can anyone let me know how many candidates passed CE 2010 (Written) from KPK (formerly known as NWFP) ? Also, If you could mention how many appeared from KPK and out of them how much passed, it'll be helpful

87 students are to be interviewed in peshawar.i think most of them will be from KPK.but i am not sure.

no not all are from KPK, around 20 are from FATA, a few of them are also from Gilgil Baltistan. however the total no of pass candidates from KPK are around 80. they have given their interviews in Islamabad and lahore as well

__________________
"pattering your life around others opinion is nothing more than slavery"

someone above said that less candidates passed from sindh because of poor education quality, I thought education in sindh was much better than education in KPK but lol ;o

Ask some professor in Quaid-I-Azam University where talent is gathered from all provinces that where does the outshining talent come from? Surely, the answer will be KP and Punjab.

Well, not everybody is going to be allocated in these top 3. But it is wrong to say that people from other groups are just nothing. Yes comparatively PSP,DMG,FSP are better than all others but comparatively. All other groups are of no match with other govt services except Civil Services. You will have to agree with me. Sar utha k phirne ki jahan tak baat hai yeh sub suni sunae batain hain it all depends upon person whoever is working under the concerned group. No one is underestimated in groups yet its true that people have made this proverb famous that PSP, DMG, FSP are elite groups rest are craps.
I know many people around me who are working in other groups and they are extremely happy with VIP job and perks. So i don't really give ears to these rumours that CSS groups are only top 3. Though its true that IG, Railway and Postal has really been downgraded by people in perception as well as preference. But all others are equally competitive groups....

__________________
“The greatest discovery of all time is that a person can change his future by merely changing his attitude.”

exactly brother i am hunderd percent agree that other groups are far better than other jobs in pakistan. or sar uthany ki bat hy i will again agree with u that i have not been to CSA but what we have heard from our friends doing their ctp is expressed here. u may disagree.

lekin yar dekho na its natural that candidates of these top three groups consider themselves superior to rest of them. is me to koi dhaki chupi bat nahi hy k ye teen group achy hen baki groups sy

__________________
"pattering your life around others opinion is nothing more than slavery"

I know best idea CSA ja k he ho sakay ga. I pray we c each other in CSA then we ll surely have fun and discussions on these. Or ye baat bhi theek hai k probationers btate hain esa sb, it is usually the attitude of candidates in top group that makes others think that they are inferior hala k they should be thankful to Allah!!!

Yeah i agree wo tou hai. yeh bhi samajhte hain apne aapko king on other groups or log bhi esa he samajhte hain and even these tops consider themselves way ahead in knowledge and aptitude on other group employees. me sirf yeh samajhta hun k this mentality should be cut off...

__________________
“The greatest discovery of all time is that a person can change his future by merely changing his attitude.”

Marilatif and Rishz! jahan tak sar uta kar chalnay ki bat hay to yaqeen kejiye har koi sar uta ke jeeta hay CSA may, as for as FSP is concerned this time it was fourth in preference in Punjab, KPK, and Balochistan, however dont know about Sindh. third was PCS.
i m in PAAS and dont feel inferior to anyone who is from other service or group. I have qualified this time and my preference is like this, dmg, psp, pcs, irs, and fsp. i m sure i will not be joining if it is other than dmg or psp,
We are to work hard and the rest we should leave to God, whatever He decides, He better knows. its sometimes just luck that someone gets good marks due to high scoring subjects, as scoring trend differs from year to year. sometimes its just a matter of a single mark or even not even a single mark that one gets allocation to top preference while the other one to his fifth to sixth. for example last year me and my friend kashif jameel had equal marks, he got FSP while i got PAAS. now you people imagine is it hard work, achievement or just luck.

Regards.

__________________
I will either find a way or make one. Hannible

Dear Brother Noor-ul-Haq AOA,
I would like to endorse your good remarks that whatevere is destinied for us will be ours and there is no need to let you down before others becaus we are not allocated in their groups.We have to be bold and courageous enough to face realities without downgrading our dignity and honor.Now I have a querry and hope you will help me in this regard.I have come to know through one of my friends that the interview pannel has the whole result of written part of our examination before them and they are in a better position to estimate our allocation after Psychological Assessment Tests.
Brother being a CSP you certainly have contact with other CSP's at CSA do you think it is correct.I have also the views of my good friends of this forum when I floated the same question to all forum members.I hope you will provide your good inputs.
Thanks
Wish you best of luck
Gul Khan