The Balochistan issue is WAY older than the war on terror (has existed since the 1970). Also, according to Pak, over 5000 Pak Army personnel and 55,000 Pak civilians have died in terrorist attacks. How many more deaths will it take to make it "our war".

I want to ask from Mr. Akhtar Mengal and other leading nationalist Balochi leaders, who are dying to save Balochis form the atrocities of Pakistan What have they done for Balochi people?
they are blood-suckers, they are those people who want to run parallel governments or one can say Shenshahat.
They should all be hanged till death.
these people are the only problem of Balochistan and Balochi people, remove them, problem solved.

This is not the time to decide who is wrong or right.Situation needs to be managed.

__________________
Puppet,Slave,Lover

Your assessment is incorrect brother, Bengal had support of India only, but current Balochistan has become nucleus of global forces. You can't gauge the gravity of this precarious scenario. You had to face only India in 70s but 0s have invited multilateral players to rescue Balochistan. We have to change our mentality. Army has never remained a better solution.

Please change your tone towards this sensitive issue. Your post seems to be reflection of a dictator army person. Our behavior and treatment needs soft touch. Had they been so problem for Balochi people they would have been killed long ago instead of Non-Balochis.

This is the mentality which has brought Balochistan on the verge of divorce. You are speaking mind of a dictator army man who thinks less and dictates more. Numbers and distance don't matter.

__________________
"Tumhary nafs ki qeemat Janat hay isy Janat say kam qeemat pey na bechna."
"Jiyo to istarh ky log tum sy milny ko tarsy; maro to istrah k log tumharee mot par royain"

Bro I'm aware of the sensitivity of this issue, but I still say that Akhtar Mengal and Co cannot hope to achieve anything by waging open war against the Pakistani state (as they have been doing for the last couple years). He can give as many provocative statements as he wants, but he should remember that in the end, Baluchistan just can't break away like Bangladesh did. In my opinion, they are unlikely to achieve anything through force of arms alone.

Regarding the army, I've never been in favor of their constant interference in political matters, but the fact remains that Baloch nationalists are, for all intents and purposes, waging war against the Pakistani state in general and against Punjabis in particular. Do you remember how they killed Nazima Talib? Pulled her out of the rickshaw and shot her while she was lying on the road. I remember this particular case because she taught many members of my family, but there are a thousand other examples of the atrocities committed by the Baloch.

I agree that our past policies are to blame for the current situation, but Baloch extremists must be brought to their senses. We would all like to live in an ideal world where every conflict can be solved through negotiation, but unfortunately, this world isn't perfect and I believe some degree of force is required to deal with these savages.

I loved your answer quite Sensible.



Same stands true for rest of Pakistan/Govt/Military. We have not succeeded to achieve anything with force, and we won't be.

What have we been doing for decades? Did it produce positive results? Have we achieved our objective with force?

__________________
"Tumhary nafs ki qeemat Janat hay isy Janat say kam qeemat pey na bechna."
"Jiyo to istarh ky log tum sy milny ko tarsy; maro to istrah k log tumharee mot par royain"

i agree with Raz shb..

in a nutshell, the government, establishment (primarily military) should adopt anything whether its through negotiations, force, what ever.. but we should make sure that 1971 episode is not repeated again.. It will be a great holocaust. If God forbids this happens. We not only as a state, but as citizens will fail.. its our responsibility as a nation, to show them affection and love, and make them feel that they are integral part of Pakistan.

http://baask.com/diwwan/index.php?topic=1231.0

__________________
"Wa tu izzu man-ta shaa, wa tu zillu man-ta shaa"

This is all struggle to gain power, Akhtar Mengal, his father Attaullah Mengal, Akbar Bugti etc. They all have been a part of government for long. During their power why did they not do any thing for people of Balochistan?
The problem of Balochistan not only revolves around Baloch, Pashtuns are also partener in it. Some points of Mengal are valid, like there should be no intervention of army in politics, but some sort of force is needed to be used.
Answer me a question, what is the difference between Taliban and Baloch separatists?

I have the best solution... why doesn't Pakistan test few nuclear missiles on balochs.....problem solved..i know Baloch has a very stubborn nature of sticking towards its cause, fighting for its right till death so i think its better to finish them all.. cheers.

__________________
Whatever doesn't kill you, simply makes you stranger.....