As per my poor info our country is facing many problems since it's birth, for facing & solving the problems "Awami" Government need time.< if it is given by Gen.s> every problem should be solved if democrtic do its work fairly. I am not in favour of seperation but fundamemtals facilities should be provide in this area.

thanks to all participents but any one who can conclude all discussion plz?

__________________
After every failure there is a success waiting 4 u so do,nt lose heart and keep hard working ALLAH will help u.Malik Hassan Raza Ghallu Advocate.

IN MY OPINION ,WE CAN CONCLUDE THAT THIS IN NOT THE PROPER TIME TO MAKE THE NEW PROVINCES BECAUSE PAKISTAN HAS BECOME POOR TO A FAULT.......

__________________
--WASALAM--

As the voting graph shows that most of the people have argued that it is not the proper time for making new province. Then what is the right time?
Dears i totally disagree with that. in my opinion now or never. Only this is the right time that all the province should be given their rights. Because we are enjoying a democratic government (ppl elected parliament) after a decade of dictatorship. So why should we wait for an other military coup. Would we be able to raise voice for our rights against a dictator? i think it is the right time. if a dictator comes, he will bring forth other complicated issues like(Musharraf, and Zia) so it will be better to solve our greivnces and dispute at this time.( Because Democracy in Pakistan.........Kal ho na ho)

MR. NATIONALIST are we enjoying democratic government? sirf moun se bolny se koi b govt democratic nahi ho jati.kuch nazar b to aye

even i dont agree with u ...u r saying "v r having democratic govt" ..... the line seems to be rubbish.
what i meant to say about time is fully logical.
a new province will want new offices,houses,and apart from these,a huge chunk of money is required!and we lack that money....our buget is in deficit..we have not sufficent money to handle the problems which we are facing now a days....and creation of new province will prove to be a huge disaster.

__________________
--WASALAM--

It is a fact that regional re-distribution of Pakistan is ultimate and essential. As the question of creation of new province is concerned we must have a clear and rational reasons for that. A some sort of self-questioning is required. creation of new province will solve what sort of our problem ,bound issues or unbound problems, administrative, social, political ,economic etc?
What are its immediate and long term effects?
what are its side-effects on Pakistan as whole?
In short a complete road map is necessary for this triumph step.

I also completely agree with @Raaz

As matter of money is concerned this excuse was also common during separation of Pakistan. They also claim that Pakistan will fall soon due to dismal economic situation. funding or poor budget is not the issue but the issue is the absence of critical minority in grieved areas especially southern Punjab and Baluchistan. Newly born state was also poor in economics but was rich in human and skill wealth . They have genuine and sincere leaderships. creating new federating units is not dangerous but to handover the fate of many million people to cruel,in-competent,selfish and feudalistic mentality is real problem.Toyn B.,great historian, has said that ' Change become inevitable if a critical minority develops in a society,a nation and a state' critical minority,a small group of highly motivated and inspirational personality with strong character and dedication to their purpose. In recent struggle for judiciary , i believe, outcome would be different if it wasn't led by people like Aitzaz Ahsan, Ali ahmad kurd, Tariq Mehmood etc.

i totally agree with u? yes new province can provide oppertunities to our people but from where we vl get money for it. govt cannot even met the expenses of 4 provinces then how our so called democratic govt vl manage the budget

Making new provinces will be helpful for the cause of national integration. It will pacify the aggrieved parties in the country and ensure distribution of resources on the right basis.
So far as problems-newly-made-provinces-will-be-facing are concerned, they will be dealt with their own resources...
Moreover, in case of any fiasco to the new federating units, central govt and other provinces are there to help them out...
Even then, the status quo of Pakistan does not favour that...so it would be the right step sometime in future!

My dear u argued that it will be difficult to handle the new province and that we are out of resources so making of new province will not be in the best interest of Pakistan.
Dear every new state and Province have to face such difficulties. When pakistan came into existence it also faced economical, financial and other serious problems but it was only the true spirit of its decendants which made it possible and showed that we can handle our new state. So i think we must not worry about these problems. as brother Sajid have told that such problems will be dealt with the resources and people of that province. Moreover Other provinces are also there to help. so that might not be a good excuse.

Regards

__________________
We can live without religion and meditation, but we cannot survive without human affection.....