@inayat, mubashir, phupoto

guys, would you please let me know that how many marks are of interview. In written part we had three papers of 300 marks. What about interview marks, ususally how they award us the score of interview. I mean there were two members, don't you think both members had seperate marks, like I have heard that chairman has 60 marks in his hand and the other member has 40 marks. If any of the members give you less then 33 percent marks and does not recommend you that means you are decleared failed. No matter how much good you are at written even you are at top highest marks but if any of the member does not recommend you that means you are doomed and failed straight away. I have heard such thins but I am almost not sure that whether these are based upon reality or rumours. Please let me know this thing and share your information.

Waiting for your detailed reply and thanks in anticipation
exclusively

I am adding another thing to ask you guys, look at the trend of ASI what I have observed everything is as under according to the qualification. They set a strategy to conduct the interview in 3 different categories:-

Category A
Masters Degrees' holders, interview is almost in English language only

If you introduce with master degree then you would have to answer the following questions:

1-Why do you want to join Police?
2-What do you say about terrorism and how would you tackle it?
3-How would you eliminate corruption and so on such debatable questions which have an analytic slandered?
Plus
1-Along with chairman an other old man who is set there to ask too much difficult questions which are most likely devised statistical and figarative questions e.g. dates, kilometers, establishments, world geography etc..
Apart from that chairman also ask gk questions which are comparatively easier than the old man member but not that much easier e.g 1st and second CM of sindh after the separation of Sindh from bombay. Constitutional pure LLB based questions.


Category B
Qualification: Graduation, and the interview would be in the Language: Mix Urdu, Sindhi. and hardly English; if you have are graduate then the questions are as under:

1-Chairman used to ask average questions e.g like PM, Presidents, Islamamiat, and nothing else special.
2-Then, the second old man of the film ask the questions which are comparatively easier than the category A. e.g He asks about in the same tendency like statistics and dates, facts and figures related to geo-politics of the world but not that high much difficult as he does for category A.==this is big discrimination!
After that, some times, he asks to write down the difficult spellings.

Category C
Qualification: Intermediate; if you are intermediate or having master degree but you mentioned intermediate then the interview would likely be halwa for you. The intermediate questions are as under:-

Language: Only urdu and sindhi no Eglish
Chairman ask very easy questions in sindhi/urdu like as under:-
1-Pakistan ka pehla sadar kon tha?
2-Sindh ka pehla CM kon tha?
3-Chach kya he?
4-Singapore ka capital kya he and many such easy capitals
5-Or ap apni marzi ka ek paragraph likhe essay ka? that's over. Bus kya baat hay!


Now, let's analyse the interview pattern:
A-If you are masters then you will face very difficult questions, especially the old man, the right side old man monster will likely eat you in asking difficult and stupid questions like we are deemed to be appreared in a quezz competition. Hence, your interview will give you really tough time and it gave me really tough time while I mentioned masters degree along with a prominent experience of job, it means I hit hard an ax on my on feet and fueled the fire while to tel the old man aa bhens mujhey marr ..


B-If you mentioned B.Com, B.A, Then, your interview would not be that much difficult and you would probably mange to sum up your viva smoothly..


C-If you mentioned Intermediate that means you are deemed lucky and they throw very very easy and silly questions. You will easily be able to answer all the questions correctly.


Now coming to the point?

1-Why one should mention his/her master degree and job experience? Agar inter batadia to muja e muja matlab ek b question miss nahi hoga!!

2-It means having higher degrees-the higher you fly the harder you fall???

3-However, if you are graduate or intermediate, then you are king and all in all to sum up your interview to the level of perfection with easy questions to answer.


Effections

If a candiage having master degree to face rubish questions and the candidate having intermediate mentioned on interview faces halva questions then why should one mention his/her master degree? Don't you think it is a BIG discrimination because they don't treat equally!

It is my personal opinion that, every body should be treated equal while interviewing, no one is above the cloud. Every body must get the opportunity on the basis of his/her own education background but questions should be asked what is on the basis of job and requirement. Because, if you are Phd, then they must not ask phd questions, as they are not going award us the another phd. Simply, the test is based upon intermediate then the questions should also be same as per the requirement and equal tendency should be devised.

In addition to this, I had seen many candidates on the gate of SPSC, waiting for the candidates to collect the questions because they or their kith and kinds were likely to take the interviews in the upcoming days. Thus, it can be said that spsc's role is antagonist here and not up to the mark to manage the equity and in transparent manner for every candidate.

80 percent questions were repeated, one of my friends collected a lot of questions and in the end he managed to answer the all of questions easily and correctly. I am not saying he did wrong, but I am saying their interview conducting and questioning repeatation shows that they are not competent including chairman who had read only sindh history and constitution.

Apart from that, personally, I did not like the way they were conducting the interviews, their way of analysing and selecting the candidates is not up to the mark. While panel was tired in the end of the candidates' interviews, they only ask two three questions and used to say bas beta ap jao because they were too much tired and were eager to go to home early. This is not good at all! They, don't care about the candidate who has been striving hard for the job for last three years.


Guys, now let me know what is their tactic to award the marks, do they consider master degree and experience reliable for the post as compare to intermediate. If they ask very easy and silly questions from the candidates of intermediate and unlike masters then don't you think it is a big discrimination? May be my assumption is wrong; may be they give more marks or recommend higher education for the post of ASI. I have no idea about that, hence, I will love to know about it, and if you know about the interview trend regarding marking and awarding according to qualification, job experience to a candidate for the job of ASI, then please share?

Thanks in anticipation

Dear Ghulam asghar phulpoto; These were only my views... dont you worry You are topper in ASI posts.... I request you to progress your studies and become CSS officer... Looking at your performance i am 100% sure you would easily be an ASP... I recommend you not to Join Sindh Police as ASI.... In future I am looking in you a PSP officer. Go for CSS Examination.....

Dear, Najam Vighio... Your Interview is also very impressive... I am sure you have qualified your Interview... hope for best... My best wishes are with you....

__________________
One has to remember that every failure can be a stepping stone towards something better.

dear,inyat your interview also went superb,you will also qualify,but as much i have observed you have no interest to join police as asi,,,,,lets see,what will happpen, i think cat will be out of box on monday

__________________
Success consists of going from failure to failure without loss of enthusiasm.” – Winston Churchill

it was last interview of Hyderabad range today, so guys you the candidates of Hyderabad range fasten your belts, result may announce any time.

__________________
Take risks. If you win, you will be happy. If you lose, you will be wise.

Thankx to all of my dear friends and and heartily pray for all of you to we will be together at training center for ASI.

__________________
"I always walk in the rain as No one can see my tears"

god will help those who are hard worker,may god will pass all of forum members,

dear mubshir,tomorrow is last day of hyd range interview,because now spsc has increased hyd range candidate which are 425,which is sheer injustice to call many candidate on merely 65 seats it is opposite of commission policy ,they should have kept good passing criteria in written rather than pass many candidate on merely passing marks ,spsc has also shorten the sukkar range seats ,which are 53,,initially,there were 63 seats for sukkar,,spsc has given full advantage to karachi candidate there are 148 seats for 460 boys,,spsc has updated today this new policy ,,,,

__________________
Success consists of going from failure to failure without loss of enthusiasm.” – Winston Churchill

o sorry i forgot total hyd range candidate are 435,last date of interview is 20 November ,,they have updated today in asi schedule ,the number of candidate are much larger

__________________
Success consists of going from failure to failure without loss of enthusiasm.” – Winston Churchill

yes saima you are right.

actually i have come to know that some of the candidates who were declared physically unfit have given chance to appear in interview, thats why the number of the candidates further increased. well lets see.

yes i saw it, actually i was wrongly informed thats why i shared above information, I apologize from all the forum members as I shared such wrong information.
regards.

__________________
Take risks. If you win, you will be happy. If you lose, you will be wise.

dear exclusively you have analysis the interview pattern very brilliantly, No doubt interview consists of 100 marks but i don't think so that they have divided marks into each other, agar aisa hota tou mere kch doston se sirf chairman ne interviews conduct kiye hen tou kiya ab un ko only 60 marks milenge? no way, in addition to this i only say that masters degree has nothing to do with chances of selection. get remember when you were calling for scrutiny of your documents by clerk at spsc head office on the day of interview there were only column of intermediate no further column was added there for higher studies. and i think passing marks of interview are 33 but it does not mean that if some one not giving correct answers in GK or in other education credentials then he/she will be failed, take a look on your own interview i mean you have been asked only 5-6 academics or Gk questions and you have answered 2 wrong so as per your information you are may be failed. as per my own assumption interview is not only about your academics ability or how you are powerful in English or in your recent qualification but actually its depend upon multiple choices, your personality your background etc. it was my first interview in spsc so may be i am wrong and i don't know actual selection criteria.
stay blessed


[QUOTE=inayatali;782200]Dear Ghulam asghar phulpoto; These were only my views... dont you worry You are topper in ASI posts.... I request you to progress your studies and become CSS officer... Looking at your performance i am 100% sure you would easily be an ASP... I recommend you not to Join Sindh Police as ASI.... In future I am looking in you a PSP officer. Go for CSS Examination.....

my pleasure bro, bus aik dafa police mein in hojaen phir CSS bhi karlenge, jaldi kiya hai yar.


does any body knows how many candidates are from sukkur range after this new info, and is it confirmed that we sukkur range has only 53 seats, i didn't see any such news on spsc website, what about srp?

__________________
"Among the signs of ignorance is arguing with irrational people" - Imam Hussain (AS)

about which information you were wrongly informed? regarding SRP seats? by the way what is the scene of merit. some one says there will be no merit whereas many others say there is only merit nothing else.

__________________
"Among the signs of ignorance is arguing with irrational people" - Imam Hussain (AS)