Usman Brother.
Sorry to say but the Last Island had uttered those words just after my post. It was the very first comment I received. If you say that it was nor directed at me then I am sorry to admit that I am taken as an infant who can't understand anything.
Brother. I was ready to expect the opposition ever since I initiated the thread. I am not afraid of opposition but I was really stunned by the observation as to how many Mature aspirants forcibly took the debate towards some other direction.
Just read my comments where I kept on, kept on and kept requesting the members as to what my prime cause of concern was.

And dear brother. There is huge difference between opposition and SARCASM.

Brother, with due respect, you claim that your purpose of this thread was to point out those repeaters who despite being in their desired group reappear to improve their position/merit. But on the other hand, in your very first post you have mentioned:

Now, tell me whether these toppers were improving their positions?? You should know that they reappeard to get/improve their groups which is the right of every candidate. I don't deny the fact that there might have been some candidates who reappear to improve their position despite being in their favourite group. But how many are such candidates?? Can you give me a dozen of examples of such repeaters in CSS History??? If you know one or two such candidates and generlize this to the extent that such repeaters are making life difficult for fresh candidates, its not true.

Now if you suggest measures to penalize repeaters. Think this way: suppose a candidate prepares for 2 months and manges to qualify but can't get allocaiton/desired group. Further suppose that next year, he prepares for 4-5 months. Now there is a fresh candidate who has been preparing for exam for a year or even more. Both are competing in next year, don't you think fresh candidate will be better prepared than the repeater? Now, if one proposes to implement penalties on such fresh candidates, will it make sense? Obviously not!! Giving an attempt doesn't install in some one super natural abilities to perform better in next attempt. One has to study like a fresh candidate to acquire good marks/position unless he/she is very lucky.

Term 'incompetent competitors' is not singular rather plural so how can it be intended for you? It has been said in general context for all those candidates who are afraid of competition and I also endorse its veracity.

__________________
Best end of life is not knowledge but action.
Don't limit yourself to what you think people are expecting!

Usman Brother.
the sorry point of the discussion has been that the member picks up his favorable comment and build argument on that. Sorry to say but you have done the same.
You have completely neglected ( intentionally or unintentionally ) my comments in which I have CLEARLY mentioned the real cause behind initiating this very thread. Here is the comment number and my comments.
Comment # 3.
" I just want to quote that I have only voiced the concern of numerous CSS aspirants in the form of this thread of mine"
Comment # 34.
" Firstly, let me state the point here that this is not entirely my own opinion. I have been helping the tyro aspirants with every bits and pieces of experience and knowledge I have.
These are the concerns of the numerous CSS aspirants. I couldn't satisfy them with my replies to their very query.
I have posted this thread not only on CSS Forum but also on the CSS-related groups on FaceBook.
I have received quite logical and convincing replies from several CSP's and other semior members on various forums. "
Comment # 38.
" The thread was merely a mouthpiece of several tyro aspirants which I expressed on their behalf. "
Comment # 43.
" Brother, I just voiced the concern of several tyro aspirants and nothing else."
Brother Usman. this is the point I have been trying to make. I am sorry to say but you somehow missed these comments of mine and commented on the thread you wanted to.
Half truth is far more dangerous than a lie.
Ragards,
Ainu.

__________________
Form is temporary, but class is permanent.

I just kept on shouting, shouting and shouting but people heard what they wished to hear.
I kept, kept and kept on saying. I kept on repeating again and again, time and again but to no avail.

__________________
Form is temporary, but class is permanent.

That is democracy dear , you have freedom of expression but others have no duty to listen to it (jk).

__________________
The precondition for existence of a higher humanity is not the state, but the nation possessing the necessary ability.

Brother, where have I said that this is your concern? If you have voiced the concern of other aspirants then its also your duty to apprise them about the factual situation as I have mentioned in my posts.

Please also convey opinion of all other members (either in support or against the discussion topic) to those CSS aspirants. It is also my humble request to please inculcate into them the spirit of competition because unfortunately their concern doesn't seem maintainable and workable. How are they going to stand the real test of life if they start thinking on such escapism theories. I think you being a teacher can teach and guide them in a better way!

__________________
Best end of life is not knowledge but action.
Don't limit yourself to what you think people are expecting!

Those comments from LI were justified, In fact, that was the most politest way to tell someone what exactly a "competitive" exam is. You were/are obviously not taken as an infant for understanding the implication of the comments but you obviously are considered as an infant for being emotional rather than being rational. Teacher saab kindly come up with arguments that are understandable and/or logical/rational.

The way you reacted and are reacting clearly negates the statement of you "Expecting" opposition & You might NOT be afraid of the opposition but I assure you that you are ANNOYED of the opposition, isn't it?

Instead of requesting members and being emotional it would have been a better option to ACTUALLY read what the members are saying and then answering the reservations with logic rather than telling them how grieved you are with the opposition and how your expectations were ruined etc etc.

It depends on the perception, If you perceive opposition as SARCASM then there's nothing much one can do, the perception has to come from within.

May be this is first time participation of Ainuddin in any discussion forum that's why opposition seems to him as sacrcasm.
Sorry no offense

__________________
You've got to get the stage in life where GOING for it is more important than WINNIG or LOSING.

No Kashif.
This is not Democracy but dictatorship where you keep on shouting but are left unheard. And I can some members clicking on the Thanks option as a part of the duty.

I can inculcate into them the terms by calling them " Incompetent Competitors"

I would have surely come up with the arguments but smelled that one is backed after another irrespective of the truth of the mater.

I never said that I was annoyed of the opposition but I have stated time and again that I was annoyed by the rough manner in which my query was met. I was not hurt by the opposition but by the manner the post was met.

The perception is clearly perceived by the words in the written form and the words in the written form are here on the thread.
Just need to read them neutrally.

I know the difference between Opposition and Sarcasm.

One of the members was doing a fine job in clicking the option " Thanks "

__________________
Form is temporary, but class is permanent.

Dear brother Ainuddin I know you know the difference between opposition and sarcasm. And I really appreciate your knowledge. If a member cliks THANKS button in response to a post it means he/she is agreed to that post and this becomes not a duty/JOB of that member rather agreeing with an opinion/view.

Dear bother it's your DUTY and JOB to face opposition with a broad mind. And if you feel sarcasm anywhere then you must convince the sarcastic with strong logical arguments. This would be quite appreciating. But if you keep on trying to plead in a childish way then it's impossible for others to hear you.
Apologize if I performed the duty of clicking THANKS on my like views'posts.

__________________
You've got to get the stage in life where GOING for it is more important than WINNIG or LOSING.