Now I need to hear your viewpoints regarding this topic. In various countries around the world, the most prominent being the some nations in Europe and South America, police is a separate body from the government. In the case of the UK the Scotland Yard is independent of government control. They carry out operations without the consent of the government, having their own command of control. Do you guys think, such a system should be introduced in Pakistan?
There should be a federal, nationwide police force which is independent of political interference. They should have a governing body, with their own budget and their own hiring system wherein competent individuals can be recruited. I am sure this will bring greater efficiency and ensure that there is an unbiased police force free from political clout. I believe this will bring several benefits:
1) It will ensure that high profile political murders (which has plagued Pakistan since forever) reach their conclusion quickly.
2) The crime rate itself will decrease owing to greater efficiency.

These institutions would have separate legal wings for prosecution of criminals. I believe if these reforms are carried out, there will be no need of army/rangers intervening in civilian cases.

Now this is purely theoretical. I know this will be extremely hard to carry out. Just need to know what you guys think.

Assalam-o-alaikum. I think it is a very good step to make police free from the Government but there two things which will make them work harder against every crime committed anywhere. Firstly, Police cannot impelement their powers until the law and order situation is not good. If you review the laws of foreign countries, their is a huge difference between Pakistan's law and their law. Secondly the main issue is that any of the Police officer doesn't get enough pay to fulfill his/her necessary needs which leads them to take bribe and extortion. So These issues should be resolved first and then Police will play it's role in the society.

__________________
Whenever I hear, “It can’t be done,” I know I’m close to success.

I agree to everything you have said. Which is why police should have a separate pay scale, possibly different to that of government officers. And what about the high-profile murders in which our politicians get freely involved?

I think Police should not be separated from government but it should be free from government uncontrolled interference.Any such institution without having state controlling authority would go Scot free and might encroach upon the basic rights of citizens.

Yes indeed Politicians are involved in high-profile murders, I can mention Kamran Faisal's murder here. Politics is a very weird think my brother, one cannot predict about it. Usually police officers are involved in these type of matters but they are also pressurized by the Powerful Politicians to perform such course of actions. If they decline their offer, those powerful people make them suffer from the worst part of their life.

__________________
Whenever I hear, “It can’t be done,” I know I’m close to success.