You can't mix the issue of saraiki province with karachi soba and Hazara soba, there is a huge difference between them.
1-Saraiki soba is the demand of almost 7 crore saraiki people.. what is the population of muhajir and hazara??? merely in lacs.
2-There should be some sort of ample land for a place to be declared as a province.... what will be the area of Karachi and Hazara???
3-why people of Karachi need a province??? are they deprived of their rights??? its the most developed area in sindh my dear brother.

Right. Yes karachi is most developed area of sindh and here people should rather can not demand a separate province because here different kinds of people with different background lives there. We can not make mohajir suba because mahajir means refugees's suba. This does not make any sense, why we should make a seprate province for refugees?? Mohajir came in sindh and they should be called sindhi, because sindh gave them warm welcome and today they should not talk about it's division. Sindh's case is different unlike saraiki. People of Saraiki people are living there from hundreds of years and they have majority.

__________________
For me it is enough that I am different from others.

Momin bar bar aik jagah se dhoka kha hi nhi sakta (Hadith)

IF this lot of Politicians turn every city into a new province they will even fail miserably for their intentions are impure to gain political mileage.

Make everything digitized/computerized to administer well (Simple formula)

Regards,

__________________
When you try, you risk failure. When you don’t try, you ensure it.

In sindh which group is deprived of....?? In sindh Sindhi, urdu, Pakhtun and Punjabis are the members of the Sindh assembly. Almost all the parties are in government, ministers include sindhi, urdu, Pakhtun even non muslims. Perhaps sindh is the only open hearted province which has welcomed all the people coming all the way from Behar, Asam, Bugladesh, Burma, Nepal, Afghanistan, Punjab, KP, Gilgit, FATA, Balochistan. They entered here either legally or illegally but have become citizens and domiciled in sindh and getting jobs, Don't you think that this is unjustified act? Isn't it against the rights of the inhabitants of sindh? Inspite of that you'll find harmony among various ethnic groups.

The rural and urban phenomenon is need to be seen in the context that sindh is the most urbanized province of Pakistan and in sindh 60% population (mostly sindhi) lives in rural areas with limited educational facilities while 40% population (majority urdu + sindhi) lives in 3 cities (KHI, HYD, SUK) with almost all facilities. So that phenomenon was adopted to balance the ratio of all ethnic groups in all departments instead of any particular group.

__________________
Your attitude, not your aptitude, will determine your altitude...Zig Ziglar

@All

Look at the quoted post,this is thinking of people belonging to affected areas.Can we neglect such hue and cry?

Can you answer him?I don't know about the things he is referring so I'm unable to disagree.

__________________
Love is my Shield,Truth is my Sword,Brain is my Crown,Smile is my Treasure and I'm a Queen;
Quitters never win and Winners never quit..!!!

exactly there is no result to be seen except the political game

__________________
Wheat is Brilliant Gold

What is the strength of urdu speaking in Army & Bureaucracy? Go through the statistics then everything will be cleared.

Keep in mind dear that there are numerous people who migrated from india to punjab at the time of partition so this group is not limited to a mega city of pakistan Moreover why not the division of punjab is going on the basis of like Ruler & urban? if we take the major cities of punjab having all faculties as urban and rest ruler then what will be the situation it may be seems like punjab urban & punjab ruler.

What sort of harmony among the groups bubbling in your mind in the largest city of our beloved country , dont you think that ground realities are beyond your justification.

Feel free to comment on gilgit baltistan, its population along with its area.

Do you think that Developed area, ample land, population are the parameters to measure the rights of people residing in a particular area and are pre requisites to make the province? kindly justify your answer or it is written in the constitution of Pakistan?

I think one day when I will be playing cricket on the road A man next door will come outside his house and will say " Hey Its my Province you go to to hell"

Its not a simple issue as the discussion is going on here...Who says the Management will be Improved????
A person who is saying that and giving a length of arguments is either totally unaware of whats happening in departments of Pakistan..
You know why Management is a failure in this country???
A 16,17,18,19,20,21 etcetc..... Grade officers who is supposed to do work from 8 to 3 for 7 hours I can bet here If you carry out a survey the average working time will be from 2 to 3 hours...
This is the cause behind your poor managements not the lack of provinces...

Person who is talking about 2-3 fertilizer factories in his region...I want to say to him that My city Faisalabad has about minimum of 5 factories in one k.m of area...You can't even count in a day...Why shouldn't we make it the province after all it creates even more revenue then Lahore and probably the most neglected cities of all..(even by terrorists :-) )

Its absolutely right that Zardari wants the new province just and nothing else...Pass on..x

__________________
If I am what I have and if I lose what I have, who then am I?

This is change of topic, as you said that a group in sindh in deprived and I gave examples that no group is deprived in sindh, while army is federal issue and it has nothing to do with sindh, perhaps sindh has been deprived in higher army ranks, as from 42 only 1 general is sindhi, but its another issue, not related to this topic.


The division of rural and urban in sindh is the key factor which has kept balance between various ethnic groups and the ratio is maintained as per population in almost every walk of life, but as this division is not in practice in Punjab hence the people of southern Punjab feel that they have been deprived of their rights.

You should keep in mind history is evident that in Karachi sindhis are never involved in fighting. The fighting is going on between Urdu speaking two groups, Pakhtuns and Lyari gang war Balochs, and its to gain supremacy over karachi for land/drug mafia.

__________________
Your attitude, not your aptitude, will determine your altitude...Zig Ziglar

The man should come and ask you to play cricket in a "ground" as you block traffic on road.

If new provinces are not made then can you ascertain that management will improve?

"Whatever happening in Pakistan" should be handled or just not making new provinces will be the only solution?

Can you please answer why the British administration divided Bengal?


And people love Zardari to such an extent that they also started to demand new provinces ?

__________________
Love is my Shield,Truth is my Sword,Brain is my Crown,Smile is my Treasure and I'm a Queen;
Quitters never win and Winners never quit..!!!