yupsi bro i got your point and i was also saying same point public ad had esult of above 80 every year with the criteria you set for m.law to be a sscoring subject . bro im also a charterred accountant and i know about the subject very much so im not firring bullets in the year and according to my experience of css i will suggest not to opt it and ppublic ad is better than m.law . and yes IR is quite low scoring than m.law when compared but again it also gave good scores every year but their % was low as in m.law . so bro according to your analysis i can say every subject is scoring and one more thing IR was beaten last years so it means is it going to be scoring ? i Alhamdulilah cleared css but didn't went for m.law being a student of accountancy then so i would suggest others too go for scoring subjects like journalism sociology domestic languages public ad or even muslim law instead of merchantile law