear of failure....

Those who support examination to be retaken are only losers who think they are already failed by analyzing their performance. There is no need to re-appear in the examination. Jin ke papers ache hue hain unka kiya kasur hai? baqi jinhon ne papers hi aise kiye hain jo unko abhi se pata hai wo fail honge to wo kahenge na papers dubara hon ke kahin is dafa unka duka lag jaye.

I also believed that re-take exams will not be wise decision..it is difficult to accumulate your same energies in re-take sort of situation.

__________________
There is no Telling How many Miles You have to run while chasing a Dream....