InshaAllah you will win the case.As there are beneficiaries in this re-exam then why am i not a beneficiary? I want to re-appear to improve my results this is gross discrimination!!!!

Agreed. Why should an entire region be penalized for the mistakes of a few? Suppose if few Lahoris would have done that, then was all Lahore meant to be banned? Disagree..

Both these demands are absurd. Banning Faisalabad inductions is a foolish idea and taking re-exams all over is more than foolish.


Its NOT a fundamental right. One needs to think logically before going for an action. The decision of FPSC is debatable but still I don't find it unfair. Do you guys have a better solution to this problem? If yes, please share. You people are saying that the culprits should have been identified. My question is... How???

Suppose I write on 23 May 2013 with a Sheaffer fountain pen with blue ink. After the exam time is over, mein MUKK MUKA kar ke amlay se same ya new answer sheet le kar correct answers likh deta hoon. How will you identify that the ink was real or fake or was it really me?

A probable alternative was to stay silent and identify in terms of the number of sheets written. But that idea would have again failed because writing speed differs from person to person. Moreover, the ones who wrote on an altogether new sheet would again not have been identified.

If FPSC would have failed all the candidates of this Center, many people would have been made scapegoats and be persecuted along with the culprits. In that case, petitions would have been filed again by many claiming that they were penalized for no reason.

Now, once FPSC has made a decision to hold re-exam of that particular Center and NOT ENTIRE FAISALABAD, people are willing to file a petition in order to conduct exam country wide. One more thing, they are not taking all the exams. In most of the cases, it is limited to 4-6 papers. See the list of Roll numbers for your clarification.

I am extremely dismayed and disappointed over this demand. This has compelled me to recall a memory of my MBA last semester when a teacher failed 36 out of 45 students in his subject. He failed around 12 people deliberately by giving them 48% marks when passing marks were 50%. He admitted in front of entire batch that he has failed those 12 guys deliberately.

When those 12 people stood up against him, they were backed up by 24 remaining people but their demands failed... You know why??? Because they all demanded that either he should pass everyone or none..

Now tell me... What right do the other 24 people have to claim their re-examination? They failed because of their own deeds but when they saw an opportunity, WOH APNA ULLU SEEDHA KARNAY BAITH GAYE and destroyed not only their unjustified demand but also the chance of deserving ones. How could have a candidate having mere 3% marks be passed?

Bilkull aisay hi mujhay lagta hai ke pooray Pakistan main re-exam karanay ki petition daair karnay ka maqsad protest nahi, APNA ULLU SEEDHA KARNA HAI.

And I can smell it through these words:


"As there are beneficiaries in this re-exam then why am i not a beneficiary? I want to re-appear to improve my results this is gross discrimination!!!!"

That means jis ki attempt theek nahi hui, wo petition daair kar de aur jis ki theek hui hai, wo iss ka azaala karay. What a nice example of double standards.

Seeing all this stuff, I wish ke kaash FPSC khamosh raha hota aur chup chaap written result declare kar daita. Tab sab theek tha. Hain na??

But now they have admitted a mistake and they are trying to rectifying in a way, they should suffer. How cute.

Kya hum log mistakes nahi kartay? Kya kisi aur idaaray se ghalti nahi hui? Kya humaray mulk main ghaltiyaan nahi hoti? Kya koi ghalti karay to ussay phaansi de di jaye?


If in your view FPSC has not done justice, please don't expect anything special from judiciary too. Even if I agree to your claim that FPSC cannot do justice, Insha Allah Allah will do that.

If you are confident over your attempt, then this bunch of cheaters cannot defeat you, no matter whatever they do. So you should not feel threatened with 320 odd candidates. Waise bhi I feel that if we bring human psychology of FPSC staff and teachers, these people might be grilled instead of being shown a sympathy.

Baaqi your life your decisions. Its your right to file a petition and I am no one to be a road block. Laikin agar country wide re-take ki petition gayi to Insha Allah sath hi aisay logon ki self interest ki iss fazool aur shar-pasand demand ke against ek aur petition aaye gi... In that case, best of luck my bro's.

I, like many of my fellows out here, am confident over my attempt, over my self, over the prayers of my family and over the Justice and Mercy of Allah Ta'ala so after standing against such petition, I would ultimately leave the case with Allah Subhaan o Ta'ala.

__________________
In order to succeed, your desire for success should be greater than your fear of failure....

+1 support aminshah101 totally, all those who want a re-exam are the ones who want a second bite on the apple. Be warned if you weren't able to chew it the first time, you will most probably choke on the second bite. Best of Luck.

Thanks for your understanding . Shukar hai, kisi ko to meri baat sahi lagi.

__________________
In order to succeed, your desire for success should be greater than your fear of failure....

They have got 2.5 months of preparation which is ample time for revision and serious study of CSS exam retake. A miscalculated venture on part of FPSC!

Their cant be a better solution to this problem.
And when they let the cat out in the first place, a solution which everyone agrees to was never going to be possible.
And most CSS aspirants are doing their jobs, I am a doctor in DHQ FSD, and since I heard this news, I am still in a fix.
The whole day I tried to find ways , that how I will study again , I probably will not get another leave this time. It's so difficult .
One of my friends gave a very satisfactory attempt, and he was only doubtful of his essay, now he is to be re examined only in optionals, and he is so depressed, as he believes that it's going to be difficult to retake, after he was satisfied with his papers.

And believing that court will undo this decision or cancel the re examination , is hoping against hope.

And I myself is apprehensive that we might be tested through a harder task this time and marking will also be tighter.

And this reexam can help in the investigations , as if there is some dramatic decline in the quality of the material in the papers of some candidates , they are surely the ones.



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

__________________
There is always room for improvement , it's the biggest room in the house.

totally confused. should i take it as a blessing in disguise or a bullet from the bow.Let's see what happens.

"And I myself is apprehensive that we might be tested through a harder task this time and marking will also be tighter".

Fpsc can serve the justice if they simply can get the average marks of previous and re-took examination so that no one gets benefitted because of his good attempt this time and others whose last attempt was more fruitfull than this.

if it happens then hard work of many who are taking this re-take as a blessing will bear nothing. again it will be unfair.

We are going for a petition in court against re-examination. We are six people and we need upto 15 people for a stronger writ. I would highly appreciate if you join us.

They are probably trying to protect the culprits by re-examination

brother please join us for a strong petition against such unjust and foolish step taken by FPSC

why are they not sending the disputed copies to the forensic department to find the age of ink on paper? sources in forensic department say they can give report back within 24 hours! why not catching the culprits???? I would say this is the repetition of what zia did when he created 11th special common ...

please contact me on my number .... although I did not take CE 2013 but I am available for every possible help because this is slaughter of merit.... yes some one close to FPSC officials is being protected.