F. 4-172/2017-r [senior auditors] - Page 41

Shah Taj Ali Khan · #**401** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Quote:

Originally Posted by M Numan

Age can also be secured in National Bank

NO

Sent from my ALE-L21 using Tapatalk

Shah Taj Ali Khan · #**402** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abdullah22

Y he dastoor yahan hamare Mulk ka , batch 2 waale margae , bacth 1 and 3 waale jeet gaye. ye he
Insaaf FPSC ka. Sindh saare jo b selection hui he 99% bacth-1 and 3 ki hui he. You can see the alphabetical order in the list.

Is Mulk ka kuch nahi hosakta jahan paper set karne waale ko equality nahi aati k what should be the standard of setting a paper. Ek level k Exam paper set krna nahi aatay. kisi batch ko bilkul asaan to kisi ko bohat Mushkil. yaa to ek waqt me ek hi paper lo na sab se jaahilo...

Why FPSC is conducting exam, FPSC is not a body that can conduct an exam on merit basis. I know Who have passed will not agree with me so I know the comments from their side.

Batch 4 test was as difficult as batch 1. Par this is life. Luck matters also. Don't get disappointed. Your day will also come

Sent from my ALE-L21 using Tapatalk

umarmalik987 · #**403** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Alhumdulillah, Qualified in 1st section.. Aghay keh liya dua karna.

Shah Taj Ali Khan · #**404** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shah Taj Ali Khan

Batch 4 test was as difficult as batch 1. Par this is life. Luck matters also. Don't get disappointed. Your day will also come

Sent from my ALE-L21 using Tapatalk

I meant Batch 2.

Sent from my ALE-L21 using Tapatalk

El barto · #**405** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

When i started visiting this forum some time ago, generally i noticed a lot of people talking about the "Luck" factor in getting selected. My personal view is that this "Luck" is basically a polite, or ignorant way of not calling FPSC inefficient or inept ( I suspect the latter one more so). Because, lets be very honest, FPSC is inept and inefficient, and the aspirants who had the bad "Luck" of getting placed in the 2nd batch (or 4th, if it was bizarre just like the 2nd one) found this out first hand, myself included. Now saying stuff like 'It's ok you will get another chance' or 'Allah must have something better for you' or 'Don't lose hope/ better "Luck" next time', loses its meaning if you weren't even given a fair chance in the first place.

Abdullah22 · #**406** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Quote:

Originally Posted by El barto

When i started visiting this forum some time ago, generally i noticed a lot of people talking about the "Luck" factor in getting selected. My personal view is that this "Luck" is basically a polite, or ignorant way of not calling FPSC inefficient or inept ( I suspect the latter one more so). Because, lets be very honest, FPSC is inept and inefficient, and the aspirants who had the bad "Luck" of getting placed in the 2nd batch (or 4th, if it was bizarre just like the 2nd one) found this out first hand, myself included. Now saying stuff like 'It's ok you will get another chance' or 'Allah must have something better for you' or 'Don't lose hope/ better "Luck" next time', loses its meaning if you weren't even given a fair chance in the first place.

Brother we should do something, we can create a forum for this make together. We can a file a case on FPSC officials who prepared the exam paper. I can guarantee you that in Sindh only 4-5 candidates have been selected from batch-2. then the series starts from name Muhammad . . . . ., My friends have been selected those who never prepared for the test but they got a golden chance of sitting in Batch-1 and 3.

I don't know about the batch-4,m but heard it was tough too. but the Alphabetical series that was in barch-2 is all missing. You can see this even.

Abdullah22 · #**407** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shah Taj Ali Khan

Batch 4 test was as difficult as batch 1. Par this is life. Luck matters also. Don't get disappointed. Your day will also come

Sent from my ALE-L21 using Tapatalk

Yes Luck matters a lot. but Disappointment also matters a lot.

angel65 · #**408** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Any Body receive text or email or only they upload the list?

AccountingPrince · #**409** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

انا لللہ و انا الیہ راجعون۔

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abdullah22

Y he dastoor yahan hamare Mulk ka , batch 2 waale margae , bacth 1 and 3 waale jeet gaye. ye he
Insaaf FPSC ka. Sindh saare jo b selection hui he 99% bacth-1 and 3 ki hui he. You can see the alphabetical order in the list.

Is Mulk ka kuch nahi hosakta jahan paper set karne waale ko equality nahi aati k what should be the standard of setting a paper. Ek level k Exam paper set krna nahi aatay. kisi batch ko bilkul asaan to kisi ko bohat Mushkil. yaa to ek waqt me ek hi paper lo na sab se jaahilo...

Why FPSC is conducting exam, FPSC is not a body that can conduct an exam on merit basis. I know Who have passed will not agree with me so I know the comments from their side.

Quote:

Originally Posted by El barto

When i started visiting this forum some time ago, generally i noticed a lot of people talking about the "Luck" factor in getting selected. My personal view is that this "Luck" is basically a polite, or ignorant way of not calling FPSC inefficient or inept ( I suspect the latter one more so). Because, lets be very honest, FPSC is inept and inefficient, and the aspirants who had the bad "Luck" of getting placed in the 2nd batch (or 4th, if it was bizarre just like the 2nd one) found this out first hand, myself included. Now saying stuff like 'It's ok you will get another chance' or 'Allah must have something better for you' or 'Don't lose hope/ better "Luck" next time', loses its meaning if you weren't even given a fair chance in the first place.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abdullah22

Brother we should do something, we can create a forum for this make together. We can a file a case on FPSC officials who prepared the exam paper. I can guarantee you that in Sindh only 4-5 candidates have been selected from batch-2. then the series starts from name Muhammad . . . . ., My friends have been selected those who never prepared for the test but they got a golden chance of sitting in Batch-1 and 3.

I don't know about the batch-4,m but heard it was tough too. but the Alphabetical series that was in barch-2 is all missing. You can see this even.

Salam
I have done some analysis.
Instead of wild guessing, download the following analysis and check yourself
https://ufile.io/rlq1m

According to this analysis, only 3 alphabets secured 70% plus positions. (A, M and N. and if these are from batch 1 and 3 then it is confirmed that the result has not been made batch wise, and test difficulty has played a major role in selection (which is extremely unfair). Something should be done. At least reservations should be sent to FPSC so that at least this does not happen again in future. Matter should be brought in to the attention of higher authority (but only if premise is true).

AccountingPrince · #**410** Wednesday, November 29, 2017

As usual, those who could not make it, don't get depressed.