Both are extremes.
If we don't abuse him it does not mean we have sympathy for him.
Here abuse is not intended but having soft corner takes it to other extreme.

sorry,you are correct.

Hazrat Uzair(AS) was put to sleep for 100 years.It was Hazrat Idrees(AS).

__________________
Work until your idols become your rivals.

The Prophet Idris (peace be upon him) was taken alive to Heavens at the age of 365 years. Ibn Jarir relates in Rauzatul Ahbab that the Prophet Idris (peace be upon him) was the special friend of one of the angels of heaven. The angel took him up into the heavens and when they arrived in the fourth heaven, they met the Angel of Death. The angel questioned the Angel of Death how many years there were remaining of the life of the Prophet Idris (peace be upon him). The Angel of Death said: Where is Idris because I have been commanded to end his life. The Prophet Idris (peace be upon him) then remained in the fourth heaven and he died in the wings of his angel friend who had taken him from earth. Mutwaslah was one of his distinguished son who made his mark.

__________________
The Me you have always known, the Me that's a stranger still.

He is right! You can say that earth was one big mass before big bang. For when you say it had infinite density it means either it had infinite mass(a very big mass) or (almost)zero volume.
As Density=mass/volume, Density=infinity if and only if mass=infinity or volume=zero. If mass=0 and volume too=0 then density=undefined(indeterminate).

He is just a molvi, he is not supposed to teach us quantum mechanics. If he starts talking in terms of quarks and things like that no one will understand. By the way what's wrong with his statement? Did these atomic particles not ultimately join together to form stars and planets?

Of course Aristotle knew but how many of the lay men knew of that? If every one knew that, why did uncle Copernicus take pains to prove in 16th century that earth is round?

Only Aristotle knew of that!

10th grade student must also know that Zakir naik is not a nuclear scientist.

According to Zakir Naik, only Hazrat Isa (AS) was lifted to heaven and no other Prophet was lifted alive.
YES HE
is correct
bcoz As our holy Quran says
hr nafas ko mout ka zaiqa chakhna hy.
to Isa (AS) k elawa hr aik ki jaan nikali gahi hy
ur Idress ki b jaan nikal li gahi thi wo alag bat hy kh
He has gone to heaven with malahika.(will give hadith,if u demand)
2. Status of Prophet Isa (AS) will be of a Prophet but he will follow the Shariyah of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).

Your Zakir Naik says that Hazrat Isa (AS) will descend as a common man and He (AS) will not be a Prophet.
these are also correct

He will b under Imam mhdi.will pray salat behind Him.

__________________
always speak truth!

Un ki Jaan Aasmaon pe hi qabz ki gai thi. Zameen se wo hayat hi uthaye gaye thay.
You are mistaken. Baat Imam Mehdi ki nahi ho rahi. Sawal yeh hai keh Hazrat Isa AS ki hesiyat kya ho gee? Zakir Naik clearly said "He will not come as a Prophet". Jab ke baat khud Nabi Pak (SAW) ne fermai hai keh Hazrat Isa AS Nabi hon gay. Aap Zakir ki baton ko sahi sabit kernay ke liye us ki baat ko koi aur maani na pehnaein.

__________________
The Me you have always known, the Me that's a stranger still.

mam this discussion is going no where. you should close this thread as discussing religion without proper knowledge is very sensitive matter.
shaid discussion k doran kuch members kuch galt bol dain ya kuch ulta seedha bol dain aur gunah k murtkib hon... so it is my humble request to close this thread.

__________________
Success is never achieved by the size of our brain but it is always achieved by the quality of our thoughts.

koi ya nai kehta k Dr,ZAKIR NAIK jo kehta ha wo lafz-ba-lafz thek ha, wo hamari thara aik insan ha, be-shak un say ghalti hogi lekin is ka ya matlab nai k ham kahy k wo logo ko gumra kar raha ha. ap us k role ko deky, kitny log un k hatho mushaf-ba-islam huey ha. kitny log jo quran ka mazaq uraty thy un ki waja say ab mun tak nai kol sakty.

mery khyal ma to aj kal k material dor main ager koi islam ki khidmat k ley aik din b waqaf karta ha to hamy un ki dil-o-jan sa qadar karni chhey na k un k khilaf baty kary...

ap uny sunny jo bat un ki thek ho us ko ly jo thek nai usy na ly, aur jahan tak bat ha mislead karny ki to mery khyal ma koi kisi ko mislead nai kar sakta qk ya har insan ka faraz ha wo jo bat suny to us par amal karny aur dusro tak pohnchany sa pehly us bat ki tahqeeq kary. ham bazar ma ager 10 rupees ka aik jeez jab kharedthy ha to 5-6 shops ma us ki quality k bary ma tahqeeq karty ha to q na ham deen ki koi b bat 5-6 ulama sy confirm kary.

__________________
“Taleba Khawre ba Mula shai, Pa Kitab Porot ye Yadawai Shinki Khaluna”

The point you missed is that there is a difference between one big mass and infinite mass.

Sequence is wrong. By the way what is wrong with this statement that first he was born and then his father?

Albiruni ,born in 973 AD, estimated the diameter of Earth (his figure was very near to the correct one). And your uncle did not work to prove that earth is spherical but to prove that the sun is center around which earth and other planets revolve, the theory known as heliocentric theory.

You underestimate early civilizations.
In other words you say that he is just an MBBS doctor, he is not supposed to teach us what he is teaching....
Then why is he delivering lectures on this subject?

__________________
He who has a why to live can bear almost any how.

Munasib baat hay. Meray khayal main kisi kay gumrah honay ya na honay ka faisla hum nahi kar saktay chahay wo sunni ho wahabi ya Ahal Tashee. So I limited my discussion to his scientific mistakes and not religious viewpoint.

Bilkul wo Islam ki khidmat kar rahay hain. I appreciate his thesis that all religions have a common origin. But while he is working on finding similarities between religions, he says something which infuriates a sect of Islam. No doubt he is free to believe whatever he wants to but you know whatever you say publicly will be discuss publicy. No one asked him to curse Yazid but agar wo yazeed ko openly Razi Allah na kahtay or door az kaar Ahadith kay mafhoom say yeah sabit karnay ki koshish na kartay kay wo Ashra Mubashra ki saf main khara hay tu is say Zakir Naik pay koi azaab tu nahi aa jana tha. Unka personal aqeed jo bhi ho laikin unhain munafarat or firqa wariat nahi phailani chaheye.

Baqi rahi baat unki credibility ki tu I was once his fan and a regular listener, but when I had the oppertuinity to transcribe and edit his work my view was thoroughly changed. And I already explained why was it so.

__________________
He who has a why to live can bear almost any how.