KARACHI:

A total of 51 officers, selected through allegedly forged and tampered results of the Sindh Public Service Commission (SPSC) exam from the year 2003-2004, are all set to receive promotions even though the high court has yet to verify the exam results.

In the SPSC Combined Competitive Exam (CCE) held in December 2003 to January 2004, a total of 2,225 people qualified the written test. Out of these only 532 qualified both the written test and the interview, and only 77 were allocated various posts, such as revenue DDO, section officers, registrars, labour assistant director, excise and taxation officer and others.

According to a petition these candidates filed in the high court in 2008, the SPSC itself conceded that the results of as many as 51 candidates were tampered with but these officials have yet to be discharged from duties. “We have informed the court and filed a report on the tampering,” admitted SPSC controller Jumma Khan Chandio, while talking to The Express Tribune. “Now it is up to the court to decide.” Chandio refused to elaborate on the issue.

Meanwhile, the candidates who cleared the two steps and were denied posts are upset as the SPSC has dragged the issue for five years. “Every time the SPSC resorts to hoodwinking and avoids providing the merit list of those who actually qualified the exams in 2003 so they could be declared successful,” said the petitioner, Muhammad Saleem Shaikh.

The SPSC either provides irrelevant data or recommends holding re-interviews of all the candidates – even the ones who failed, said Shaikh. According to him, this will be a grave injustice as the ones who actually passed in 2004 would be required to go through the viva voce again whereas, those who failed the viva voce earlier, would have another chance to compete.

The SPSC submitted its report in the high court on June 16 and declared that they reviewed the cases and found that 35 of the 51 candidates were qualified on the basis of tampered results. “The decision on the remaining 16 candidates – which are earlier called ‘fraud entries’ by some members of the inquiry committee – were tactfully withheld for obvious reasons,” claimed another petitioner Zameer Abbasi. The next hearing of the case is scheduled for August.

Apart from the commission, an inquiry was also held by the anti-corruption force but so far the fate of the qualified candidates hangs in the balance.

“They have failed to submit a fresh merit list in high court – after removing the 51 cheats – of those who actually qualified both the written and viva voce in 2004,” pointed out Abbasi.

With the matter in court since 2008, the high court has to give the final verdict on what will happen to the beneficiaries and the officers who were involved in tampering the results.

The beneficiaries

Some of the 51 candidates who may have benefited from the tampered results include the son of the then chairperson of SPSC Muhammad Hussain Bhutto, Ayan Mustafa Bhutto, who was allocated the post of revenue DDO. He is now expected to be promoted to grade-19. Sindh government bureaucrat Ghaffar Soomro’s son, Fahad Ghaffar Soomro, SNGD secretary Ghulam Sarwar Khohru’s brother, Ghulam Shabbir, were also reportedly among the 51 candidates.

Published in The Express Tribune, June 21st, 2013.

http://tribune.com.pk/story/579776/f...ve-promotions/

Please read and discuss / comment on solutions to mitigate the malpractice.

Jis ka power uski jobs

It will also happened this time don't worry.

disappointment is not the solution. we have to fight. SPSC has done its job excellently in past and selected people on merit. some people has malighn the name of SPSC for their personal gain. lets not say no to SPSC but to those crooked officials.

make your mind for everything before appearing in the exams under SPSC... Surprises can shake any one's fate... So be ready for shocks as we have witnessed ourselves the governance led by PPP last 5 years, now we have to face them directly.... Aur do votes inko... JEAY BHUTTO.

http://www.awamiawaz.net/%D8%B3%D9%8...%D8%AA%D9%8A-2

__________________
"Tumhary nafs ki qeemat Janat hay isy Janat say kam qeemat pey na bechna."
"Jiyo to istarh ky log tum sy milny ko tarsy; maro to istrah k log tumharee mot par royain"

http://www.thekawish.com/www3/home_page/News-24.html


The Kawish Group of Publication
B/2 Civil Line Hyderabad,Sindh Pakistan.
Phone:+92 (22) 2780026,2780027,2780525 Fax: +92 (22) 2780772, 2781167

__________________
"Tumhary nafs ki qeemat Janat hay isy Janat say kam qeemat pey na bechna."
"Jiyo to istarh ky log tum sy milny ko tarsy; maro to istrah k log tumharee mot par royain"

Any body affected of malpractices in PCS 2003? I,myself, am on of affected candidates. I qualified the exam but could not get allocated. I intend to go to the court so that all responsible should be punished and justice can be done with the rightful candidates. Any body here willing to join the cause.

I had written following letter to the Chairman, SPSC on dated 16/09/2009 and kept Sindh Govt. Stakeholders in copy.

To
The Chairman
Sindh Public Service Commission
Hyderabad

Subject: REQUEST FOR CONSIDERATION OF MY CASE FOR COMBINE COMPETATIVE EXAMINATION 2003-04

Respected Sir,

With due respects it is glad to know that the Anti-Corruption Establishment found suspected involvement of huge amount of illegal gratifications, favoritism, nepotism, missing and tampering of record, enhancement and decrease of marks obtained resulting in a manipulated list of successful candidates for the Combined Competitive Examinations - 2003 held by the SPSC for the posts of Deputy District Officer, Section Officer, Assistant Director Labor, Assistant Registrar Cooperative Societies, Labor Officer and Ward Rationing Officer in the Government of Sindh in 2003, the exams of which were held between 31.12.2003 and 12.01.2004, and the results announced on April 10, 2004. As per these results 531 candidates were declared successful in the written examinations, while after viva voce, 77 individuals were recommended to the Government for appointment in any Department for which the Combined Competitive Examinations were held.

Sir, I Abdul Fatah Brohi S/o Abdul Majeed Brohi having Roll No. 16 was also declared successful in the written examination and I was called for an interview on dated 10-05-2004 where as I was appreciated in the interview but I was not selected for any post which made me disappointed.

Sir, in view of above it can be safely deduced that meritorious candidates were illegitimately superseded, through foul means and undeserving candidates were selected.

It is therefore requested that my case may be re-examined and though a fresh review my marks may be re-awarded to me through a transparent process. Further, in pursuance of this review I may be appointed in the service with immediate effect.

Sincerely


Abdul Fatah Brohi
Combine Competitive Examination 2003
Centre: Karachi


Copy for information:
1. Dr. Ishrat Ul Ebad Khan, Governor Sindh
2. Syed Qaim Ali Shah, Chief Minister
3. Secretary to Chief Minister Sindh
4. Chief Secretary Sindh
5. Additional Chief Secretary (SGA&CD)
6. Principal Secretary to Governor Sindh
7. Secretary (Services, SGA&CD Department)
8. Chairman, Enquiries & Anti Corruption
9. Secretary, Sindh Public Service Commission
10. Controller of Examinations, Sindh Public Service Commission

It is really a shocking news for me as well for my friends, who appeared in CCE-2003, and did not get allocation or otherwise failed in some papers deliberately. The SPSC authorities have done this unlawful and shameful act without any feeling of hesitation and regret.

Shame on below mentioned culprits (report published by daily Kawish News Paper on 28th July, 2013).

جاچ ڪاميٽي رپورٽ موجب جن ناپاس اميدوارن کي جعلسازي ذريعي پاس ڄاڻايو ويو آهي انهن ۾ جاويد رول نمبر (2658)، عاشق حسين چانڊيو رول نمبر (216)، مولا بخش شيخ رول نمبر (595)، سڪندر بلوچ رول نمبر (1073)، سعيد احمد شيخ رول نمبر (947)، مس ڪرن شيخ رول نمبر (1246)، محمد افضل چنا رول نمبر (601)، عمران رول نمبر (444) مختيار احمد ملاح رول نمبر (758)، علي انور رُڪ رول نمبر (1218)، اياز احمد صديقي رول نمبر (254) شامل آهن، جن جون ڪاپيون ۽ مارڪ شيٽون ميمبرن ابرار حسين مرزا چيڪ ڪيون، ان کان علاوه فواد غفار سومرو رول نمبر (344)، محمد ڪامران خان رول نمبر (681)، قمر الله رول نمبر (4323)، نوشين عثمان رول نمبر (3133)، سيد رضوان علي رول نمبر (3193)، زبير احمد چنا رول نمبر (1196)، فاروق اعظم ابڙو رول نمبر (4206)، صنم عامر رول نمبر (983)، ماهما ڊي سليم رول نمبر (721)، صفيه ناز منگي رول نمبر (4555)، عبدالقادر عباسي رول نمبر (60)، سيد احمد فواد (رول نمبر 2139)، ٿيٻو محمد جمن رول نمبر (2910)، غلام سرور اُتيرو رول نمبر (2492) علي گل سنجراڻي رول نمبر (2185) مڱريو محمد يعقوب رول نمبر (746) جهانزيب عباس رول نمبر (4303) شاهه ميمونا رول نمبر (3665) عامر ضياءَ اسراڻ رول نمبر (179) شعيب احمد کيڙو رول نمبر (1063) صابر علي ابڙو رول نمبر (931) به اهي اميدوار آهن جن جي امتحاني پيپرن ۽ مارڪ شيٽن ۾ جعلسازي ذريعي تبديليون ڪري کين ناپاس هئڻ باوجود پاس ڪيو ويو، ڪميشن جي امتحان وارن جوابي ٽيسٽن ۾ هيرا ڦيري ٿيل اميدوارن ۾ عبدالصمد رول نمبر (4052) ارشاد کوکر رول نمبر (2618) عبدالوهاب ساريو رول نمبر (79) سيف الله ابڙو رول نمبر (3231) محمد نواز سوهو رول نمبر (2946) رياض احمد ڏهر رول نمبر (915) شاهه احسان الله رول نمبر ( 423) ابراهيم رول نمبر (418) ڪامران احمد کيڙو رول نمبر ( 2673) فياض احمد جتوئي رول نمبر ( 4208) عمران ڀٽي رول نمبر (436) محمد خرم منگي رول نمبر (684) شبير احمد سيٺر رول نمبر ( 4587) عبدالشڪور نوناري رول نمبر (4059) محمد توفيق رول نمبر (738) راجا مصطفيٰ علي رول نمبر (891) مختيار احمد شر رول نمبر (757) فياض حسين عباسي رول نمبر (332) جمشيد عالم رول نمبر (479) ۽ غلام مرتضيٰ ميمڻ رول نمبر (2464) شامل آهن، جاچ ڪاميٽي رپورٽ ۾ ان سڄي فراڊ جو مک ڪردار سنڌ پبلڪ سروس ڪميشن جي ان وقت جي امتحانن واري ڪنٽرولر عمر زنئور ۽ چيئرمين محمد حسن ڀٽو کي قرار ڏنو آهي ۽ چيو آهي ته اهڙي فراڊ سان اداري جي ساک تمام خراب ٿي آهي ۽ اهو فراڊ شرم جهڙي ڳالهه آهي، ڪنٽرولر عمر زنئور سليڪٽيڊ اميدوارن جون جوابي ڪاپيون پاڻ ۽ ٻئي اسٽاف کان چيڪ ڪرايون، ڪاميٽي سفارش ڪئي آهي ته چٽا ڀيٽي واري امتحان ۾ شريڪ ٿيل سمورن 2555 اميدوارن جون جوابي ڪاپيون ۽ مارڪ شيٽون ٻيهر چيڪ ڪيون وڃن ۽ جعلسازي ۽ مارڪن ۾ هير ڦير ذريعي ڪامياب ٿيل ۽ سيٽون الاٽ ڪيل اميدوارن کي ناپاس ۽ نا اهل قرار ڏئي سندن نوڪريون ختم ڪيون وڃن ۽ حقي اميدوارن کي سيٽن جي ايلوڪيشن ڪئي وڃي، انهن کي نوڪريون ڏنيون وڃن، جڏهن ته ايڏو وڏو ڏوهه ڪندڙ عمر زنئور ۽ ٻين عملدارن خلاف نوڪري کان برطرفي واري قانون تحت ڪارروائي ڪري کين برطرف ڪيو وڃي، ٻئي طرف اينٽي ڪرپشن جي جاچ رپورٽ ۾ اهڙي فراڊ جي تصديق ڪندي چيو ويو آهي ته 54 من پسند اميدوارن کي جعلسازي ۽ فراڊ ذريعي پاس ڪيو ويو ۽ پاس ٿيل اميدوارن جون مارڪون گهٽائي کين فيل ڪيو ويو، جاچ رپورٽ ۾ اهڙي فراڊ ۾ سنڌ پبلڪ سروس ڪميشن جي ان وقت جي چيئرمين محمد حسن ڀٽو، امتحانن واري ڪنٽرولر محمد عمر زنئور، آفيس اسسٽنٽ فاروق نور خان، ايڊيشنل ڪنٽرولر اعجاز حسين جعفري کي قرار ڏنو ويو آهي، اينٽي ڪرپشن ڪاميٽي جاچ رپورٽ ۾ سفارش ڪئي آهي ته فراڊ ۾ ملوث آفيسرن خلاف سيڪشن 420، 465، 468، اي 471، 34 پي پي سي (لا ڊبليو) سيڪشن 5(2) اينٽي ڪرپشن ايڪٽ تحت ڪيس داخل ڪيو وڃي، جڏهن ته ان وقت جي سليڪشن ڪاميٽي جي چيئرمين اي بي سومرو، ميمبرن عبدالغفار جوڻيجو، ۽ ايڊمرل (ر) سيد باقر خلاف به ڪارروائي ڪري سندن نالا چالان جي ڪالم نمبر 2 ۾ ڳاڙهي مس سان وڌا وڃن،

__________________
Success…seems to be connected with action. Successful people keep moving. They make mistakes, but they don’t quit.

Though news shared is in Sindhi, discussion must be carried out in English language only.

__________________
The Me you have always known, the Me that's a stranger still.